- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces SADock, a surface-aware diffusion framework for blind protein-ligand docking. Motivated by the observation that globally distinct receptors share similar local interaction geometry and chemistry. Extending DiffDock, SADock combines surface representations with residue- and atom-level features via hierarchical message passing and time-conditioned modulation. The paper reports strong docking performance on PDBBind and DockGen, with further analysis pointing to improved pocket localization as the key driver of these gains.
Critical strengths
This paper tackles a key bottleneck with a clear and well-reasoned hypothesis. The observation that global receptor dissimilarity does not imply a novel interaction interface provides a solid motivation for surface-aware blind docking.
The empirical claims are supported by a strong set of complementary experiments.
Critical weaknesses
The experiments do not yet fully isolate the proposed representation-level explanation. Introducing the surface branch also brings in extra geometric and physicochemical descriptors, more computational pathways, and potentially higher model capacity.
While the ablation study confirms that the surface-augmented system is useful, it doesn't quite distinguish whether the gains come from organizing information on molecular surfaces or simply from feeding the model richer inputs.
While the theoretical analysis aligns with this interpretation, it relies on energy-perturbation and model-sensitivity assumptions that haven't quite been verified for the evaluated receptors.
A few reporting and implementation details need clarification to make the core results fully interpretable. For instance, Figure 3 is described as using the five highest-confidence candidates, meaning its RMSD success rate at 2 Å should match the corresponding Top-5 result in Table 1 under the same configuration. However, the plotted value appears noticeably lower, so these numbers should be reconciled.
The construction and updating of ligand surface geometry and descriptors as torsions change could use a clearer operational description, especially since this mechanism sits right at the heart of the proposed representation.
Questions for authors
Could you reconcile the data between Figure 3 and Table 1? Given that Figure 3 uses the top-five confidence candidates, its RMSD success rate at 2 Å should match the corresponding Top-5 figures in Table 1. Clarifying whether the exact same checkpoints, candidate budgets, and aggregation rules were used would clear up any apparent discrepancies.
How are ligand surface points, normals, geodesic neighborhoods, and physicochemical descriptors handled when torsional changes happen during training and inference?
Are the Euclidean-only and surface-augmented models truly comparable in terms of capacity and underlying chemical information?
Section 3.1 refers to results on 428 PoseBusters complexes, but those numbers didn't seem to show up in the current manuscript. Could you point us to where they are or correct the statement?
2 comments
Response to Reviewer zqJG: W3, W4/Q1, W5/Q2 & Q4 — Theoretical Assumptions, Reporting Consistency, Ligand Surfaces, and PoseBusters
W3: Empirical validation of theoretical assumptions.
Thanks for this constructive comment. We agree that our theoretical analysis establishes sufficient conditions for transferability. To further substantiate the underlying assumptions, we conducted two additional analyses.
(1) Physical-level assessment (Eq. 7). We performed 50 geometric perturbations on each of 20 DockGen complexes, obtaining 989 valid comparisons of Lennard–Jones and Coulomb interaction energies under fixed ligand configurations. We calibrated per-complex empirical bounds with at least 90% coverage:
yielding and kcal/mol. These results quantitatively characterize the relationship between surface discrepancy and interaction-energy variations, providing an initial empirical assessment of Eq. 7. See implementation details in Reply W2-1 to Reviewer W4gW.
(2) Model-level stability (Eq. 8). On 300 PDBBind complexes, we quantified the Euclidean residual sensitivity under controlled perturbations while keeping surface inputs fixed. At t=1, perturbations of 0.01/0.1 Å produce only 0.55%/1.84% relative score variations, with sensitivity increasing as denoising progresses (Pearson r=0.91 with (1-t)). This supports the intended reduced Euclidean sensitivity during early pocket localization.
Together, these results provide empirical evidence for the physical and model-level stability assumptions underlying our theoretical formulation, while the theoretical guarantees remain conditional on the stated assumptions. We have incorporated these analyses and clarified their scope in the revised manuscript.
W4 & Q1: Consistency between Figure 3 and Table 1.
Thanks for pointing out this inconsistency. Table 1 used the EMA checkpoint (SADock-400K-EMA), whereas Figure 3 mistakenly used its non-EMA counterpart (SADock-400K). We have corrected Figure 3 to ensure consistency with Table 1.
W5 & Q2: Dynamic ligand surface construction during denoising.
During training and inference, the ligand surface is reconstructed using NanoShaper after each conformational update, before the next score evaluation. Surface points, normals, areas, geodesic neighborhoods, and atom–surface connections are updated accordingly. Atomic chemical attributes remain unchanged and are incorporated into surface representations through Hetero-MP; no separate surface hydrophobicity or electrostatic descriptors are used. Ligand surface generation and graph construction take only ~20 ms per update, and CPU preprocessing can overlap with GPU inference of other batches, limiting the additional overhead.
Q4: Missing PoseBusters results.
Thanks for pointing out this omission. We have supplemented the evaluation on all 428 PoseBusters complexes, using 40 candidates per target.
Table R18: PoseBusters results.
| Method | Oracle | Top1 | Top5 |
|---|---|---|---|
| DiffDock | 51.40 | 35.51 | 44.63 |
| DiffDock-L | 61.92 | 50.93 | 56.07 |
| SADock | 64.49 | 42.52 | 56.07 |
| SADock-L | 75.47 | 53.50 | 66.59 |
Notably, SADock-L outperforms DiffDock-L across all three metrics, improving Oracle, Top-1, and Top-5 success by 13.55%, 2.57%, and 10.52% (absolute), respectively. We have added these results to the revised manuscript.
Response to Reviewer zqJG: W1/Q3 & W2 — Controlled Model Capacity, Surface Geometry, and Hierarchical Modeling
We thank the reviewer for recognizing that SADock “tackles a key bottleneck with a clear and well-reasoned hypothesis” and that our empirical claims are supported by “a strong set of complementary experiments.” We address your concerns point by point below.
W1 & Q3: Representation-level contribution and controlled model capacity.
Thanks for raising this important concern. We would like to clarify that molecular surfaces are derived from the same molecular coordinates and chemical identities used by Euclidean representations, without introducing additional external information. By explicitly organizing geometry and physicochemical properties around the molecular boundary, surface representations provide an interaction-aligned inductive bias that facilitates transferable pocket localization under structural distribution shift.
Regarding model capacity, we deliberately match SADock/SADock-L (~20M/30M parameters) with DiffDock/DiffDock-L, respectively. More importantly, our Euclidean-only ablation is retrained with the same atom/residue inputs, training data, optimization budget, and parameter count (~20M) as SADock, rather than using the released DiffDock checkpoint.
Under these controlled settings, introducing surface representations improves DockGen Top-5 success from 15.3% to 28.6% and oracle success from 16.4% to 36.5%. Further component ablations confirm the contributions of geodesic encoding and surface–Euclidean interactions. These results support the benefits of surface-aligned representation learning beyond increased model capacity or additional molecular information.
W2: Contribution of surface geometry and hierarchical modeling.
To distinguish the benefits of surface representation learning from simply introducing richer descriptors, we conducted finer-grained component ablations, using the same pretrained DiffDock confidence model for consistent ranking.
(1) Hierarchical surface modeling. While retaining the same surface descriptors, removing F2C/C2F reduces DockGen Oracle success from 36.5% to 32.3%, demonstrating the benefit of hierarchical surface communication.
(2) Intrinsic surface geometry. Replacing geodesic distances with Euclidean distances further reduces Oracle success to 30.7, highlighting the importance of modeling intrinsic surface geometry beyond conventional Euclidean proximity.
These results demonstrate that SADock's improvements depend not only on richer surface descriptors, but also on how interaction-relevant information is geometrically organized and propagated. We have incorporated these ablations into the revised manuscript.
Table R17: Component ablation results.