- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposed HyperGCN-Vessel, a hybrid Euclidean–hyperbolic framework for topology-preserving vascular segmentation, motivated by the difficulty of SOTA methods in maintaining the connectivity of thin and distal vessels. The method combines an early transition from Euclidean features to the Poincaré ball with HyperConv, an efficient tangent-space convolution operator, and Topo-Gate, an uncertainty-aware differentiable regulariser designed to reduce vessel disconnections without explicit skeletonisation.
Critical strengths
Strong engineering work.
Critical weaknesses
-
The novelty is limited The paper introduces multiple concepts, including a hybrid Euclidean–hyperbolic architecture, HyperConv, Topo-Gate, Flow-Init, HCA, and ALM, most components appear to be simple adaptations or combinations of existing geometric learning, attention, and topology-aware techniques. The main contribution is therefore their integration for vessel segmentation rather than a fundamentally new learning mechanism with strong theoretical justification. There is no new key insights neither new analytical support.
-
The ablation study in Table 2 does not independently validate each component. Several rows change multiple factors simultaneously, making it difficult to attribute improvements to individual modules. For example, Euclidean backbone + Euclidean TG achieves a lower error than HyperGCN segmentation-only (63.10 vs. 64.70), so the results do not clearly demonstrate that hyperbolic representations outperform a simpler Euclidean topology regularizer. Moreover, removing HCA increases the error from 48.79 to 211.40 and the error from 7.40 to 100.30. This suggests either that HCA is the dominant component or that the training is unstable, neither of which is adequately discussed.
-
Table 1 is disconnected from the main scope of the paper. Table 1 reports results on two 2D retinal vessel datasets, DRIVE and CHASE_DB1, whereas the main paper focuses on 3D MRA vessel segmentation using Conv3D. The manuscript does not explain why these datasets are included, how the 3D architecture is adapted to 2D, what training and evaluation protocols are used, or whether the baselines are retrained. The results are also not discussed anywhere in the main text, making the table appear to be an experimental remnant that was not properly integrated into the paper.
-
Most of the citations are in the wrong format (\citet vs \citep)
-
The statistical analysis of significance is not included in all the empirical studies.
Questions for authors
What's the typical value of the curvature c after training?