- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents an interesting solution to the problem of uneven camera positions in 3DGS, but it addresses a very specific setting. The main idea is to estimate and refine the camera angles while reconstructing the object, constraining all camera movements to a physically consistent turntable rotation. This is based on the observation that viewing a rotating object is equivalent to moving a camera around a stationary object.
Critical strengths
- Comprehensive experiments
Critical weaknesses
- The method assumes a circular camera path with unequal angular gaps, rather than varying distances from the rotation axis. It is unclear how useful this specific setting is in practice. The method also requires foreground masks, known camera intrinsics, and ordered images.
- VGGT already estimates camera poses without assuming equal angular spacing. Please clarify whether the main difficulty arises from irregular angular spacing itself, errors in sparse-view pose estimation, or converting VGGT-estimated poses into a shared turntable model. Reporting pose errors before circle fitting, after fitting, and after refinement would help distinguish these effects.
- Refining camera angles can be detrimental when the initial angles are already accurate. The paper reports a dB decrease in this experiment, which is consistent with overfitting.
Questions for authors
Please see weaknesses above.