- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2(+1)
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PairSense, a framework that uses pair representations from the Boltz-2 trunk for binding affinity and CYP substrate. In addition, the distrogram is used both for pocket cropping and as a probability-weighted input to the affinity module. With the Boltz-2 trunk kept frozen and only the affinity module fine-tuned, PairSense is validated on binding affinity benchmarks and three TDC CYP substrate tasks.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
1. Missing comparison with the baselines
The binding affinity comparison in Figure 2 considers FEP+4, OpenFE876, and CASP16, but is missing conventional baselines reported in concurrent works, such as physics-based baselines (FEP+, ABFE, OpenFE) and recent models such as Nesso-1 (open source) and IsoDDE. Without these baselines, the claim of the highest correlation is not supported. Nesso-1 should be compared directly, given its released code and weights; for the closed-source IsoDDE, a discussion would be sufficient.
Jang et al. (2026), cited in the paper and the source of its ligand-only trunk control, evaluates Boltz-2 representations on the same TDC tasks under the official splits. While Table 2 includes MiniMol, I cannot see Jang et al.’s results on CYP substrates. This leaves the main CYP claim insufficiently supported.
2. Overstatement of ADMET in the title for three CYP substrate tasks
While the title and introduction present the work as ADMET prediction, the evaluation only covers three CYP substrate tasks. The authors note that they have considered eight protein-related TDC tasks and excluded five because of conformer generation failure. However, three small tasks do not support an ADMET-level claim, and therefore I think the title should be changed to protein-mediated metabolism rather than ADMET.
Questions for authors
1. CYP tasks without conformer generation failing cases
Could the authors present the results on the test data with conformer generation failing cases excluded? Though excluding them would break comparability with the official TDC leaderboard, comparison with models including MiniMol and FP2048 on the reduced test split would provide insight on the proposed method, informative for more than three CYP substrate tasks.