- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
To address the problem that indiscriminate consistency regularization in existing RGB-T fusion may suppress fine-grained complementary cues, introduce inter-modal interference, and reduce the discriminability of fused representations, the authors propose ART, a decoupling-alignment-interaction framework for RGB-T object detection. ART decomposes RGB and thermal features into a shared common semantic space and two modality-specific unique spaces, models them separately, and performs interaction afterward.
Critical strengths
The experiments are relatively complete, and the method achieves SOTA on four datasets.
Critical weaknesses
Beyond Duality [XX], RDCRNet [XX]. “The optimization procedure is provided in Algorithm ??” “Algorithm ??” “The implementation details of the interaction block are provided in Algorithm ??” “As shown in Tab. ??, ART remains stable under mild and moderate training-time misregistration.” “As shown in Fig. ??, the red region at the bottom of the figure is not due to dispersed attention.” Where are the references here?
There is a problem with the ablation experiments. There are three components, but results are provided for only four combinations, so the contribution of each component remains unclear.
There are too few methods in the efficiency comparison. These columns should be added for all four datasets so that readers can intuitively compare different methods.
The compared methods are somewhat old, and there is no comparison with strong baselines from the three major CV conferences or the three major ML conferences in 2025 and 2026. Setting aside the 2026 methods for now, the paper should at least compare with 2025 baselines, such as M²D-LIF and WaveMamba. These two methods have only tens of millions of parameters and FLOPs of only slightly over one hundred G, while their accuracy is close to or even higher than that of your method. Your method has more than six hundred million parameters and more than one thousand GFLOPs. Current methods already achieve dozens of FPS.
[1] Rethinking Multi-modal Object Detection from the Perspective of Mono-Modality Feature Learning, ICCV, 2025.
[2] WaveMamba: Wavelet-Driven Mamba Fusion for RGB-Infrared Object Detection, ICCV, 2025.
Questions for authors
Everything has already been stated in the weaknesses.
Concern 1: 1.The input modality for the SeaDronesSee experiment is unclear. The paper presents SeaDronesSee as an RGBT benchmark, which however, only contains RGB images. The author should explain where the thermal input required by ART comes from.
We acknowledge that there are typos in the text, e.g., [XXX]; however, regarding this point, we believe it is a factual error, and we would also like to ask the reviewer why you think there are only RGB images? As far as we know, the dataset we used is an RGB-T dataset. Did you make this judgment based on the output of an AI tool?