1. Insufficient editing quality in qualitative results.
In Table 1, ER-Chord achieves a better background preservation metric compared to other baselines, but as seen in Figure 4, the background often does not remain preserved. For instance, the 1st row “colorful roses” case, FlowEdit and InfEdit relatively well preserve the spilled paint background than ER-Chord. In the 1st case of Figure 5 (brown cat → white cat), Direct Inversion + PnP preserves background wood, but ER-Chord not. Also in the 3rd case of Figure 5 (gray smoke → red-orange flames), ER-Chord add to unexpected building shadows in the background. Similary, In the 4rd case of Figure 5, ER-Chord shows red artifacts in the sky while others not. Also, the images in Figure 4, 5, and 6 are not cut to fit the grid and are shifted slightly. PIE-Bench's image resolution is 512 × 512 pixels, but the image quality of Figure 5 feels lower than that. This suggests that insufficient effort was made, such as not creating and reviewing the figure, or that AI was used. The quantitative performance improvement, which is not convincing given these qualitative results, sharply contrasts with the paper's claims and arouses skepticism among reviewers.
2. Insufficient justification for endpoint consistency as a measure of editing reliability.
The proposed method defines a local endpoint-consistency score in Eq. (2) based on the relative disagreement between editing fields at neighboring noise levels. The authors interpret this score as a reliability signal for spatially redistributing editing strength. However, temporal consistency does not necessarily imply semantic correctness or correspondence with the intended editing regions. For example, two endpoint fields may consistently predict an incorrect editing direction in a background region, resulting in a high consistency score. But regions requiring substantial semantic changes may exhibit greater endpoint disagreement and consequently receive lower consistency scores.
This issue becomes particularly important when considering the spatial multiplier defined in Eq. (4):
uER(p)=mpuC(p),mp=ap+η∗1.
Since the multiplier is not restricted to values below one, the proposed redistribution can amplify editing strength in regions with high endpoint consistency, even when the original editing direction is incorrect. For instance, consider a simplified two-location example with an intended editing region A and an unedited background region B, where both have the same original Chord magnitude. Suppose A exhibits substantial endpoint disagreement (cA=0.125), whereas B has perfectly consistent but semantically incorrect editing fields (cB=1). Under the paper's configuration (μ=0.25), the equal-energy solution yields approximately mA=0.902 and mB=1.090. The editing magnitude in the intended region is reduced by approximately 9.8%, while the incorrect background modification is amplified by approximately 9.0%, despite the total energy being preserved. Although this is a hypothetical example rather than an observed failure case, it illustrates that the proposed formulation does not inherently distinguish reliable editing from consistently incorrect predictions. The experiments do not directly establish whether the endpoint-consistency scores in Eq. (2) correlate with actual editing correctness, particularly whether high-scoring regions correspond to correctly predicted edits.
3. Limited theoretical justification for preserving the stability properties of ChordEdit.
Although the authors establish the existence and uniqueness of the global minimizer for the proposed equal-energy optimization in Eq. (3), this theoretical guarantee does not necessarily imply improved editing quality or preservation of the stability properties established in the original ChordEdit framework. ChordEdit motivates its temporally aggregated control field through a numerical stability analysis based on the consistency proxy in Eq. (4.6) of the original paper, which depends on both the temporal derivative and the state-space Jacobian of the editing field. However, ER-Chord introduces spatially varying multipliers, uER(p)=mpuC(p), as defined in Eq. (4). Since these multipliers can exceed one and depend on the underlying field estimates, the redistribution introduces additional derivative terms that are not explicitly controlled by the proposed optimization. Preserving the total Frobenius energy does not guarantee that the original numerical stability bounds remain valid. While the empirical results demonstrate consistent improvements, it remains ambiguous whether the spatially varying multipliers preserve the stability conditions analyzed in ChordEdit.