- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
CURVO treats prediction horizons as operator coordinates and learns interval-average responses, allowing one-pass joint prediction of multiple future PDE states with inference-time temporal resolution. The architecture combines a multiscale spatial–horizon U-Net, spectral horizon mixing, physical-coordinate attention, and shared interval-conditioned refinement. Experiments cover five PDE configurations and a CIFAR-10 extension.
Critical strengths
1.Original and well-motivated formulation: avoids sequential rollout and independent per-horizon prediction.
2.Architecture is coherent; cross-horizon coupling and variable-cardinality attention are technically sound.
3.Strong main results on several PDE families; good generalization to unseen query cardinalities, placements, and off-grid horizons.
4.Competitive memory and latency at larger query cardinalities.
Critical weaknesses
1.Limited experimental scope: mainly 64×64 2D PDEs. No 3D, irregular meshes, real-world scientific data, or long-horizon/chaotic extrapolation.
2.Theory is narrow: Proposition 1 covers linear dissipative modes; nonlinear response families lack theoretical guarantees.
3.Baseline comparison is incomplete: AR-FNO2D outperforms CURVO on both Navier–Stokes settings. Latency/FLOPs comparisons are selective and not reported across all datasets.
4.No statistical rigor: appears single-seed; no confidence intervals or variance.
Questions for authors
1.Multi-seed results: Are Table 1 results single-seed? Please report mean±std over ≥3 seeds for the main PDE benchmarks. Small ranking differences, especially vs. AR-FNO2D and U-NO, are otherwise not reliable.
2.Navier–Stokes claim: AR-FNO2D outperforms CURVO on both NS settings. What is the precise claim—accuracy, latency, memory, or compute-matched trade-off? This directly affects the “best sequential” comparison.
3.Ablation clarity: Table 3 is garbled. Please provide a clean table with exact definitions and full settings for horizon coupling, latent refinement, and joint vs. independent prediction.
4.Scope/generality: Are there any 3D, irregular-mesh, or real-world scientific datasets? If not, please state that the claim is limited to 2D regular-grid PDEs.
We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment and appreciate the recognition of our formulation, which avoids both sequential rollout and independent per-horizon prediction, the soundness of the cross-horizon coupling and variable-cardinality attention, and the generalization to unseen query sets and horizons. Below we address the experimental scope, the theory, the comparison with AR-FNO2D, the multi-seed results and the ablation table, supported by the new Tables R1 and R2.
W1 & Q4. We thank the reviewer for this suggestion and agree that these settings would broaden the evaluation. This work focuses on the temporal side of the problem: we chose 2D benchmarks ranging from viscous decay to strongly nonlinear evolution (Table 1) and tested generalization to unseen query sets (Fig. 5, Table 10), off-grid horizons (Table 2), readouts of up to 100 states (Table 8) and a higher spatial resolution (Table 15). Sec. 5 already notes that CURVO predicts within the trained horizon window. Extending it to 3D domains, irregular meshes and real-world data mainly concerns the spatial operator and the data, and we will further discuss these directions in Sec. 5 as future work.
W2. We thank the reviewer for this comment. Linear dissipative dynamics are a special case of the nonlinear systems we study. They arise whenever the nonlinear terms vanish and, to leading order, for small perturbations of a steady state, where each spatial mode evolves at its own wavenumber-dependent rate [2]. For example, the Taylor–Green vortex is an exact solution of the 2D Navier–Stokes equations whose vorticity decays purely linearly [1]. Proposition 1 shows that even in this special case no fixed temporal basis shared by all spatial scales represents the interval responses exactly. As a necessity result, it therefore extends to every nonlinear family that contains this case, which motivates coupling horizons within each spatial scale in CURVO. We will make this argument explicit in Sec. 3.2.
W3 & Q2. We thank the reviewer for this observation. Figure 1 shows two datasets for space reasons, and the revised appendix will report accuracy, latency and parameter count for all methods and datasets. With three seeds (Table R1), AR-FNO2D is more accurate only on NS ν=10−3, where CURVO halves its latency (62 vs.\ 120 ms). On SWE, Gray–Scott and Active Matter, CURVO is both more accurate and 1.6–3.9× faster, with 4.9M parameters versus 16–31M for U-Net, U-NO and MeanFlow. Our claim is thus higher accuracy at lower latency with fewer parameters on most systems, which we will make explicit in the Discussion.
W4 & Q1. We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. Table 1 was single-seed. Within the rebuttal period, we have retrained CURVO and most baselines with seeds 42, 123 and 2024 and report mean ± std in Table R1; the remaining baselines will follow in the revision, where we will update Table 1 accordingly.
Q3. We thank the reviewer for pointing this out. Table R2 gives a clean ablation, scored on the full trajectory as in Table 1, with its settings stated in the caption. Coupling denotes the horizon interaction Hℓ,h of Eq. (5), without which each horizon is predicted independently, and refinement denotes the shared interval-conditioned cell Cψ of Eq. (9). We will replace Table 3 with this table.
We thank the reviewer again for the constructive comments. The multi-seed results, the clarified claim on Navier–Stokes, the clean ablation table and the explicit scope aim to make the evaluation more rigorous, and we would be glad to address any remaining questions.
[1] G. I. Taylor and A. E. Green. Mechanism of the production of small eddies from large ones. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A, 158(895):499–521, 1937. [2] M. C. Cross and P. C. Hohenberg. Pattern formation outside of equilibrium. Reviews of Modern Physics, 65(3):851–1112, 1993.