- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents TAMGen, a framework for time-aware, goal-conditioned humanoid motion generation. The main motivation is that satisfying the same spatial target under different time budgets may require qualitatively different motion patterns, rather than simply temporally rescaling the same trajectory. TAMGen addresses this with a flow-matching-based generator that decomposes generation into root trajectory and articulated pose generation while explicitly conditioning on duration, physical time, and normalized motion progress. The framework further introduces a Motion Compatibility Evaluator (MCE), which scores generated candidates based on both goal satisfaction and physical motion quality and can also jointly select a duration when the completion time is unspecified. The method is evaluated on G1-retargeted LAFAN and BoneSeed motions, sparse-target tasks, and a physical Unitree G1 robot. The results demonstrate strong target accuracy, improved physical-quality metrics after MCE selection, online target updates, and recovery from external disturbances.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses an important and somewhat underexplored distinction between spatial goal satisfaction and temporal appropriateness. Simply reaching a desired state at a requested timestamp is not sufficient if the resulting contact sequence or whole-body coordination is physically inappropriate. Explicitly modeling duration, physical time, and normalized progress is therefore well motivated, especially for humanoid control. The root-to-pose decomposition is also a sensible architectural choice for this setting.
- The work provides a fairly complete generation-to-execution pipeline rather than only evaluating generated motions offline. MCE provides a practical mechanism for selecting among stochastic candidates according to both target compatibility and physical quality, and the quantitative results show that this selection consistently improves the raw generator. The physical G1 experiments further demonstrate online target updates and disturbance recovery, making the practical relevance of the method substantially stronger. The paper reports that MCE improves all seven metrics on both datasets, although the best method still varies for some physical metrics.
Critical weaknesses
- Although the paper demonstrates promising results for time-aware motion generation, the evaluation of duration-dependent adaptation remains relatively limited. Most demonstrations focus on locomotion, with some simple object-interaction examples, leaving it unclear whether the framework generalizes to more diverse actions, such as more complex object manipulation under different time constraints.
- While the paper motivates its approach by highlighting the limitations of simple temporal rescaling, a direct comparison with such a baseline is missing. A more systematic evaluation across motion types and duration constraints would further strengthen the paper's central claim.
Questions for authors
Q1. Could the authors clarify how well TAMGen generalizes to different motion types and more extreme duration constraints? For instance, can it generate appropriate motions for fast and slow object manipulation? Additionally, how does the framework handle unusually short or long duration constraints (e.g., traveling 3 m in 1 second or 2 minutes)? Does it adapt the motion accordingly, or are there limitations on the supported duration range? Q2. Since the paper emphasizes adapting motion content rather than merely rescaling motion speed, could the authors provide a comparison with a simple temporal-rescaling baseline to better demonstrate this advantage?