- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces CoDE, a Coordinate and Density Encoder that combines atomic occupancy, experimental electron density, and density gradient magnitude on a shared voxel grid. A Channel-ViT is pretrained through joint masked reconstruction on PLINDER complexes. The frozen representations are then used for binding-affinity regression and pocket-conditioned ligand generation with VoxBind. The results show improvements over the matched coordinate-only encoder.
Critical strengths
-
The motivation is convincing. Experimental electron-density maps contain information that a single fitted structure does not fully capture, and the paper investigates whether this information can improve protein–ligand modeling.
-
The CoE baseline and channel ablations support the contribution of experimental electron density.
Critical weaknesses
-
My main concern is how far these results generalize beyond the PLINDER pretraining data. The authors exclude downstream validation and test entries by exact PDB ID, but complexes with different IDs may still have similar pockets, or ligands. These similarities are not reported. It remains unclear whether density also helps on complexes with few close neighbors in the pretraining set.
-
The chemical interpretation of the improvements remains limited. It is unclear which binding-site features are better represented with electron density and why this improves affinity predictions. A few representative examples linking density features, binding interactions, and prediction changes would make the explanation more convincing.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors report nearest-neighbor similarities between the test and pretraining sets for pockets and ligands separately? With the existing model, does CoDE still improve over CoE and other baseline on low-similarity subsets?
-
For binding-affinity regression, could the authors analyze a few representative complexes where electron density clearly helps, linking the relevant electron density features and specific binding interactions to changes in model predictions? This would help explain the chemical basis of the improvement beyond the aggregate metrics.
3 comments
Thank you for your response
Dear Authors,
Thank you for your response and the additional experiments. They address most of my concerns.
One point remains: the pre-training status of BindNet in Table 13 differs from what is reported in your response to my review. Please verify which designation is correct and update the table or response accordingly.
The experiments provide a convincing answer to the paper’s central research question, and I am therefore raising my score.
Best regards.
Dear reviewer RiUR, We are happy to hear that the additional experiments have addressed most of your concerns.
Regarding the pre-training status of BindNet in the response, the entry should be ✓, as shown in Table 13 of the revised paper. We have updated the table in our response and noted it in dark green.
Thank you again
We thank the reviewer for the comments on generalization and chemical interpretation, and address both below with new analyses. We highlight additional content and modifications in the revised paper in dark green.
[W1, Q1] Generalization under pocket or ligand similarity
In Appendix F.2 we report nearest-neighbor similarity to the pre-training corpus for pockets and ligands separately: sequence identity with BLAST+ [1] following ATOM3D [2], and ligand ECFP4 Tanimoto. While the ligand similarity is low, many test proteins have a close sequence neighbor. Stratifying the test set leaves too few complexes per bin, so we instead removed every protein at or above 30% identity to a CL3 test protein from the corpus (nearly 12%) and the downstream train split.
We additionally checked the new pre-training corpus with PLINDER’s pocket-lDDT clusters [3, 4], which come from Foldseek alignment rather than sequence. As a result, the fraction of test complexes whose nearest pre-training neighbor has pocket-lDDT ≥ 95 decreased from 67.9% to 0.5%.
We report the sequence similarity-filtered results in Table 13, where most models drop in performance. Nonetheless, the ordering is preserved, and CoDE stays competitive and improves over CoE. Models marked with ‡ are pre-trained on a corpus we cannot filter and contain proteins sequence-similar to CL3 test proteins, reported for context.
[1] BLAST+: architecture and applications, BMC Bioinformatics 2009
[2] ATOM3D: Tasks On Molecules in Three Dimensions, NeurIPS 2021
[3] PLINDER: The protein-ligand interactions dataset and evaluation resource, bioRxiv 2024
[4] lDDT: a local superposition-free score for comparing protein structures and models using distance difference tests, Bioinformatics 2013
[W2, Q2] Representative examples linking density, interaction, and prediction changes
We have added representative examples in Appendix F.3, linking density features and binding interactions to changes in prediction for binding-affinity regression. We selected complexes with the largest reduction in the absolute error from CoE to CoDE, computed the protein-ligand interactions with ProLIF [1], and examined what each model receives as input at those interaction sites. At the interaction sites identified by ProLIF, the experimental map carries density in the region between the interacting groups, where the atom-blob channels fall off. CoE receives only the atom-centered channels and therefore has little input in that region.
[1] ProLIF: a library to encode molecular interactions as fingerprints, Journal of Cheminformatics 2021