- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces topological neural operators. The proposed work aims to generalizes neural operators, which operate functions on points, to operators on cell complexes. This operator is constrained to respect the signal topology through DEC, and retains flexibility through a learned metric.
Critical strengths
- The problem considered in this paper is of significant interest to the learning community
- The approach offered is principled, and effective in several regimes
- The paper is easy to read in most places
Critical weaknesses
- There doesn’t appear to be a dedicated related work section which makes it difficult to assess how this work sits in relation to existing literature, and the baselines presented in the empirical analysis.
- Related papers [1-2] are not compared against, or discussed (as I understand ICLR does not consider ICML publications contemporaneous)
- It is not clear to me how to understand the empirical analysis beyond performance, since the baselines are not discussed in a related work section and there is no discussion of the interpretation of the results.
[1] Structure-Preserving Learning Improves Geometry Generalization in Neural PDEs. Shaffer, B.D., Koohy, S., Kinch, B., Hsieh, M.A. & Trask, N.. Proceedings of the 43rd International Conference on Machine Learning, in Proceedings of Machine Learning Research 2026 [2] Topology-Preserving Neural Operator Learning via Hodge Decomposition, Dongzhe Zheng, Tao Zhong, Christine Allen-Blanchette Proceedings of the 43rd International Conference on Machine Learning, in Proceedings of Machine Learning Research, 2026
Questions for authors
- Should H_out be positive definite?
- Does the learned nonlinear operator preserve the structure of H_out?
- Does the fact that the raising and lowering transfer maps don’t commute impact whether TNO respects (P1-3)?
3 comments
Q2. Structure under nonlinear updates.
Does the learned nonlinear operator preserve 's structure?
The layer preserves the assignment of features to cochain degrees and their interactions in the language of DEC. For example, , and are all -cochain-valued quantities. We combine these quantities at each -cell using the same learned feature transformation across cells of that degree (see Eq 9).
A generic cellwise nonlinearity does not, however, preserve closed, exact or harmonic subspaces. Even if , we don't necessarily have .
Similarly, the identities of the fixed DEC operators do not impose the corresponding identities on independently decoded outputs.
An additional ablation now illustrates this latter distinction by constructing outputs using and , which enforce their differential relations but increase their prediction errors (Reviewer 9Qbx, W1 / Q2 (b)).
Q3. Noncommuting transfer maps.
How does noncommutation of raising/lowering maps affect P1–P3?
Noncommutation does not affect P1–P3. We interpret this as two separate questions of compatibility.
Within a complex, the raising and lowering maps and do not need to commute ( and are the two contributions to the Hodge Laplacian), and P1–P3 do not require them to be equal. For the fixed DEC operators, the relevant identities are and the Hodge-adjoint relation between and .
Between resolutions, restriction maps would additionally need to satisfy to be compatible in the de Rham sense, and likewise for prolongation. Our HTNOs build the hierarchy on general combinatorial complexes, which do not guarantee this de Rham structure, so we do not enforce this condition. P1–P3 are relabeling equivariance, incidence-supported coupling, and weight sharing, and each HTNO level satisfies them. Without the commuting condition, the hierarchy does not guarantee that exact cochains remain exact after transfer, so the coarse levels act as a learned coarse correction, as we discuss in Appendix D.1.
We thank the reviewer for their questions and are happy to follow up. Given the additional evaluations and exposition, we would appreciate it if the reviewer would consider raising their final score once their concerns have been addressed.
Dear Reviewer 4GmY,
As the discussion period closes on November 18 (AoE), we would be grateful to hear whether the new related-work section in the main text (W1), the comparison with Zheng et al.'s HSD in Table 6, the positioning of Geo-NeWF (W2), and our answers on positive definiteness, nonlinear updates, and noncommuting transfer maps (Q1–Q3) address your concerns. We appreciate the time you spent reviewing our work and are happy to clarify any remaining points in the time we have left.
Best, The authors
We thank the reviewer for finding the approach principled and effective in several regimes. We address the positioning, interpretation, and structural properties below.
W1. Related-work organization.
Can a dedicated related-work section position the method and baselines?
We agree that placing the extensive related-work discussion in the appendix can make the contribution and baseline choices harder to assess. We have now also added a related work section in the main text that distinguishes neural operators on irregular geometries/topologies, higher-order networks, and methods that explicitly enforce differential constraints. This section now explains both the relationship to prior work and the baselines we evaluate against, and points to the extended related works in the appendix.
W2. Additional comparisons.
How does TNO compare with Shaffer et al.'s structure-preserving learning and Zheng et al.'s Hodge-based operator?
We thank the reviewer for highlighting these closely related works. Our submission includes a direct comparison with Zheng et al.’s Hodge-based operator (HSD) in Table 6, covering both configurations for the published network width and parameter-equalized variants, which are evaluated across all seven 2D benchmarks. Appendix E.3 details the implementation, tuning, and evaluation protocol.
We further thank the reviewer for pointing us to Geo-NeWF. It shares our motivation to exploit compatible differential structures, but learns geometry-conditioned reduced finite-element spaces and constitutive laws rather than learning a solution operator via cochain updates, as in TNO. We have now included Geo-NeWF as relevant related work, but prioritize HSD and HOGNN as baselines as they more directly compare to our TNO instantiation's (Eq 9) Hodge-based operator design and DEC-based architecture, respectively (Table 6).
W3. Interpretation of results.
What do the results establish beyond predictive accuracy?
Beyond improvements in predictive accuracy on public benchmarks, our central contribution is a way to formulate operator learning for fields that inherently live at different ranks of a complex. Potentials, circulations, and fluxes naturally live on vertices, edges, and faces, with interactions defined through discrete differential operators. This is established in the DEC literature, and we formalize it here in the language of neural operators. Topological neural networks (TNNs) provide architectures for learning representations on cell complexes. TNOs instead formulate learning operators between cochain-valued physical fields and use TNN layers as their computational building blocks. Our approach separates the geometric relationships between fields from the learned feature transformations. The same parameters can then be applied to different meshes by assembling the geometric operators for each mesh. The formulation also connects these constructions to existing neural operators, with Fourier and graph neural operators recovered as special cases. Our contribution is therefore the integration of DEC operators and topological message passing into a unified framework for neural operator learning on cell complexes, rather than either component individually. We summarize these contributions in our response to
hvUN, W4.Sections 5.3–5.4 in the submitted manuscript already examine why these choices matter. Our Oriented-Darcy experiments demonstrate how TNOs can natively represent multi-rank input information, while the component ablations examine how local cross-rank interactions and global spectral communication contribute to predictive performance. Additional cellular message-passing ablations now also justify the benefit of DEC routing itself (
gmQ3, W2 / Q2 (a)), and a cross-rank ablation examines the contribution of interactions between ranks (gmQ3, W2 / Q2 (b)).We have now made this interpretation clearer in the paper. We do not claim that learned model updates preserve conservation laws, as discussed in Q2 below.
Q1. Positive definiteness.
Should Hout be positive definite?
In Eq. 8, Houtk∈Rnk×dh contains the updated features on each of the k-cells. Positive definiteness is therefore not a condition on this block feature update. The positive-definite objects in the DEC construction are the Hodge stars Mk, which define the cochain inner products, yielding positive semidefinite Hodge Laplacians in these inner products.
If the question concerns the assembled block operator in Sec. 4.2, positive semidefiniteness of its diagonal Laplacian blocks does not imply positive definiteness of the coupled operator. We do not require this property. We use the block operator to prescribe geometric routes for feature transport, drawing analogies to how DEC couples dimensioned physical quantities through boundary operations.