- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper addresses the problem of learning generative Bayesian priors over physical field conditioned on text. Two approaches are considered for the learning and are compared on differing physical datasets. Incorporation of text into the priors is observed to improve the reconstruction accuracy.
Critical strengths
- The paper soundly implements two standard approaches: i) autoenconder and ii) score-based diffusion models.
- Rigorous testing and reporting of inference on three differing datasets.
Critical weaknesses
- The theorems, corollary, and lemma, are not new results and do constitute a theoretical advancement. Rather these are standard results applied to a block-triangular map.
- It it not clear what the real novelty is here. Introducing text at inference time is not a new idea and has been applied in other datasets as the authors note (e.g. imaging).
Questions for authors
- Theorems 2.3 and 2.3 bound the joint W_2, but it seems the claims of the paper should really be about the conditionals. A small joint error does not necessarily imply a small conditional error. What statements and bounds can be made on the conditional error?
- Does the application of this problem of learning text-conditioned Bayesian priors require differing considerations when applied to physical fields, or can it be applied to other datasets? Another way of saying this is, what is special about the physical fields for the methodology described here.
- On a related note, it seems that PDEs are used a proxy for physical systems, and these terms are seemingly used interchangeably in the text. What are the considerations for non-PDE physical systems?
2 comments
Thank you for the response to the raised questions. Unfortunately, the technical weakness and question have not been addressed by the authors. I will keep the score as is.
We thank the reviewer for their time and for the questions raised, and we will use some of the points to improve our work in future revisions.
Q1: We thank the reviewer for raising this question, and we will clarify this point in future revisions to our work.
Q2: This framework can be applied to other fields with paired data and text. However, our focus is on inverse problems in physical systems, which differ from inverse problems in imaging: observations are often a handful of point sensors rather than dense measurements, and calibrated UQ is essential for downstream decision-making.
Q3: Our method does not use the governing equations, and the prior is learned purely from data, so it applies to any physical system, including systems described by ODEs and PDEs, or no known governing equations at all (eg: reanalysis data in UK weather experiment).