- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PhiCast, a continuous lead-time weather forecasting framework designed to generate predictions at arbitrary future horizons from a single encoded atmospheric state. The method consists of three main components: (1) a continuous time encoding module that combines Fourier-based temporal features with state-dependent FiLM conditioning; (2) a solver-free finite-time flow that integrates multiscale spectral and convolutional operations to directly map the initial latent representation to a queried future state without numerical integration or autoregressive rollout; and (3) composition-aware learning objectives that encourage consistency between direct and temporally decomposed latent transitions and forecasts.
The authors evaluate PhiCast on WeatherBench using four atmospheric variables—2-meter temperature, 10-meter zonal and meridional winds, and 500-hPa geopotential—at a spatial resolution of 5.625°. The model is trained with supervision at four lead times (6, 12, 18, and 24 hours) and evaluated at all integer-hour lead times from 1 to 24 hours. Experiments against seven baselines, including ClimODE, ClimaX, WeatherGFT, FNO, and SFNO, show that PhiCast achieves the best average RMSE and ACC across all four variables at the 20 lead times without direct forecast supervision. Additional experiments examine temporal composition consistency, component ablations, inference efficiency, and zero-shot transfer to a finer spatial resolution of 2.8125°.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses a practically relevant problem of forecasting at flexible lead times, enabling direct predictions at lead times without explicit training supervision, which offers some practical value in real-world forecasting scenarios.
Critical weaknesses
We believe that this paper has many issues and it is difficult to solve them through rebuttal:
1. Limited Methodological Novelty.: PhiCast utilizes mature technologies, mainly including Fourier Neural Operators (FNO, FourCastNet) for spatial modeling, FiLM conditioning (FiLM, ClimaX, WeatherGFT, Stormer) and identity-preserving mappings and semigroup consistency regularization (Deep-OSG). Even its composition-aware objectives largely rely on existing consistency constraints and conventional forecasting losses. Overall, the framework appears to be an integration of existing methods rather than a fundamentally novel approach, with insufficient evidence demonstrating the necessity or unique contribution of their combination.
2. Outdated and Insufficient Baseline Comparisons. :The experimental comparisons are limited to methods published in or before 2024, omitting several important weather forecasting models, including FourCastNet, Pangu-Weather, Stormer, ARROW, and traditional methods like IFS. Moreover, most baselines are reimplemented or retrained under modified experimental settings rather than evaluated using their official pretrained checkpoints. These omissions and modifications raise substantial concerns about the fairness and representativeness of the comparisons, making the reported performance improvements less convincing.
3. Limited Experimental Settings.:The experiments are limited to a coarse spatial resolution of 5.625°, only four atmospheric variables, and a 24-hour forecasting horizon, which fall short of modern weather forecasting standards. Such settings offer limited practical value and fail to convincingly demonstrate the benefits of forecasting at lead times without direct supervision.
4. Questionable Lead-Time Sensitivity.: Figure 11 raises a serious concern that predictions across different lead times appear nearly identical, suggesting that the model may primarily produce similar atmospheric states regardless of the requested horizon. The increasing forecasting error with lead time does not necessarily demonstrate meaningful temporal modeling, as even a fixed prediction could exhibit this pattern. The authors should evaluate prediction differences across lead times for the same historical input, compare against persistence baselines, and conduct cross-horizon substitution tests (e.g., evaluating a 1-hour prediction against 6-, 12-, and 24-hour targets) to verify whether the model genuinely learns lead-time-dependent atmospheric evolution.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses.
The authors should standardize the font styles, sizes, and text formatting across Figure 3 and the subsequent code-generated figures to improve visual consistency and overall presentation quality.