- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces TRoPE, which constructs multi-scale topology-aware positional encodings to encourage appropriate motion sharing between topologically similar locations while distinguishing spatially close but structurally different locations, thereby reducing cross-part motion leakage and mitigating sticking artifacts.
Critical strengths
- The experimental evaluation is relatively thorough, with extensive ablation studies demonstrating TRoPE’s advantages in 4D generation over various positional encodings, including Euclidean Relative RoPE and topology-aware geodesic relative positional encoding.
- The motivation is clear. The paper identifies sticking artifacts as an existing problem, analyzes their causes, and mitigates them through topology-aware positional encoding. The motivation and experimental design are well aligned and reasonable.
Critical weaknesses
- TRoPE does not demonstrate a clear advantage over geodesic relative positional encoding. The ablation results show that geodesic relative positional encoding already substantially outperforms other encodings, as it is also topology-aware. However, the reported metrics do not indicate a substantial improvement of TRoPE over this alternative, and the paper lacks a discussion of why TRoPE would be preferable to geodesic relative positional encoding.
Questions for authors
- What is the computational cost of TRoPE compared with geodesic relative positional encoding and other positional encoding methods?
- Could the authors provide additional qualitative comparisons illustrating differences in 4D generation quality across different positional encoding methods?
- Could the authors provide insights into why TRoPE outperforms geodesic relative positional encoding, supported by experimental evidence?
Thanks for the clarification
Thank you for the detailed response and additional results. I have no further concerns and will maintain my positive rating.