- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a method to leverage the scores given by process reward models (PRM) to guide the decoding process of a discrete diffusion language model. The authors propose three different methods. “PRM repair” scores complete generations and regenerates from the first step whose score is below a threshold. “PRM-distilled repair” follows the same logic but uses a distilled value head to resample mid-generation if scores fall below a threshold. Finally, “step-issue guidance” uses a step-issue head to define a decoding policy that favors decoding positions that would lead to higher PRM scores. Both the value head and the step-issue head are trained to predict PRM scores, but the value predicts scores for the entire sequence (average of four rollouts) and step-issue head predicts scores per token position. The methods were tests on two reasoning datasets GSM8K and MATH500, improving over the baseline LLaDA model with no guidance.
Critical strengths
- All three proposed methods improve over the baseline in all cases, which suggests the PRM scores are used effectively and the distilled head is capable of capturing at least some of the behavior of the original PRM.
- The simplicity of the methods is a strength, as it facilitates their application by practitioners. Moreover, each of the methods represent different trade-offs between computational cost and accuracy, which might be interesting for downstream applications.
Critical weaknesses
- The proposed guidance interventions, albeit interesting, are not yet well motivated. They are based on thresholding predicted scores or on additive changes to the decoding priority, neither of which is sufficiently justified in the text. This is in contrast to much of the test-time guidance literature, which similarly estimates value functions but derives their guidance from KL-regularized reinforcement learning instead (see references below). The guidance interventions proposed in this paper might have merit and be a valid addition to the literature, but it is hard to gauge that since these prior works are not discussed or evaluated in the paper.
- Following on the previous point, the related work does not discuss prior work on aforementioned score-guided inference methods for autoregressive [1, 2, 3] and diffusion [4, 5, 6] models, as well as learned unmasking policies [7].
- The experiments are limited.
- The only baseline seems to be standard LLaDA and no other guidance method is considered. For instance, SVDD [5] is a relevant baseline to PRM repair, while step-issue guidance is essentially an unmasking policy and [7] could be a relevant baseline.
- The only use case considered is math reasoning with a single model and PRM scorer. While this might be sufficient to demonstrate the proposed methods, I do not feel confident the gains would be easily translated to other domains because of the guidance interventions are not well motivated and rely on heuristics like resampling from the first digit in the generation.
- Unless I missed it in the text, experiments cover a single seed. For instance, the gains of PRM-distilled repair over the baseline on MATH500 might not be statistically significant (Table 1), and random scores seem to outperform the baseline on GSM8K (Table 2).
- Some parts of the text are quite hard to follow. The inference paragraphs for both PRM-distilled repair and step-issue guidance are particularly confusing.
Minor issues
- At the top of page 2, there is a box that feels out of place. What is the purpose of this example? If it is useful, it should be better integrated into the text, with a caption.
- The sentence “This inconsistency motivates guidance; the final output alone does not identify which commitment decisions caused it.” also feels out of place. What inconsistency is the text referring to here?
References
[1] Yang, Kevin, and Dan Klein. "FUDGE: Controlled text generation with future discriminators." Proceedings of the 2021 Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies. 2021.
[2] Han, Seungwook, et al. "Value augmented sampling for language model alignment and personalization." arXiv preprint arXiv:2405.06639 (2024).
[3] Zhao, Stephen, et al. "Probabilistic inference in language models via twisted sequential monte carlo." arXiv preprint arXiv:2404.17546 (2024).
[4] Uehara, Masatoshi, et al. "Inference-time alignment in diffusion models with reward-guided generation: Tutorial and review." arXiv preprint arXiv:2501.09685 (2025).
[5] Li, Xiner, et al. "Derivative-free guidance in continuous and discrete diffusion models with soft value-based decoding." arXiv preprint arXiv:2408.08252 (2024).
[6] Singhal, Raghav, et al. "A general framework for inference-time scaling and steering of diffusion models." arXiv preprint arXiv:2501.06848 (2025).
[7] Jazbec, Metod, et al. "Learning unmasking policies for diffusion language models." arXiv preprint arXiv:2512.09106 (2025).
Questions for authors
- The distilled value head tries to map incomplete generation to the scores the PRM assigns to complete generations. This essentially learns a proper value function in the reinforcement learning sense [8]. Thus, one possible principled guidance objective is to maximize expected PRM reward while penalizing KL divergence from a specified reference completion distribution. This has a closed form solution as a tilted distribution that favors higher-scoring completions [4, 5]. Why not derive guidance from this objective? What advantages or practical constraints motivate that choice?
- The value function is trained with samples from two specific policies, one greedy and another stochastic. However, these policies do not account for the guidance intervention. That is, after the first intervention, the value function might not be a faithful representation of the expected score, since the test time sampling policy is different from the one used at training time. Have the authors considered that issue?
- There is a large gap in performance between PRM repair and the two other methods that use distilled heads. Could the authors comment on what is the primary cause for this? Is it the difference in performance between distilled head and original PRM or is it the different decoding policy induced by value and step-issue heads?
References
[8] Mudgal, Sidharth, et al. "Controlled decoding from language models." arXiv preprint arXiv:2310.17022 (2023).
3 comments
Why does direct PRM repair outperform the distilled methods?
The gap reflects methods with materially different information and computation budgets, so matching the full PRM is not the claim required for the lightweight guidance contribution. The current comparison does not isolate one cause. Direct PRM repair scores completed reasoning and regenerates from the first low-scoring step. Distilled repair uses a scalar prediction at a partially masked state and candidate-mask probes to choose a digit-bearing boundary. Guidance uses token-level predictions to change the original decoding trajectory without regeneration. Scorer quality, available information, boundary selection, intervention timing, and computation therefore differ together.
On GSM8K, direct PRM repair, distilled repair, and guidance reach 63.53%, 48.07%, and 53.90%, respectively; on MATH-500 they reach 29.8%, 24.8%, and 25.8%. These observations support an empirical quality/cost trade-off within the tested methods. They do not establish whether teacher approximation error or the different intervention policy is primarily responsible for the gap. The digit-based boundary heuristic belongs to the distilled-repair baseline; it is not required by the primary step-issue guidance method.
Random controls and useful learned scores
Random scores do improve GSM8K from 44.73% to 46.70% in the reported run, so arbitrary changes to commitment order can affect accuracy favorably. Learned scores reach 53.90%, exceeding the random control by 7.20 percentage points; shuffled learned scores reach 44.66%. On MATH-500, random and shuffled scores reach 21.2% and 20.8%, versus 25.8% for learned scores and 24.0% for baseline. The learned-score advantage over both random and shuffled controls is evidence that the trained assignments contain useful information beyond the particular arbitrary perturbations tested. The controls do not establish that every gain is attributable solely to precise error localization.
The controls have limits. Shuffling occurs over the full prompt-plus-canvas sequence, and the implementation's control labeled “confidence” uses a hidden-norm proxy rather than token confidence. We identify it as a hidden-norm control in the manuscript. These details limit the mechanistic interpretation, and we do not claim that the controls establish significance across independent seeds.
Computational motivation and the scope of timing evidence
The primary guidance method uses an approximately 1.1M-parameter head, updates its predictions every 16 steps, and requires no PRM inference or separate regeneration. In the recorded 100-example GSM8K timing run, baseline and guidance each use 6,400 backbone calls. Guidance adds 400 issue-head calls; total times are 564.56 and 566.85 seconds, a 2.29-second increase, approximately 0.41%. Distilled repair takes 697.73 seconds and direct PRM repair 762.41 seconds in that timing run.
This is direct evidence for small observed guidance overhead under that configuration. It is a single timing run on a subset, and we do not claim that 0.4% is a statistically resolved or hardware-independent overhead. The 100-example runtime experiment is distinct from the full-benchmark accuracy evaluations.
Thank you for responding to my comments and questions.
Overall, the ideas of the paper have merit, but at the current stage, the proposed methods are still not presented in a convincing manner. As I see it, two main problems remain. One pertains to evaluation. While it is not necessarily a problem to rely on heuristics, the lack of a rigorous theoretical motivation would have to be compensated by an extensive empirical evaluation, which the current version of the paper does not provide. A larger number of datasets, models, baselines and random seeds would be required to support the main claims of the paper. The other issue is the presentation. The text is unnecessarily hard to follow, and the methods are not well motivated in the context of the broader guidance literature.
Response to Reviews
Why use the proposed intervention instead of KL-derived guidance?
The intervention is chosen to act on the decoder decision that determines which positions receive further context before commitment: using a lightweight predictor from frozen hidden states to decide which masked positions to commit later. It reuses the current backbone pass and leaves its token probabilities at that state intact. This directly targets commitment order while avoiding PRM evaluation and regeneration for the guidance method. The recorded computation figures below support the feasibility of that design.
We agree that the additive priority rule and repair thresholds are heuristic. We do not derive them as the optimizer of a KL-regularized reward objective. The scalar head predicts a PRM-derived reward proxy under the synthetic-fill procedure used for supervision; this is not automatically the expected return of the actual guided continuation policy. A KL-based objective is a principled alternative, but showing that our particular intervention implements its optimal transitions would require a derivation we do not provide. Our contribution is the supervision mapping and practical commitment-order mechanism, not an optimality result.
Relevant prior work and missing baselines
The reviewer is right that the contribution should be situated more clearly within future-aware prediction, value-guided diffusion inference, and learned unmasking policies. FUDGE uses partial-sequence attribute predictions to adjust autoregressive generation probabilities. SVDD uses soft values for reward-guided diffusion inference. Learning Unmasking Policies for Diffusion Language Models learns unmasking decisions through reinforcement learning. Our method instead learns from completed-step PRM scores projected onto masked canvas tokens and uses those predictions to change commitment priority with a frozen backbone.
The contribution lies in the PRM-to-masked-canvas supervision and the resulting inexpensive commitment policy. It does not require claiming that value-based guidance or learned unmasking itself is new. These distinctions position the method, while empirical superiority over those alternatives remains unestablished. We have not evaluated SVDD or the cited learned unmasking policy and therefore cannot claim an advantage over them. The existing experiments compare the proposed mechanism with unguided decoding, direct PRM repair, distilled repair, and score controls. We acknowledge that a broader comparative evaluation remains a limitation.
Distribution shift after guidance
The concern correctly identifies a limit of the scalar value proxy, but it is useful to distinguish that repair baseline from the primary token-level guidance method. The issue head supplies a learned ordering score; its operation does not require that a scalar head equal the expected return under the deployed policy. Intervention nevertheless changes the future state distribution for both approaches, so the concern remains relevant to prediction reliability. The training labels come from completed fills of logged states, and the resulting value proxy need not remain calibrated after guidance or candidate-masking interventions. We do not claim policy-consistent value estimation or an on-policy improvement guarantee. The end-task results evaluate the complete deployed procedures in the reported settings, but they do not isolate or rule out this distribution-shift problem.