acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

EMBER: Credit-Guided Distillation with Online Student Exploration

Abstract

Correct teacher traces do not specify which reasoning steps a changing student should imitate. We introduce Evolving Marginal-Benefit Estimation for Reasoning (EMBER), a framework that adapts supervision from fixed, text-only teacher traces to the current student's capabilities. EMBER estimates a step's credit by comparing terminal returns at adjacent teacher prefixes under the same student continuation policy. Positive credit weights imitation, while the sampled continuations also support reinforcement learning. Preserving credit magnitude allows teacher supervision to weaken as its estimated benefit declines. Our analysis characterizes credit reliability under estimation error and policy drift, and shows that question-only mastery alone does not make teacher credit vanish: value drops along teacher prefixes must also disappear. Experiments on instruction following and mathematical reasoning examine this coupling of guidance and exploration. On AMC 2022–2023, Qwen3.5-4B trained with EMBER exceeds SFT by 6.7 percentage points in avg@32, with training dynamics consistent with a diminishing teacher contribution. These findings support student-relative task return as a criterion for adapting teacher supervision during online learning.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
knowledge distillation, credit assignment, reinforcement learning, mathematical reasoning, large language models

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 4 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_gXgqOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes EMBER, a knowledge distillation framework that combines step-level credit assignment with online reinforcement learning. It estimates the benefit of individual teacher steps from student continuation outcomes, uses these estimates to weight teacher supervision, and reuses the rollouts for GRPO training. The authors evaluate the method on mathematical reasoning and instruction-following tasks, and provide theoretical analyses of credit estimation and teacher handoff.

Critical strengths
  1. Reasonable and practically motivated method.

The method evaluates teacher steps based on the student's current capabilities rather than imitating all steps equally. This is a reasonable approach that can adapt supervision as the student evolves.

  1. Theoretical analysis and experimental evaluation.

The paper analyzes credit estimation errors, policy drift, and teacher handoff. It also includes experiments across different models and tasks to examine the proposed framework.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Lack of fair baseline comparisons makes the performance gains difficult to attribute.

The main benchmark results rely largely on baselines from previous papers without matching training data or compute budgets. For example, EMBER uses the full OpenR1-Math-220k dataset, while the reported Prefix-RFT baseline uses approximately 46k examples. Their average performance differs by only 0.5 percentage points.

The main training study lacks a compute-matched SFT + GRPO baseline, making it difficult to determine whether the gains come from the proposed credit assignment or existing hybrid training strategies.

These issues weaken the evidence that EMBER outperforms existing methods.

  1. The necessity and effectiveness of step-level credit assignment are not sufficiently demonstrated.

In Table 4, step-aligned credit improves over shuffled, question-level, and uniform weighting by only 0.4–0.5 percentage points, without multiple training seeds or statistical significance analysis. This provides limited evidence that precise step-level assignment is important.

The accuracy of the online value model's credit estimates is not adequately validated, particularly its ability to distinguish positive and negative credit.

Adaptive prefix sampling and credit weighting are not fully disentangled, leaving their individual contributions unclear.

Given the additional rollout and value estimation costs, the practical benefit of this complexity remains uncertain.

Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors provide fair comparisons with strong baselines under matched training data and compute budgets, particularly SFT + GRPO, to establish a meaningful advantage of EMBER?

  2. Can the authors provide convincing evidence that step-level credit assignment offers a substantial and reliable improvement over simpler weighting strategies, given the small differences reported in Table 4?

Reviewer_24pXOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper propose a method that finds out which teacher reasoning steps are useful for student models. It is based on additional rollouts and a value model to estimate how each teacher steps help the student solve a problem. They also use this information to help distillation. The final training is also based on SFT+RL.

Critical strengths
  1. I think considering the student's current ability is a reasonable idea compared with simply copying all teacher reasoning steps.
  2. This method only used teacher's generated text. This makes it possible to use all kinds of models.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Although the technical design has been explained a lot, the novelty is still not clear. Can the authors clarify why this method is novel?
  2. My main concern is it seems EMBER needs additional rollouts and a value model in the process, but is this extra complexity really worthy compare with simple SFT+GRPO? If we spend the same computational budget on SFT+GRPO only, will that reach the same level as EMBER?
  3. Also in table 4, the improvement is like 0.4 to 0.5%. Can the authors explain whether this small improvement is meaningful? Is this average results from multiple runs?
Questions for authors

I've raised questions after each weakness points, please check the above.

Reviewer_is62OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces a framework for assigning credit to steps in teacher traces based on the performance of the continuation with the student’s policy, on the teacher's prefix. The resulting model was tested on math benchmarks such as AIME 24/25 and MATH, and separate experiments with the Skywork reward model were done to test instruction-following performance. A mechanism study was additionally done to show how the teacher's credit declines as training progresses.

Critical strengths

Credit-guided distillation is a genuinely interesting and useful problem. In many cases, a student model can’t/shouldn’t imitate the teacher model, and having it learn only on key actions that point to success has many useful applications.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Results from Tables 1 and 2 compare against results published in literature without local reproduction. I think this would make the margin inconclusive unless there is rigorous justification that the setup of the original paper is replicated exactly. Additionally, the number of trials did not seem to be specified for Table 1. Is it avg@32?

  2. Section 3 should have a clear explanation of the algorithm, and it is otherwise hard to understand how it works. I don’t think you can only rely on Figure 1 to explain the entire algorithm.

Questions for authors

Huang et al. (2025) cited in Table 2 also seems to use expert demonstration prefixes to guide student exploration. Could you elaborate how your work differs from theirs?

142: “A block of B teacher examples receives an expected G=bBG=bB prefix groups, with fractional counts…” What is bb defined as? I also see it in Figure 1, but I'm not sure what it represents.

What values of λT\lambda_T and λR\lambda_R in equation 4 was used during training?

Reviewer_69zAOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces EMBER, a framework for adapting imitation of fixed teacher traces to a changing student. It treats each teacher step as a text-only intervention and estimates its student-relative value from terminal returns after adjacent teacher prefixes, using shared student continuations both to fit an online prefix-value model and to form within-prefix GRPO updates. The paper analyzes estimation error, policy drift, and conditions for vanishing credit, and evaluates instruction following and mathematical reasoning.

Critical strengths
  • The intervention framing makes the target quantity clear: EMBER measures the change in terminal task return when a fixed teacher step is supplied and the same student policy continues from either prefix. Section 3 explicitly controls the continuation policy and response budget, and Appendix A distinguishes this estimand from the effect of a neural parameter update. This is a useful conceptual separation for text-only teacher supervision.
  • The method reuses sampled suffixes for online value fitting and within-prefix GRPO rather than treating value estimation and exploration as unrelated objectives. Section 3.2 specifies the shared rollout budget, cross-fitting, acquisition mixture, and treatment of constant-reward groups; Appendix B and C add update masks, seeds, decoding, and loss normalization. These details make the system easier to reason about and reproduce.
  • The paper is unusually careful about scope. Lemma 2 states the error and policy-drift assumptions needed for a sign certificate, and the text warns that cross-fitting alone does not guarantee prediction accuracy. The analysis also gives a concrete counterexample to equating positive teacher advantage with a safe Euclidean likelihood update, while the AMC trajectory and Table 4 offer targeted empirical tests of credit magnitude and step alignment.
Critical weaknesses

The paper’s strongest reliability guarantee is not established for the reference algorithm. Lemma 2 requires bounded endpoint-estimation error and policy drift, but Section 3.3 uses the reference setting u=0; the online value model also predicts unmeasured prefixes, for which Appendix A.3 says cross-fitting does not provide a uniform error certificate. The method uses 16 continuations per sampled prefix, and Appendix A.3 notes that the resulting conservative bounds can be vacuous at this sample count. Appendix D further states that the experiments do not measure false-positive rates, pointwise value coverage, or sign-certificate validity. Since positive-part weighting can retain overestimated positive gaps, the paper does not yet show how often deployed teacher weights correspond to genuinely beneficial interventions. The manuscript already acknowledges that its plug-in estimates have no sign certificate; my concern is the missing empirical validation of these estimates, not an incorrect unconditional theorem claim. Please evaluate predicted gaps against independent, fresh rollouts under the current policy and report sign error and gap-estimation error at sampled and unmeasured prefixes; any evaluated uncertainty gate should additionally report coverage and admission rates.

Questions for authors
  • For Table 1, report the number of evaluation prompts and the exact GPT-4o judging protocol, including the prompt and model version; this would make the reported score easier to reproduce and interpret.

  • Since instruction-following training uses Skywork-Reward-V2 while GPT-4o supplies the reported evaluation score, a brief reward-model sensitivity check or a discussion of reward/evaluation disagreement would help readers assess how much the result depends on the training scorer.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.