- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies the mismatch between nominal control parameters and their actual effects in generative models, with a focus on reference control under incremental commitment. It analyzes how commitment timing affects control responses and proposes a post-hoc calibration approach based on isotonic regression. Experiments examine several image, motion, and video generators, showing improved calibration for some models while also identifying cases where calibration is less effective.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses a practical and meaningful problem: a linear change in a control parameter does not necessarily produce a proportional change in the generated output. The analysis of incremental commitment provides a useful perspective on this issue.
- The empirical study covers multiple generators and control configurations. The authors also report and analyze negative results, which helps clarify the limitations of the proposed calibration approach.
Critical weaknesses
- Although the paper provides a useful analysis of reference control under incremental commitment, its calibration approach shares a similar motivation with prior work such as FreeSliders. The distinction from existing nonlinear control reparameterization methods could be clarified. Moreover, the theoretical analysis relies on simplified assumptions, and a direct quantitative comparison between its predictions and the responses of real generators is not provided. The main figures could also better emphasize the key findings beyond conceptual illustrations.
- The abstract discusses five generators, but systematic quantitative calibration experiments are conducted on only three. A fitted linear calibration baseline would help clarify the benefit of isotonic regression. In addition, the submitted PDF does not support text selection or searching, and the repeatedly referenced appendices are neither included in the PDF nor available as supplementary files, making several experimental and theoretical details difficult to verify.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the weaknesses above. Could the authors clarify the novelty of their calibration approach relative to FreeSliders, quantitatively validate Eq. (4), and include a fitted linear calibration baseline? Please also provide the missing appendices and a searchable PDF.
2 comments
Thank you for the response and the revised manuscript. However, I have serious concerns about the unusually extensive revisions. The changes are not limited to correcting the missing appendices or improving presentation. Large portions of the abstract, introduction, method, experimental discussion, and even the limitations section have been rewritten, with substantial changes to figures and tables as well. The revisions appear to affect nearly every major section of the paper, making it difficult to regard the revised manuscript as a straightforward clarification of the original submission.
More importantly, my main technical concerns remain unresolved. The authors acknowledge that Eq. (4) has not been quantitatively validated on real generators and that a fitted linear calibration baseline has not been evaluated. The response primarily narrows or clarifies the claims rather than providing the evidence needed to address these concerns.
I also expect the authors to take full responsibility for the accuracy and quality of their submitted work, as stated in their AI Use Statement.
Thank you for recognizing the practical control problem and the value of reporting negative results. We have clarified the relation to FreeSliders and the scope of each experiment. FreeSliders detects and remaps concept-slider traversal ranges; our study examines reference-duration controls whose response depends on the order in which sampler states become fixed. We use standard isotonic regression as the calibration procedure and focus on commitment-order effects, the shared effect scale, and held-out transfer. We do not claim a new isotonic algorithm or superiority over FreeSliders.
The independent-token derivation is exact under its stated fixed-time assumptions, and Monte Carlo validates that identity for the synthetic sampler. The real-model experiments intervene on commitment order and measure resulting response widths. They support the claim that order can change response concentration, but they do not quantitatively fit Equation (4) to neural outputs. We have made this distinction explicit in the revised manuscript.
Five generators appear in the comparative control study; prospective calibration is evaluated on three masked models. We now state that split directly in the abstract and experiment description. The fitted affine calibration baseline has not been evaluated. Our quantitative calibration claim is therefore limited to the comparison between frozen isotonic selection and native α=β selection; these results do not establish an isotonic advantage over a linear map.
The revised PDF now contains Appendices A–H and searchable text. The first-stage omission was ours, and we recognize that the missing material prevented verification in the version you received.