- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
ActFlow predicts single-cell perturbation responses by jointly learning expression and activation-mask velocity fields within a shared DiT backbone. The masks preserve cell-specific nonzero expression patterns, with positive values replaced by perturbation–gene medians computed from training data. Training combines expression and mask velocity losses with MMD regularization. At inference, both trajectories evolve jointly, while only the expression output is retained. Experiments on Norman and ComboSciPlex demonstrate competitive performance, particularly on distributional metrics.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses an important problem and explores a useful approach to modeling sparse single-cell expression data.
- Evaluation covers both genetic and drug perturbations, using complementary metrics for mean reconstruction, perturbation effects, distributional agreement, and differentially expressed genes.
- Improvements on distributional metrics are substantial. Four random splits and condition-level significance tests on Norman provide additional support for the reported results.
Critical weaknesses
W1. Insufficient comparison with directly related methods.
Conditional flow matching and MMD have already been used in scDFM, while mask-based modeling of sparse single-cell expression has been explored in Doloris. The contribution requiring validation is therefore the shared-backbone joint generation of expression and masks, together with the proposed mask construction.
Although the paper discusses Doloris and Departures, neither is included in the experimental comparison. These methods directly address the sparsity problem motivating ActFlow. Their omission makes it difficult to establish the advantages of the proposed joint-generation design over existing masking approaches. The current results demonstrate improvements over the selected baselines but do not fully establish the additional value of the central design.
W2. The connection between the stated problem and the proposed mechanism lacks direct evidence.
The paper largely motivates its approach through the high proportion of zero-expression entries, arguing that these entries dominate training and obscure informative perturbation signals. However, under its flow-matching formulation, the target velocity for an entry with is , rather than zero. The frequency of zero-expression entries alone therefore does not establish that they dominate the velocity-regression loss or parameter gradients. Direct analysis of their optimization contributions is needed.
Table 3 shows meaningful improvements in distributional metrics from the mask branch, but the ablation covers only one additive split, leaving the robustness of this effect insufficiently established. Analyzing whether the mask trajectory recovers reliable structure earlier during generation would also help explain the value of joint evolution.
Furthermore, indicates detected expression, not necessarily perturbation-induced activation. Constitutively expressed genes can be nonzero, and perturbation responses also include downregulation and silencing. The paper should distinguish expression-detection modeling from perturbation-induced activation modeling and moderate its biological interpretation accordingly.
W3. Missing task-specific simple baselines.
In the Norman additive setting, the constituent single-gene perturbations of each test combination are observed during training. An explicit additive baseline is therefore applicable: This comparison would directly test whether ActFlow improves upon adding known single-gene effects. A training-set perturbed-mean baseline would also help assess whether improvements in mean reconstruction and perturbation-effect metrics depend on condition-specific predictions. The importance of such simple baselines is supported by Ahlmann-Eltze et al. (2025).
Although the paper includes a bilinear Linear baseline, it does not sufficiently explain whether its representations and prediction structure cover the explicit additive formulation. The authors should clarify this equivalence or report the additional baseline. Comparisons on distributional metrics should also distinguish deterministic mean predictions from generated cell populations.
Questions for authors
Q1 Related methods. How does ActFlow compare with Doloris and Departures under the same data splits and evaluation protocol? What advantages does the shared-backbone joint-generation design offer over their approaches to modeling sparse expression?
Q2 Motivation and mechanism. Can the authors quantify the contributions of zero- and nonzero-expression entries to the velocity-regression loss and parameter gradients? Does this analysis support the claim that zero-expression entries dominate optimization?
Q3 Robustness and trajectory behavior. Do the improvements from the mask branch persist across additional random splits? Is there evidence that the mask trajectory recovers reliable activation structure earlier than the expression trajectory, thereby providing useful guidance during generation?
Q4 Biological interpretation. Since measures detected expression rather than perturbation-induced activation, what evidence supports interpreting the learned masks as perturbation-specific activation signals rather than general expression patterns?
Q5 Simple baselines. Does the bilinear Linear baseline cover the explicit prediction ? If not, how does ActFlow compare with this additive baseline on Norman’s additive setting, and with a training-set perturbed-mean baseline on mean reconstruction and perturbation-effect metrics?