The paper does not establish a sufficiently substantive new contribution beyond dataset-specific transfer observations.
The manuscript explicitly builds on a field-atomic framework that already studies asymmetric transfer among mathematical domains. Its extension is to examine these initializations after target-domain GRPO and describe the resulting reasoning behaviors. However, the study does not turn these observations into a validated principle for selecting data in a new setting. It remains unclear how a practitioner should use the analysis without first performing essentially the same exhaustive comparison of candidate initializations.
The broader relationship between post-training and generalization has also received substantial study. For example, Chu et al., SFT Memorizes, RL Generalizes: A Comparative Study of Foundation Model Post-training (ICML 2025), explicitly evaluates generalization to unseen rule and visual variants. That work does not settle the present initialization question, but it illustrates why another transfer study needs a clearly differentiated and well-supported finding. My concern is not that the research area is closed; it is that this manuscript adds too little reliable, reusable knowledge to it. Proceedings of Machine Learning Research
The improvements are too small and may not be significant.
Using the rounded average accuracies in Table 1, the best non-domain-aligned SFT initialization exceeds the domain-aligned initialization by approximately 0.1, 1.1, 0.2, and 1.4 percentage points across the four targets. Table 1 does not report uncertainty across independent training runs. The models studied here are 7B; differences between algorithms usually shrink for larger models, so this result may not generalize to frontier models.
The path-reward experiment is a useful intervention, and its largest reported improvement—3.7 percentage points on Topology-low—is larger than the initialization differences discussed above. Nevertheless, rewarding transitions into Answer does not by itself validate the proposed explanation of domain transfer. The intervention needs controls that distinguish the value of the selected transitions from simpler effects involving response length, answer formation, or termination behavior.
More generally, the manuscript has not shown that its behavioral descriptions can predict an effective initialization on held-out data or transfer into a reliable training decision. Annotation agreement establishes that the labels can be applied consistently; it does not establish that the labels capture the causal or practically decisive factors behind the reported improvements.