- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies time-conditioned prediction of diffusive processes: given a current image and an arbitrary target time, the goal is to generate the future observation. It proposes Diffusive Grid, which treats the denoising axis of a diffusion model and the physical time axis as a two-dimensional grid of noisy latent states. In addition to the conditional Denoiser, an Evolver network predicts transitions along time at a fixed noise level. Dynamics Alignment Learning (DAL) aligns the Evolver's prediction of a grid node with the Denoiser's prediction of the same node from a higher noise level, and Grid Walk (GW) supervises the endpoints of multiple paths that alternate between temporal evolution and DDIM denoising. On Scalarflow and Duke DCE-MRI, the method reports better frame-level fidelity and lower temporal (tRMSE) and drift (dRMSE) errors than DDPM, OU-noise, STCL, and Dynamical Diffusion.
Critical strengths
- Discontinuity and directional inconsistency are real failure modes of generators that produce each target time independently, and the paper separates them clearly with dedicated metrics.
- Coupling a learned temporal transition model with the denoising process at multiple noise levels is an intuitive idea, and the method retains direct target-time generation at inference.
Critical weaknesses
-
The connection to physical diffusion is largely nominal, and the novelty relative to existing time–noise modeling is unclear. The grid is motivated by an analogy between the "diffusive dynamics" of denoising and real diffusive processes, but the forward noising process of a diffusion model is unrelated to the physical transport being modeled, and the method uses no physical structure such as a diffusion equation, mass conservation, or an explicit directionality constraint. The method is therefore best viewed as a generic regularizer for time-conditioned image prediction. From this perspective, existing methods such as Diffusion Forcing, Rolling Diffusion, FIFO-Diffusion, and AR-Diffusion already vary noise levels or denoising schedules across sequence positions. DYffusion also connects its generative steps to the physical time of the underlying dynamics.
-
The mechanism by which the training-time grid improves inference is not established. At inference, the model generates each target time separately using only the Denoiser. The paper should clarify whether the same initial Gaussian noise is reused across target times and whether this protocol is consistent across methods, since noise coupling can affect tRMSE and dRMSE. The straight path in GW uses only the Evolver at noise level 0 and cannot directly affect the inference-time Denoiser, consistent with this, the Straight Path row in Table 5 is identical to the +DAL row in Table 1, which contradicts the claim that the two path types provide complementary benefits. Finally, Table 4 shows that rolling out the Evolver on the initial noise substantially improves results on DCE-MRI, but this procedure is not used at inference and the reason is not discussed.
Questions for authors
- Is the initial noise shared across target times at inference, and is the same protocol used for all methods?
- Why is the Straight Path result in Table 5 identical to the +DAL result in Table 1, given that the straight path does not involve the Denoiser?
- Why is the Evolver rollout in Table 4 not used at inference, given its large improvements?
- Can the authors compare with Diffusion Forcing and/or DYffusion, and clarify which parts of the method are specific to diffusive processes?
Thank you for the thorough response and the additional experiments. The clarifications on the inference protocol, the patient-level evaluation with paired tests, the training cost and the DyDiff adaptation address my questions on those points.
However, I am inclined to keep my score. I find that the new results narrow the paper's central claims more than they support them. The clean-state-only control recovers most of the gain (SSIM 0.817 against 0.828 and tRMSE 0.155 against 0.150 for full DAL, within the reported standard deviations), so the benefit of aligning across noise levels remains weakly supported. Also under matched compute, DAL alone outperforms DAL+GW on four of five metrics, while GW raises the per-step cost. Finally, DYffusion and Diffusion Forcing obtain lower tRMSE on both datasets and lower dRMSE on DCE-MRI, which does not support the claim of better continuity and consistency.