- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Event4D extends PAGE-4D with a recurrent event encoder, staleness-conditioned feature fusion, and event-to-camera attention. It trains on synthetic and real event datasets and evaluates depth and camera pose across five datasets. The depth results are strong under several challenging conditions, including reduced RGB frame rates.
Critical strengths
- Events can provide useful motion information between RGB captures, particularly in fast motion and low light.
- Explicitly encoding RGB staleness is a sensible way to handle repeated or delayed images.
- The paper tests multiple datasets and conditions, with useful ablations for input modalities, the event encoder, losses, and staleness conditioning.
Critical weaknesses
- The RGB-only results in Table 4 match the PAGE-4D baseline in Table 1, while Event4D is trained on seven datasets with additional losses. A same-data, same-training RGB-only baseline is needed to determine how much improvement comes from events and fusion.
- The frame-rate experiments evaluate repeated RGB inputs, but the paper does not say whether training includes stale frames or nonzero staleness values. Please report the training schedule and the staleness distribution; these details are necessary to interpret the F/2–F/8 results.
- Event4D has higher ATE than PAGE-4D on N-Sintel (0.225 vs. 0.179) and MVSEC (0.552 vs. 0.298). The pose table also omits EAG3R, a relevant event-based 4D method with reported MVSEC nighttime pose results EAG3R. These regressions and the baseline choice need discussion.
- The quantitative results report depth and pose, but not point-map accuracy, global 3D reconstruction quality, or temporal consistency. The point-map evidence is qualitative.
- Synthetic events are generated from videos interpolated with SuperSloMo before applying v2e. Since temporal performance is a central claim, a comparison across real-event and synthetic-event training, or an analysis of sensitivity to this simulation pipeline, would strengthen the evidence.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the concerns raised in the Weaknesses section.