- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Proxyboros repairs self-intersections in rigged animations by alternating mesh-space collision repair with rig-space fitting. Temporally parameterized pose corrections aim to preserve the original motion while maintaining compatibility with the input rig. Evaluation includes collision metrics, motion-preservation measures, ablations, and a user study.
Critical strengths
The paper demonstrates a useful collision–motion trade-off. Compared with ISIR, collision reduction is broadly comparable, while motion-direction distortion is substantially lower. This directly addresses a practical limitation of collision repair that alters the intended animation.
The alternating formulation has meaningful experimental support. Comparisons with one-shot repair followed by rig fitting, including matched iteration budgets, and temporal ablations provide evidence that the proposed workflow improves over straightforward sequential processing.
Critical weaknesses
The contribution is not fully separated from the temporal representation and regularization. A direct rig-space collision optimizer using the same spline parameterization, pose regularization, and comparable budget would be a stronger control. Without it, the necessity of alternating proxies remains partly unresolved.
Collision-metric robustness and cross-rig generalization need stronger evidence. PVR depends on semantic partitioning and voxelization, which can omit within-part intersections and introduce resolution sensitivity. This matters because its advantage over ISIR is only 0.40 percentage points, while IFR is slightly lower. Quantitative evidence on non-SMPL rigs is also limited.
Questions for authors
Does the method still outperform direct rig-space collision optimization when temporal parameterization, regularization, and computational budget are matched?
Are the conclusions stable across voxel resolutions and an independent collision measure that includes within-part intersections?
What are the quantitative collision and motion-preservation results for the non-SMPL characters?
We thank the reviewer for the positive feedback on the practical value of our work. Below, we respond to the main concerns.
Q1:
Performance over direct rig-space optimization. To further validate the effectiveness of PMRO, we introduce a variant that directly optimizes the mesh-space repair objective in rig space under a matched optimization budget, removing the progressive mesh–rig interaction while retaining the same temporal parameterization and pose regularization. The quantitative results are shown below.
Although direct rig-space optimization achieves higher collision reduction, it substantially degrades pose preservation and motion fidelity. This confirms the kinematic coupling issue illustrated in Figure 1 of the main paper, where local collision corrections induce excessive skeletal articulation and unintended motion changes. By progressively incorporating mesh-space repair guidance into rig-space optimization, PMRO achieves a substantially better balance between collision resolution and motion preservation.
Q2:
Voxel resolution sensitivity. We would like to clarify that voxel resolution affects the numerical estimation of PVR, rather than the repair results themselves. We re-evaluate all methods at different voxel resolutions, and the results are shown below.
At coarse resolutions, small residual penetrations may be missed by coarse voxelization, leading to higher PVR values.
However, our method consistently achieves the highest PVR across all resolutions. More importantly, its advantage over the other baselines remains stable at resolutions above 160, showing that our reported improvement does not depend on a favorable voxel resolution.
Within-part intersections. We clarify that within-part intersections are already included in our evaluation through IFR, which measures triangle-level intersections on the complete mesh independently of semantic partitioning. PVR instead measures volumetric penetration between body parts, where finer partitioning does not necessarily yield more accurate estimates. To examine this, we additionally evaluate PVR using a finer bone-level partition of SMPL-H with the same skinning-weight-based segmentation and surface capping procedure.
While all methods exhibit substantially lower PVR, ours remains the best. This decrease mainly arises from artificial overlaps near bone boundaries, where non-rigid skinning deformations cause adjacent capped segments to overlap without actual surface intersections. Our original 13-part partition avoids such artifacts while capturing major inter-part penetrations. Moreover, finger articulation remains fixed in the evaluated PoseShield sequences, supporting the grouping of each hand into a single part.
Q3:
Non-SMPL quantitative evaluation. We have added quantitative results on 30 non-SMPL animations from Objaverse and Truebone Zoo, covering diverse geometries and skeletal structures. As shown in Table 2 of the revised manuscript, our method achieves competitive repair quality with strong pose preservation and the best motion fidelity, further supporting its generalizability beyond SMPL-H.