- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a Dynamic Kuramoto–Hodge Operator (DKHO) based on the three main components. The first component is a form-aware encoder, representing known PDE conditions on their native geometric support. The second component is Dynamic Simplicial Kuramoto module, coordinating along the adjacent-degree pathways of the Dirac operator. The third component is a Hodge-based decoder, decomposing the response into non-harmonic and harmonic responses. Overall, the paper addresses a largely underexplored problem, is clearly written and provides a new perspective for neural operators (NOs) on non-Euclidean domains. On the other hand, the paper misses some very important prior work, which somewhat undermines the novelty of the presented approach.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses a problem which is widely met and very important but is not yet well investigated, that is, neural PDE solvers on domains with complex geometries.
The paper is overall clean mathematically.
It provides quite a comprehensive list of the considered datasets with complex geometries.
Critical weaknesses
The paper misses some important, closely related work, thereby undermining the claims of novelty. See, for example, Global Topological Dirac Synchronization (Carletti et al,, 2025) and Dirac–Bianconi Graph Neural Networks – Enabling Non-Diffusive Long-Range Graph Predictions (Nauck et al., 2024). It seems that these results, especially, Dirac–Bianconi GNNs (DBGNNs) of Nauck et al., 2024 has a similar idea on Dirac-operator dynamics as a learned layer, while differs from DKHO on some other aspects. It is hence essential to discuss these approaches, contrasting to these results on the topological Dirac operator as well as the Dirac and global topological synchronization models, and present a numerical study comparing to DBGNNs. Otherwise, the novelty claim related to the Dirac–Kuramoto model is ungrounded.
Other missing competitors are Curv-GT of Liao et al., 2025 and GLNO of Tang et al. 2025.
A more extensive ablation study on the second component, i.e., Dynamic Simplicial Kuramoto module, will be helpful.
Results lack variability analysis, no standard deviations are reported.
Questions for authors
see weaknesses above
9 comments
Response to Reviewer Fe4S (Part 2)
2. Dynamic Simplicial Kuramoto ablations (W2; Q2)
We agree that the original component study should have fully separated the individual choices inside the Dynamic Simplicial Kuramoto module. During the rebuttal, we therefore added both component removals and same-backbone replacements of the complete relation update. All variants use the same inputs, widths, data splits, and validation-based selection as DKHO-small:
| Controlled change | Mean task-wise RelL2 increase |
|---|---|
| Without Dirac routing | +278% |
| Without phase rotation | +27% |
| Without phase lag | +22% |
| Without multiplicative gate | +21% |
| Learned DEC diffusion | +187% |
| Gated message passing | +48.6% |
The results separate the effects of routing and relation dynamics. Removing the signed Dirac routes has the largest average effect (+278%) and reaches +1098% on Darcy . Face-level accuracy is therefore particularly sensitive to the cross-degree incidence route. Within the relation update, removing phase rotation, lag, or the multiplicative gate increases mean RelL2 by 27%, 22%, and 21%, respectively.
The two replacement controls test whether a more conventional update is sufficient. Degree-wise DEC diffusion preserves Hodge-Laplacian smoothing but removes the persistent cross-degree relation state, increasing error by 187% on average. Gated message passing preserves adaptive adjacent-rank exchange but replaces accumulated relation dynamics with direct content messages, increasing mean RelL2 by 48.6%. Together with ablations of component removal, these results show that the gains depend on both the signed incidence route and the way relation information is accumulated.
Representative ablations have been summarized in Section 5.5, and the complete eight-target accuracy and fidelity results, together with the two replacement dynamics, have been added in Appendix E.2 of the revised manuscript.
Response to Reviewer Fe4S (Part 3)
3. Variability and standard deviations (W3; Q3)
We appreciate the request for multi-seed statistics. The complete comparison contains eight targets and ten models, including separately tuned native- and matched-input runs. Given the rebuttal time and compute budget, we completed the full comparison once with seed 42 rather than reporting multi-seed results for only a small subset. All reported runs use common data splits, evaluation samples, metric definitions, and validation-based model selection.
The main performance gaps are particularly large: DKHO-large obtains 0.0155 vs. 0.0854 on Darcy and 0.0436 vs. 0.6250 on cavity , corresponding to approximately 82% and 93% lower RelL2 than the strongest native baselines. Together with the consistent protocol and the same ordering across the broader target set, these gaps increase the evidence of the advantage of our DKHO. We will run a broader multi-seed study in the camera-ready version.
We have clarified the common selection procedure, the evaluation samples, and the seed used for the reported DKHO runs in Appendices D.2--D.3 of the revised manuscript.
We thank the reviewer again for the constructive feedback, which has helped us position DKHO against the relevant competitors, examine the dynamics in isolation, and describe the stability of our results more candidly. We welcome further questions and discussion.
Response to Reviewer Fe4S (Part 1)
We thank Reviewer Fe4S for pointing out the missing related work, and for requesting a broader analysis of the Dynamic Simplicial Kuramoto module and experimental variability. These suggestions helped us sharpen both the positioning and the empirical evaluation.
1. Related work and novelty (W1; Q1)
We agree that Global Topological Dirac Synchronization and Dirac--Bianconi Graph Neural Networks (DBGNNs) are closely related and should be discussed explicitly. The revised discussion now distinguishes the questions addressed by these methods. Global Topological Dirac Synchronization studies when oscillators defined on different simplex degrees synchronize under a topological Dirac operator. DBGNNs learn non-diffusive node--edge propagation for long-range graph prediction. By contrast, DKHO shares their incidence-driven organization, but it is a condition-to-field neural operator: it separates persistent relation states from physical content states, adapts the exchange to PDE coefficients, forcing, and boundary conditions, and decodes fields directly on vertex, edge, or face supports through a Hodge-structured output map.
We also added the two missing competitive neural operators, CurvGT and GLNO, under both native-input and independently tuned matched-input protocols on all eight targets. Representative native-input results are:
DKHO-large outperforms both added competitors on all three representative targets. DKHO-small also improves substantially over both methods on Darcy C1 and Torus C1, while remaining close to CurvGT on Cavity H0. The complete tables report all eight outputs under both native- and matched-input protocols, including the cases in which another method is stronger.
We agree that a numerical comparison with DBGNN would also be valuable. However, a faithful transfer is not a drop-in baseline: the public implementation predicts node--edge graph quantities, whereas our benchmarks map PDE conditions to vertex-, edge-, and face-supported fields. Extending DBGNN to this setting requires a rank-2 representation, condition encoder, face-supported output head, capacity matching, and independent tuning. A partial port would not provide a faithful comparison with the published DBGNN. Within the rebuttal period, we therefore focused the numerical study on CurvGT and GLNO, which could be adapted and validated consistently, while adding a direct conceptual comparison with both Dirac-based works.
We have expanded the Related Work to compare DKHO with Global Topological Dirac Synchronization and DBGNNs, and added the complete CurvGT and GLNO results to Sections 5.1--5.4 and Appendix E.1 of the revised manuscript.