- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
FRESCO presents a conditional flow matching model that generates multi-channel single-cell images from a treatment's gene expression and a same-batch control image. Images and expression come from different cells and are paired only by treatment. Expression is given as an average over a random subset of the treatment's sequenced cells and encoded as transcriptional-program tokens. The flow model transforms noise into a simulated treated cell image, conditioned on program tokens and on the control "anchor" image. It uses a pretrained variational autoencoder for image encoding and a channel-factorized transformer (MM-DiT) backbone. The authors also introduce perturbation-specific metrics: response cosine, medcos and top-1 retrieval. The paper reports results on five datasets. Three of them are image-only (JUMP, RxRx1 and BBBC021), where the model is conditioned on perturbation embeddings instead of expression: Morgan fingerprints, Gene2Vec embeddings and HyenaDNA representations. On these, the method outperforms CellFlux and IMPA in FID and KID. The main results are on the two datasets with sequencing data, scGeneScope and OPS Explorer. The model shows better results than MorphDiff, CellFlux and MultiVCDiff, including on 56 held-out (out-of-distribution) genes: top-1 25.9% vs 11.1% for the strongest baseline.
Critical strengths
Group-level conditioning makes sense and is well motivated. It avoids artificial cell-to-cell pairing between imaging and sequencing.
On the three image-only benchmarks, FRESCO achieves better FID and KID than CellFlux. On BBBC021 it also improves mode-of-action (MoA) accuracy, for both seen and held-out compounds.
Code has been released (anonymously).
Critical weaknesses
The main concern is the held-out generalization. It is the key result, but it rests on one dataset, 56 genes and a single seed, with no confidence intervals. Held-out genes could have transcriptionally similar genes in training, yet there is no simple kNN baseline. The authors also do not discuss what drives the generalization, or the batch structure of the sequencing data.
CellFluxMM: Multimodal Generative Modeling of Perturbation-Induced Cellular Responses (ML4H 2025) is not cited. It is a CellFlux-based flow matching model on treatment-matched expression and Cell Painting data. Given this work and MorphDiff, the claim “we formulate expression-conditioned morphology generation for treatment-matched datasets” might overstate the novelty.
Cross-channel attention seems to give the largest gain, but it is evaluated only with FID. The model size behind each table is not stated, so the FID gains over CellFlux may partly come from a larger model.
Questions for authors
Overall, I find the paper interesting, particularly the group-level conditioning and the results on held-out genes are promising. Still, several points need clarification before I can support acceptance:
- Can the authors show that the held-out results are driven by expression and not by batch information from sequencing path? How does FRESCO compare with a simple kNN baseline that uses the most transcriptionally similar seen gene?
- How does FRESCO relate to CellFluxMM, and how does it differ?
- Which model size was used for each table? Can the authors report the cross-channel ablation with the conditioning metrics (top-1, medcos)?
- Can the authors comment on why one-hot conditioning performs significantly better than the expression embedding on seen genes (Table 3: top-1 52.0% vs 30.0%)?
- Did the authors try dropping out one control image during training?
4 comments
Nearest-neighbour baseline and cluster-held-out evaluation (Q1b)
We agree that a nearest-neighbour baseline is needed to assess how much the held-out results depend on similar training genes. For each held-out gene, the baseline selects the training gene with the most similar average expression using cosine similarity and returns its real training images. We score these against the same references as FRESCO.
Original split. FRESCO and the lookup achieve similar point estimates. The paired intervals include zero for all three metrics, establishing neither an advantage nor equivalent performance.
| OPS held-out, 54 genes | top-1 | medcos | cos(e,d) |
|---|---|---|---|
| FRESCO | 25.9% | 0.573 | 0.682 |
| kNN-1 lookup, pseudobulk cosine | 25.9% | 0.582 | 0.636 |
| FRESCO − lookup [95% CI] | 0.0 pts [−12.7, +12.7] | −0.009 [−0.118, +0.089] | +0.046 [−0.130, +0.209] |
Cluster-held-out split. To test transfer beyond shared transcriptional clusters, we retrained FRESCO with six entire clusters withheld (123 genes; 122 eligible for evaluation). No test gene shares a cluster with a training gene, although similar genes may remain in other clusters. Expression preprocessing includes held-out genes’ expression; their treated images are excluded from generator training.
On this split, FRESCO achieves higher medcos and cos(e,d) than the lookup, with no detected top-1 advantage. We also retrained MorphDiff and Jones et al. (2026) on this split. FRESCO has the highest point estimates on all three metrics, tying Jones et al. on top-1.
| OPS cluster-held-out, 122 genes | top-1 | medcos | cos(e,d) |
|---|---|---|---|
| FRESCO | 4.1% | 0.371 | 0.403 |
| kNN-1 lookup, pseudobulk cosine | 3.3% | 0.237 | 0.251 |
| FRESCO − lookup [95% CI] | +0.8 pts [−2.5, +4.1] | +0.135 [+0.009, +0.266] | +0.151 [+0.012, +0.286] |
| MorphDiff, retrained on this split | 1.6% | 0.126 | 0.227 |
| Jones et al. (2026), retrained on this split | 4.1% | 0.255 | 0.306 |
Intervals are from 10,000 paired gene-bootstrap samples. We will include both splits and the kNN baseline in the revision.
Prior work, model sizes and cross-channel attention (Q2–Q3)
Q2 / W2. Relation to CellFluxMM.
We agree that our formulation claim should acknowledge this prior work more clearly. We will cite CellFluxMM alongside MorphDiff and MultiVCDiff and narrow the claim accordingly. CellFluxMM jointly generates perturbed images and population-level L1000 expression. It starts from controls and processes the concatenated image and expression latents. FRESCO generates multi-channel single-cell images conditioned on resampled scRNA-seq summaries. It uses the control image as context, starts the flow from noise, and has explicit spatial and cross-channel attention.
We will replace the sentence the reviewer quotes with: “We study expression-conditioned single-cell morphology generation under treatment-level pairing, building on MorphDiff, MultiVCDiff and CellFluxMM.”
Q3a / W3. Model size.
The OPS and scGeneScope results in Table 1 use FRESCO’s 8-layer S model. The corresponding model sizes are shown below. Counts refer to trainable generative-network parameters; frozen pretrained autoencoders are excluded, and trained autoencoders are listed separately.
| Model | Model size (OPS / scGeneScope) | Trained autoencoder size (OPS / scGeneScope) |
|---|---|---|
| FRESCO | 56.8M / 56.8M | none |
| CellFlux | 56.7M / 56.7M | none |
| MultiVCDiff | 61.7M / 61.8M | none |
| MorphDiff | 378.5M / 378.5M | 55.3M / 55.3M |
Q3b / W3. Cross-channel ablation with conditioning metrics.
We retrained FRESCO without cross-channel blocks on both transcriptomic datasets, keeping the total block count fixed. Guidance was chosen as for FRESCO, and evaluation used the same samples:
| OPS held-out (FID / top-1 / medcos) | OPS seen | scGS round 1 | scGS round 2 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FRESCO | 3.28 / 25.9% / 0.57 | 2.79 / 30.0% / 0.63 | 11.76 / 32.1% / 0.48 | 9.40 / 37.0% / 0.55 |
| no cross-channel | 12.65 / 16.7% / 0.39 | 12.25 / 18.0% / 0.52 | 86.53 / 17.9% / 0.37 | 77.24 / 40.7% / 0.50 |
The point estimates favour cross-channel attention on all three metrics for OPS and scGeneScope round 1, and on FID and medcos for round 2. Round-2 top-1 is higher without it (40.7% versus 37.0%, a difference of one compound out of 27). The ablation therefore measures more than FID. However, image quality also changes substantially, so it does not separate better conditioning from better image quality. We will include these results in the revision.
One-hot conditioning and control-image dropout (Q4–Q5)
Q4. Why one-hot beats expression on seen genes (52.0% vs 30.0%).
A one-hot label gives a fixed, unambiguous identity for a perturbation already seen during training, allowing the model to learn its associated morphology directly. An expression summary varies with the cells sampled and may overlap with those of other perturbations. The model must therefore infer perturbation-specific morphology from a variable input, which may make exact-identity retrieval harder. The comparison also uses different backbones, so it does not isolate the effect of conditioning alone.
Q5. Dropping out the control image during training.
We did not use control-image dropout in the reported runs. We trained a separate model with no control image at all. This shows whether the control helps, but not whether occasional dropout would make the model more robust when the control is missing or uninformative.
That model shows the control helps. Removing it worsens FID and retrieval in both scGeneScope rounds (round 1: FID 15.35 versus 11.76, top-1 28.6% versus 32.1%; round 2: 12.29 versus 9.40, 22.2% versus 37.0%). On held-out OPS genes, top-1 drops from 25.9% to 20.4% and medcos is similar (0.56 versus 0.57), while FID is slightly lower without the control (3.10 versus 3.28). In the intended use, a control image from the target plate is always available, so we did not optimise for a missing control.
We thank the reviewer for these questions and would be glad to discuss any of the results further.
Held-out generalisation: uncertainty and expression controls (W1, Q1a)
We thank the reviewer for the questions about generalisation and conditioning. The new analyses support higher held-out top-1 and medcos than the evaluated MorphDiff run, and the expression controls argue against a batch-only explanation. Compared with nearest-neighbour image transfer, FRESCO has similar scores on the original split and higher response-direction agreement when whole clusters are held out. We also clarify the relation to CellFluxMM, report model sizes and cross-channel conditioning metrics, and address the one-hot comparison and control-image dropout.
W1. Held-out uncertainty and training seeds.
We resampled the 54 eligible genes with replacement 10,000 times, using the same sampled genes for both methods and keeping the retrieval candidates and references fixed. The table reports 95% percentile intervals:
Across three independent FRESCO training runs, held-out top-1 is 25.9%, 27.8% and 20.4% (mean ± s.d.: 24.7 ± 3.9%), each above the evaluated MorphDiff run (11.1%). All runs use the same evaluation samples and guidance weight, selected on seed 0. The gene-bootstrap intervals quantify variation across query genes for fixed outputs; the three runs separately assess FRESCO’s training variability.
OPS remains the only transcriptome–morphology dataset here that tests held-out perturbations. scGeneScope holds out acquisition replicates; BBBC021 tests held-out compounds with the identity-conditioned model. We will make these different evaluation settings clear in the revision.
Q1a / W1. Expression or sequencing batch?
OPS: each perturbation’s cells are spread across the 32 sequencing libraries in nearly the same proportions. Library composition alone retrieves the perturbation near chance (2.6% versus 1.8%). Giving FRESCO the wrong gene’s expression reduces top-1 to 1.9–5.6% (chance 1.9%). The wrong gene has a similar library mix to the correct one. Together, these checks argue against library composition alone explaining retrieval, but do not exclude all technical variation in the expression input.
scGeneScope: round-1 test sequencing batches differ from training, whereas round 2 shares batches. Expression still distinguishes compounds within a round-2 batch (54.8% versus 12.9% chance). We also tested four combinations: expression from the correct or a shuffled compound, each taken from the same or the other sequencing round. The two rounds have separate batches and different compound groupings:
Expression from the correct compound still gives positive response alignment when it comes from the other round. Shuffling the compound reduces alignment to near zero (chance top-1: 3.6% / 3.7%). This supports a compound-related signal that transfers across rounds.