acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

From Chains to Atoms: A Unified Math Agent with Atomic Capability-Grounded Reasoning

Abstract

Mathematical reasoning serves as a critical testbed for LLMs, offering both ob- jectively verifiable outcomes and a wide spectrum of complexity. Despite recent progress, existing approaches remain fundamentally limited: (1) linear Chain-of-Thought scales by extending reasoning, often leading to overthinking and local optimality; (2) agent systems usually lack effective alignment of mathematical atomic capabilities between planning, execution, and feedback, preventing the specialized action of agent reasoning. We introduce AtomMath-Agent, a Unified Math Agent based on atomic capability-grounded reasoning unit, which comprises one mathematical atom-goal paired with an atomic capability. Agent's planner forms these units a dependency graph shared by planning, execution, and memory. The Planner specifies what mathematical capability is required, while Executor determines a capability-conditioned atom skill for how to realize it. The atomic unit also defines a verification protocol based on it mathematical atomic capability, which is used for feedback of results and dynamic planning of subsequent steps. This shared representation turns atomic reasoning into the organizing principle of the agent. Across seven backbones, AtomMath-Agent improves text-only and multimodal accuracy by 5.0 and 4.4 points on average. Tool-matched comparisons and controlled ablations further show gains and support the roles of atomic units and replanning. We further apply AtomMath-Agent to data synthesis and improve agentic mid-training, with the clearest transfer from math to other agent tasks. These results provide insights and demonstrate atomic capability-grounded reasoning as a unified thought for LLM-based agent community.

Primary area:
neurosymbolic & hybrid AI systems (physics-informed, logic & formal reasoning, etc.)
Keywords:
mathematical reasoning, LLM agents, atomic capability reasoning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_iDkvOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces a Planner-Executor-Feedback workflow for maths agent. Planner decompose the problem into a 10 steps plans and determine what specific maths atomic capability should be used in this steps; the skills are then loaded into executor to make progress; after each step, the verifier checks the observations and determine whether retry, continue or stop. The paper reports gains over base models on three text and three multimodal math benchmarks, outperforms AutoGen / OctoTools / MathAgent while being more token-efficiency.

Critical strengths
  1. Shows consistent improvement among a range of maths benchmark and across both open-source and closed-source models, and beats other agent frameworks with fewer tokens used. This is helpful because the comparison is not depend on the model backbone and tool use or not. There is evidence that the capability typed decomposition itself has its value.
  2. The atomic capabilities are curated and discussed by domain experts, and the ablation shows it matters: replacing it with generic labels costs +4.6 / +2.8 (Qwen3-8B) and +5.4 / +4.3 (Gemini-3-flash). Also these principles might be valuable beyond this agent framework.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper does not specify what the validation contract actually is, although it is important to understand how verifier works based on the atomic capability. It is only described as three lists (operational / local / global checks) generated by the planner, with no explanation of what a check looks like or how it is evaluated. In Figure 9, the verifier prompt is: "Rules:\n- If the current step number is less than the predefined total number of steps and the previous step has a valid result, CONTINUE.\n- If the current step number is greater than or equal to the predefined total number of steps and a complete solution is available, STOP.\n- If a step fails or the result is empty, but there are still steps left, CONTINUE.\n- STOP only when all necessary steps have been completed and the final answer has been obtained.\n". There is no verifier contract here. This matters because the paper’s central claim is that gains come from capability-grounded planning and verification (Sec 3.5, ablation on replanning); if the verifier that actually ran is a generic step counter, that part of the claim is unsupported.

  2. The reported AIME25 score for Gemini-3-Flash (60.0) is far below the score shown on MathArena (97.5%, with thinking_level=high, https://matharena.ai/models/gemini_gemini_3_flash). MathArena’s output is about 18K tokens per problem, which is within the paper’s 20K output limit. Since the main gains are measured against the base models, this needs explanation.

Questions for authors
  1. For each base model evaluation, please specify the configuration such as the thinking setting and output limit. Please explain the differences between your eval and public leaderboard scores.
  2. Please confirm how the Figure 4 (a) end to end token composition was calculated. For base model, if it is without any agent flow, how can it has 34K (input + output) per problem when your output token limit is 20K. (Does it mean in average your problem input is more than 14K?)
  3. Which verifier actually ran: the contract-aware one in B.2, or the step-counting one shown in Figure 9? Could you give me an example of the validation contract, or explain it better?
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer iDkv (Part 1/2)

Thank you for your careful reading of the paper and for pointing out where the verifier description, inference settings, and token accounting needed more detail. We hope the following clarifications make the experimental setup and the role of the verifier easier to understand.

W1 & Q3: Which verifier actually ran: the contract-aware one or the step-counting prompt shown in Figure 9? What does a validation contract look like?

Response

Thank you for pointing out how Figure 9 could be read. Our experiments used the contract-aware verifier, with different validation conditions for different atomic capabilities. Figure 9 presents an abbreviated control-flow prompt and omits the current atomic unit, the capability-specific contract, and the full execution evidence. We agree that the figure did not give enough detail to show how the verifier reached its judgments. We have clarified the inputs and decision rules used in the experiments and aligned the explanations in the main text, appendix, and figure caption. The step count tracks whether the solve loop has reached its round limit.

In our interface, the validation contract is passed to the verifier with the atomic unit. The unit's mathematical capability determines the kinds of conditions to check. The subgoal and verified dependencies turn those conditions into requirements for the particular step. Operational checks assess whether execution succeeded. Local checks assess whether the output meets the current mathematical task's requirements. Global checks assess whether the current results are sufficient to answer the original problem. A successful execution can still fail a mathematical check. The round limit ends the loop when the budget is reached, and the verifier judges completion from the contract and available evidence.

Consider a Calculation unit for the following problem. Find all real solutions of x+2=x\sqrt{x+2}=x and return their sum plus one.

Atomic unit fieldContract for this example
Subgoal and primary capabilityFind the complete real solution set of the original equation using Calculation.
Verified dependenciesUse the original equation x+2=x\sqrt{x+2}=x, the real domain x+2≥0x+2\geq 0, and the necessary condition x≥0x\geq 0 from the equality.
Output formatReturn a deduplicated list of exact real solutions in the solutions field, with a derivation or calculation evidence for the candidates.
Operational checkConfirm that the resource returns a usable result, the solutions field is present and parseable, and the record indicates no execution error or truncation.
Local check L1Confirm that each candidate satisfies the domain and nonnegativity requirements.
Local check L2Substitute each candidate into the original equation and check x+2−x=0\sqrt{x+2}-x=0.
Local check L3Verify completeness. Under x≥0x\geq 0, squaring gives the equivalent equation x2−x−2=(x−2)(x+1)=0x^2-x-2=(x-2)(x+1)=0. Consider both roots and retain all that satisfy the original equation.
Global checkConfirm that the solution set is supported and that the sum of the solutions plus one has been computed.

Suppose the Executor returns {−1,2}\{-1,2\} after squaring the equation. The operational check passes, but −1-1 violates L1 and fails L2 because substituting it gives 1=1≠−1\sqrt{1}=1\ne -1. The verifier can identify the issue as an extraneous root introduced by squaring and return Retry, with the failure evidence for −1-1. The Planner can then revise or retry the unit, retaining the valid solution set {2}\{2\}.

Once {2}\{2\} passes the local checks, the overall task still requires one more step. The verifier returns Continue and releases the successor unit that depends on the solution set. The successor computes 2+1=32+1=3. The verifier returns Stop once all parts of the original objective are supported. The same contract thus guides candidate checking, local repair, and the use of the result by later units.

The LLM verifier receives the substitution, constraint, and completeness requirements as written conditions, then judges the execution result against them. For a Theorem Application unit, the contract would instead focus on the theorem's premises and scope of applicability. We hope this example makes it clearer how the check conditions follow from the mathematical capability assigned to the unit.

Revised manuscript. Validation, Feedback, and Memory in Page 6, Line 307-310, verifier inputs and workflow caption Page 15, Line 776-780, and the worked Calculation contract in Page 15, Line 806-809 and Page 17, Line 864-871.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer iDkv (Part 2/2)

W2 & Q1: Gemini-3-Flash gets 60.0 on AIME25, far below MathArena. Please specify thinking settings and output limits for every base model.

Response

Thank you for pointing out that the original submission gave too little detail about the inference settings. To make the comparison within a backbone fair, we evaluate Base and AtomMath-Agent under the same model settings in Table 1. For Gemini-3-Flash, both use thinking_level=medium and a per-request output cap of 20,000 tokens. They also use the same problems, answer extraction, normalization, and scoring procedures.

The public MathArena entry lists thinking_level=high and a 64,000-token output cap. These settings differ from ours, so the public score and our result reflect different evaluation conditions. The average output length on the leaderboard also leaves open how many individual responses would reach the 20K cap. Other inference settings, API variation, evaluation dates, and truncation could affect the results. We have clarified the settings so that readers can interpret Table 1 as evidence of the relative benefit of our method under the stated, shared inference configuration. MathArena model page.

The revised text specifies the Gemini settings and the agent's request and round limits.

Revised manuscript. We supplement the Implementation and Evaluation Details in Page 20, Line 1026-1046.

Q2: How can Base LLM use about 34K tokens per problem with a 20K output limit?

Response

Thank you for pointing out the ambiguity in our budget description. For AtomMath-Agent, 20K is the output cap of each individual LLM request. The efficiency experiment uses a separate setting for the unwrapped Base model. To reduce truncation on individual problems and better assess the token–accuracy trade-off, we raised its per-request output cap to 42K. With a 20K cap in that experiment, responses that need more than 20K output tokens could be truncated, limiting the range of the efficiency comparison. Figure 4(a) reports an average of 8,453 input tokens and 25,465 output tokens, for 33,918 tokens per problem in the higher-cap efficiency setting. The Table 1 Gemini Base uses the 20K setting described above.

AtomMath-Agent can execute up to 10 solve rounds. A round can include multiple LLM requests for planning, execution, verification, and retry handling. When the problem is solved or the maximum number of rounds is reached, the system generates a final summary and returns its answer. We calculate end-to-end token use by summing the inputs and outputs of all requests for each problem, including retries within a round and the final summary. We have added these settings and the accounting procedure to the revised manuscript.

Revised manuscript. We supllement the settings in Page 20, Line 1026-1057.

Thank you again for the detailed feedback. We hope the contract example and the clarified evaluation settings address the concerns about the verifier and the comparisons. The relevant changes are highlighted in the revised manuscript, and we will incorporate them into the camera-ready version.

Reviewer_8jEYOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The authors propose AtomMath-Agent, which decomposes complex mathematical reasoning into atomic reasoning units with explicit capability types and verfication protocol; each unit comprises a subgoal, its dependencies, an output schema, and a verification protocol. These units link planning, execuation, verification, and replanning. The paper reports gains across seven backbones and six benchmarks, along with tool-matching comparisons and structural ablations. The results show that the method improves both the accuracy and efficiency of math agents, and that the resulting structured reasoning trajectories are further used for model mid-training.

Critical strengths
  • S1. The method design offers a fairly unified and concise perspective. Unifying mathematical sub-goals, capability types and verification criteria into the atom reasoning unit allows different capabilities and tasks to share a common structure.
  • S2. The experiments are large in scale and the results are solid. In Table 1, all seven backbones improve on both textual and multimodal settings, with cross-model average gains of 5.0 and 4.4 points. Table 3 ablates tool-free execuation, the capability taxonomy, and other components. Overall, the experiments are rich and span closed- and open-source models as well as textual and multimodal settings, strengthenning the reliability of the evidence.
  • S3. The paper explores transferring the reasoning framework to model training. Beyond improving inference-time performance, it leverages the structured atomic trajectories for mid-training and obtains gains there as well, extending the practical value of the method.
Critical weaknesses
  • W1. A core component of the method is the set of atomic capabilities, yet the taxonomy is manually designed and lacks sufficient validation of its rationale. The 11 capability types are predefined by expert. The paper does not show that this taxonomy or its granularity is reasonable. It may be worth exploring adaptive approach, or grounding the taxonomy in prior mathematics literature.
  • W2. The evaluation focuses mainly on final answers and lacks direct verification of intermediate reasoning quality. The paper emphasizes that atomic reasoning improves the riger and reliability of mathematic reasoning, but the experiments rely primarily on final-answer accuracy. The correctness of atomic steps, their logical consistency, and the ability to localize errors are not systematically assessed, so the validation of the core mechanism remains incomplete.
Questions for authors
  • Q1. How is the reliability of atomic capability assignment ensured? When a mathematical sub-problem involves multiple capabilities, how does the Planner select the correct atomic capability, and to what extent does a misassigned capability affect final performance?
  • Q2. Has the method been compared with closely related reasoning frameworks that also decompose reasoning into atomic capabilities? The paper mainly compares against general agent-collaboration frameworks, but not against frameworks built on atomic capability decomposition, such as Atom of Thoughts [1] or SCoT [2].

[1] Atom of Thoughts for Markov LLM Test-Time Scaling.

[2] Can Atomic Step Decomposition Enhance the Self-structured Reasoning of Multimodal Large Models?

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 8jEY (Part 1/3)

Thank you for recognizing our shared atomic-unit design, the results across backbones, and our exploration of trajectory-based training. Your questions helped us explain the basis for the capability taxonomy and evaluate the quality of intermediate reasoning more directly.

W1: The manually designed taxonomy lacks validation of its rationale and granularity.

Response

Thank you for this helpful suggestion. We agree that the original manuscript described the rationale for the taxonomy too briefly. Our goal is to study how mathematical atomic capabilities can be integrated with an agent's planning, execution, and feedback. We therefore considered both the operations involved in mathematical reasoning and the tasks that an agent can execute and check.

(1) Literature review and design rationale. We found that prior work characterizes mathematical ability from two broad perspectives. One focuses on mathematical data across fields such as algebra, geometry, calculus, analysis, topology, and combinatorics [1-2]. This perspective informs the coverage of our task collection. The other focuses on the particular skills used in mathematical reasoning and problem-solving. Tasks such as formal theorem proving [3] and mathematical modeling [4] are especially relevant to the kinds of operations an agent needs to perform. We also collected mathematical task definitions and drew on empirical studies of mathematical skills. For example, Atomic Thinking [5] identifies three basic logical capabilities, while GAUSS [6] evaluates twelve mathematical skill dimensions grouped into three domains. Together, these works provided a basis for identifying candidate atomic capabilities.

(2) Dataset mapping. We mapped the mathematical datasets we collected to the candidate capabilities. For each candidate, we considered whether it corresponded to a common solving operation and whether it could define an executable, checkable subtask. Some fine-grained candidates occurred infrequently in the tasks we examined and did not consistently form standalone tasks. We left these out of the current taxonomy because they were difficult to use as independent atomic units in the agent.

(3) Expert consultation. We discussed the category definitions and the relevant datasets with three researchers holding PhDs in mathematics-related fields and two senior instructors with more than ten years of university mathematics teaching experience. Through this process, we refined the taxonomy to cover varied reasoning patterns and common problem-solving scenarios, limit overlap among categories, support evaluation, and align the capabilities with the agent's planning, execution, and feedback.

The resulting eleven capabilities reflect a balance between previous research and the practical requirements of the agent. Table 3 also tests the granularity through the Coarse Structure ablation. The full taxonomy improves text and multimodal performance by 2.8/2.5 points on Qwen3-8B-VL and 5.7/1.6 points on Gemini-3-Flash, respectively. These results support the granularity of our current design relative to the coarser setting we tested. We have expanded the discussion of the capability definitions and prior work in the revised manuscript.

Revised manuscript. We supplement the Atomic Capability Taxonomy in Page 13, Line 680-689 and Ablation Study Page 8, Line 406-412.

[1] He Z, Liang T, Xu J, et al. Deepmath-103k: A large-scale, challenging, decontaminated, and verifiable mathematical dataset for advancing reasoning[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:2504.11456, 2025.

[2] Wang K, Pan J, Shi W, et al. Measuring multimodal mathematical reasoning with math-vision dataset[J]. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 2024, 37: 95095-95169.

[3] Lin H, Sun Z, Welleck S, et al. Lean-STaR: Learning to Interleave Thinking and Proving[C]//The Thirteenth International Conference on Learning Representations.

[4] Liu F, Yang Z R, Liu C, et al. MM-Agent: LLM as Agents for Real-world Mathematical Modeling Problem[C]//The Thirty-ninth Annual Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems.

[5] Kuang J, Huang H, Li Y, et al. Atomic Thinking of LLMs: Decoupling and Exploring Mathematical Reasoning Abilities[C]//The Thirty-ninth Annual Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems.

[6] Zhang Y, Zhang J, Ren Q, et al. GAUSS: Benchmarking Structured Mathematical Skills for Large Language Models[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:2509.18122, 2025.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 8jEY (Part 2/3)

W2: Final-answer evaluation does not systematically assess intermediate correctness, consistency, or error localization.

Response

Thank you for emphasizing the importance of evaluating the intermediate process. We agree that a correct final answer can contain incorrect reasoning and that the presence of checkable fields leaves open the question of how reliably they are checked. We addressed this concern through a case analysis and a human evaluation of the reasoning process.

The case analysis shows how the verifier links a failed condition to a specific atomic unit, and how the Planner can keep valid upstream results while revising the unresolved portion of the graph. This lets us trace where the error occurs, which condition triggers the repair, and which later steps need to be executed again.

We also sampled the same 100 problems and invited three experts to review the full trajectories under blinded conditions. The review examined intermediate correctness and logical consistency, invalid premise references, repeated attempts without progress, and whether errors were successfully repaired. As noted in our response to Reviewer YH3c, the experts distinguished repeated attempts that added no new evidence from productive verification, including within longer trajectories. The relevant results are as follows.

MethodLogical consistency ↑Invalid premise references ↓Repeated steps without progress ↓Successful error repair ↑
Gemini-3-Flash0.860.150.270.76
OctoTools0.880.220.210.71
AtomMath-Agent0.910.090.160.82

We are encouraged by these results because the gains extend beyond final-answer accuracy to the measured quality of the reasoning process. In particular, the successful error repair proportion was 0.82 for AtomMath-Agent, compared with 0.76 for Gemini-3-Flash and 0.71 for OctoTools. The case analysis illustrates the localization mechanism, while the expert evaluation quantifies reasoning quality and repair on the sampled trajectories. Both are included in the revised manuscript.

Revised manuscript. We revise the Case Study in Page 9, Line 571-573 and supplement the Expert Evaluation of Reasoning Trajectories in Page 21, Line 1115-1128 and Page 22, Line 1134-1141.

Q1: How is capability assignment ensured? How are multi-capability subproblems handled, and what is the effect of misassignment?

Response

Thank you for giving us the opportunity to clarify capability assignment. In our design, the Planner uses the atomic capability definitions to decompose a complex problem into subproblems and assigns one primary capability to each atomic unit. The primary capability describes the operation needed to produce the unit's main output. A single unit may still draw on several kinds of mathematical knowledge. For example, extracting relations from a diagram and solving for an unknown can be decomposed into visual relation extraction, modeling, and calculation. When the immediate goal is to produce a constraint equation relating the variables, we assign Modeling Transformation as that unit's primary capability.

We agree that the Planner can still assign an inappropriate label. We check each atomic unit after execution and use the resulting evidence when deciding how to proceed. Modify can revise the primary capability. Replan can update the steps that depend on the affected unit. This allows the agent to correct an assignment using the actual execution result while preserving the parts of a valid decomposition that can still be used. The following example illustrates the effect of an incorrect assignment and how the agent can recover.

  1. Input and intended output. The diagram shows that AB=ACAB=AC, with the two lengths given as 2x+12x+1 and x+5x+5. The current unit should produce the constraint 2x+1=x+52x+1=x+5.
  2. Misassignment. If the Planner assigns Calculation, the Executor may return x=4x=4 immediately and omit the constraint equation that the next unit needs.
  3. Verifier feedback and repair. The verifier can flag the missing equation. The Planner can then use Modify to assign Modeling Transformation, allowing the unit to produce the required constraint.
  4. Dependent calculation. The successor Calculation unit receives the equation and solves it to obtain x=4x=4.

This example shows how the system uses execution feedback to make a local repair. Estimating the effect of misassignment on overall accuracy would require a trajectory-level analysis or a label perturbation experiment. We have added the example to the revised manuscript to make the assignment and recovery mechanism easier to follow.

Revised manuscript. We revise the Atomic Capability-Grounded Planner in Page 5, Line 243-247 and illustrative capability reassignment in Page 15, Line 762-767.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 8jEY (Part 3/3)

Q2: Why not compare against Atom of Thoughts and SCoT?

Response

Thank you for drawing our attention to these closely related methods. We agree that both are relevant to our work and have added a comparison to make the relationship clearer. AoT organizes reasoning around self-contained states and uses atomic decomposition to reduce dependence on prior reasoning history. SCoT organizes multimodal reasoning into minimal semantic atomic steps and combines data construction, training, and multi-turn inference. We share their interest in how atomic decomposition can support complex reasoning. Atom of Thoughts, SCoT / AtomThink.

Our focus is on systematically connecting atomic reasoning steps to the fundamental capabilities used in mathematical problem-solving. At inference time, the atomic unit ties the mathematical capability to an agent operation and provides a shared interface for the subgoal, execution strategy, and validation conditions. The same unit carries this information through planning, execution, and feedback. We believe this capability-to-operation connection is a distinctive aspect of our work. The revised discussion explains the design difference and the mathematical settings it is intended to serve. An empirical comparison under matched conditions remains open.

Revised manuscript. We supplement the Related Work in Page 3, Line 145-149.

Thank you again for your constructive feedback. Your questions about the taxonomy and intermediate reasoning helped us clarify what the system is designed to do and what the results establish. We hope the revised explanations and additional evaluation address your concerns. The corresponding clarifications and results are marked in the revised manuscript and will be reflected in the camera-ready version.

Reviewer_YH3cOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduce AtomMath-Agent, a Unified Math Agent based on atomic capability-grounded reasoning unit, which comprises one mathematical atom-goal paired with an atomic capability. Agent's planner forms these units a dependency graph shared by planning, execution, and memory. The atomic unit also defines a verification protocol based on it mathematical atomic capability. Across seven backbones and six math benchmarks, AtomMath-Agent improves text-only and multimodal accuracy by 5.0 and 4.4 points on average. They also present matched-tool comparisons, component ablations, token plots, for agentic mid-training.

Critical strengths

1、Experiment and matched-tool comparisons. The average increaces on seven backbones and tool-matched comparisons against generic agents suggest that, the method can support the roles of atomic units and replanning.

2、Mechanism-decomposed ablations. Experiments that replace capability semantics with generic labels, coarsen the taxonomy, remove replanning, or disable tools may provide more support for the proposed decomposition than an overall results alone.

3、A potentially reusable math abstraction. The atomic unit explicitly packages the mathematical subgoal, capability, dependencies, output schema, and verification contract, which can make failures more localized and make trajectories easier to inspect than an unconstrained reasoning transcript.

Critical weaknesses

1、Experiments do not fully isolate the typed representation from inference budget and prompt engineering. A shared tool list, token limit, and maximum number of iterations do not establish equality in realized input/output token counts, number of tool calls, or prompt information. Figure 4 reports different token budgets, but the full capability taxonomy may contribute richer task-specific instructions than the generic-label baseline.

2、Claim of novelty. The atomic node resembles existing structured planning with verifier patterns, the main advantage may be disciplined specification of existing components. The agentic-training extension uses relatively narrow tasks, so statements that it proves atomic capability-grounded reasoning as a unified thought maybe too strong.

3、The critique for chain-of-thought and agents maybe not tested directly enough. The introduction invokes overthinking, local optima, and mismatch between planning and execution, yet the experiments predominantly report final accuracy and token/latency totals, but do not quantify the proposed failure mode (eg. dependency violations, repeated dead ends). This may weaken the motivation to mechanism and measured benefit.

Questions for authors

1、Can you compare against a generic dependency-DAG planner? It receives exactly the same prompt but omits the explicit capability labels. This would better isolate whether capability grounding, rather than richer instructions, causes the increaces.

2、Which atomic checks are deterministic and which are model-judged? and what fraction of verification judgments were independently validated?

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer YH3c (Part 1/2)

Thank you for recognizing our cross-model results, tool-matched comparisons, and ablations. We appreciate the opportunity to clarify and explain what the results tell us about the design.

W1 & Q1: Experiments do not fully isolate the typed representation from inference budget and prompt engineering. Can you compare against a generic dependency-DAG planner that receives exactly the same prompt but omits explicit capability labels?

Response

Thank you for raising this point. We agree that removing explicit capability labels while keeping the information in the prompt fixed would help isolate the contribution of the capability labels. We included two related Atomic DAG ablations in Table 3. Atomic DAG with Generic labels retains the dependency DAG and provides generic mathematical capability names while omitting the specific definitions. The resulting DAG provides a workable reasoning structure, and the experimental results show a further improvement when the full capability definitions are provided. In our case analysis, we observed that, without specific definitions, the model sometimes merged operations that could be executed independently or split a single operation too finely, creating redundant steps.

Table 3 also reports the Coarse Structure ablation. This setting uses broader atomic capability labels and omits the full capability-definition fields and tool-description metadata. Relative to this setting, the full method improves text and multimodal performance by 2.8/2.5 percentage points on Qwen3-8B-VL and 5.7/1.6 points on Gemini-3-Flash. The two ablations provide evidence for the contribution of the full specification from the perspectives of capability semantics and classification granularity. For ease of reference, we include the relevant results below.

Table 3 settingQwen3-8B-VL TextQwen3-8B-VL Multi.Gemini-3-Flash TextGemini-3-Flash Multi.
Atomic DAG + Generic labels25.742.958.867.6
Atomic DAG + Coarse Structure27.543.258.570.3
Full AtomMath-Agent30.345.764.271.9

These results give us confidence in the value of supplying concrete mathematical capability information. The comparison proposed by the reviewer would complement these ablations by isolating the effect of the label alone. We have clarified this distinction and the scope of the budget controls, highlighted the relevant ablation results, and aligned the tool-matched comparison with the corresponding Generic decomposition.

Revised manuscript. We highlight the comparison and Ablation Study in revised manuscript in Page 8, Line 388-390 and Page 8, Line 405-412.

W2: The atomic node resembles existing structured planning with verifier patterns. The training extension may not establish a unified thought.

Response

Thank you for this constructive suggestion. It helped us describe the contribution of our work more precisely. Our main motivation comes from how people often approach complex problems by breaking them into concrete, smaller units [1-2]. To account for the characteristics of mathematical reasoning, we associate these units with different mathematical atomic capabilities. We use these capabilities to organize the intermediate reasoning process and give it a clearer mathematical structure. The capability type and atomic reasoning unit form a shared interface for the Planner, Executor, and Verifier, so that the execution and checking of each subgoal focus on the same mathematical operation. In this sense, the agent reasons through atomic units, with a defined mathematical role for each step.

To examine how this organization could benefit mathematical reasoning, we evaluated the agent's problem-solving performance and generated a large collection of atomic reasoning trajectories to train a model and evaluate it on different tasks. The training results give us evidence beyond the agent's use of skills at inference time. They suggest that atomic organization provides a useful structure for training trajectories and that some of the reasoning behaviors captured in those trajectories can transfer to the base model through training. We believe this is a meaningful benefit of organizing the reasoning process itself around atomic capabilities.

We also agree that the training conclusion should be stated more narrowly. In the extended training comparison, the six-dimension average increased from 52.48 with generic trajectories to 56.11 with structured trajectories. The gains were concentrated in mathematical **Planning ** and Feedback. Tool and Code showed smaller improvements of 0.22 and 1.25, respectively, while Deep Research declined slightly. We have revised the wording to reflect this result. Structured mathematical atomic trajectories primarily improve planning and feedback in the current training setup and show evidence of transfer on some tasks outside mathematics.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer YH3c (Part 2/2)

Revised manuscript. We revise the manuscript accordingly in Page 1, Line 014-015 and 029-030, Page 2, Line 100-101, Page 3, Line 111-112, Page 8, Line 429-431, and Page 9, Line 484-485.

[1] Atomic Thinking of LLMs: Decoupling and Exploring Mathematical Reasoning Abilities, NeurIPS 2025. [2] AtomThink: Multimodal Slow Thinking With Atomic Step Reasoning, TPAMI 2026.

W3: The introduction invokes overthinking, local optima, and planning–execution mismatch, but these failure modes are not quantified.

Response

Thank you for this valuable suggestion. In the Introduction, we discussed how chain-of-thought models and existing agent methods approach reasoning. Observations from their execution traces suggested several recurring failure modes that could affect final-answer accuracy. These observations motivated our design. We organize planning around mathematical atomic capabilities to reduce repeated attempts and help the agent move beyond an unsuccessful local strategy. The shared atomic unit also helps the Planner communicate the requirements of each subgoal to the Executor and guides the Executor toward an appropriate operation.

We agree that final-answer accuracy and total token use alone provide limited evidence about these behaviors. We therefore supplemented the case analysis with a human evaluation. We sampled the same 100 problems across the methods and invited three experts to review their complete reasoning trajectories under blinded conditions. The experts examined the quality and logical consistency of intermediate steps, the use of invalid premises, overthinking, and invalid tool calls. For overthinking, we distinguished a repeated attempt at a failed approach that adds no new evidence from a productive verification step. This distinction allows a longer trajectory to contain useful reasoning and checks. The results are presented below.

MethodLogical consistency ↑Invalid premise references ↓Repeated steps without progress ↓Invalid tool calls ↓
Gemini-3-Flash0.860.150.27—
OctoTools0.880.220.210.36
AtomMath-Agent0.910.090.160.29

AtomMath-Agent performed better on the measured failure modes in this sample. Its trajectories were more logically consistent, cited invalid premises less often, and repeated fewer steps without progress than the two comparison methods. They also had fewer invalid tool calls than OctoTools. We appreciate your suggestion to examine the reasoning process directly and have added the evaluation and analysis to the revised manuscript.

Revised manuscript. We revise the Introduction and Case Study in Page 2, Line 074-080 and Page 9, Line 571-573, and supplement the experiment in Page 21, Line 1115-1128 and Page 22, Line 1134-1141.

Q2: Which atomic checks are deterministic and which are model-judged? What fraction was independently validated?

Response

Thank you for asking us to clarify how the checks are performed. All contract checks in our current system are performed by an LLM. The verifier prompt explicitly supplies the check conditions for the relevant atomic capability. The verifier receives the atomic unit, its validation conditions, the execution result, and the available evidence in memory. It uses these inputs to assess operational success, local validity, and global completion. Results returned by tools can provide evidence for these checks. The verifier itself makes the judgment.

The purpose of the contract is to focus that judgment on the mathematical requirements of the current operation. For example, a Calculation unit may require checking the domain, substituting candidate values, and identifying extraneous roots. A Theorem Application unit may require checking each of the theorem's premises and whether the theorem applies to the current case. We use contract-based verification in this sense of model-based verification guided by capability-specific criteria. The conditions help the verifier identify a specific reason for failure and provide feedback for Retry or Replan. The checks remain subject to model error, and we have clarified the role of tool evidence in the revised manuscript.

The blinded review described above assesses reasoning trajectories. A separate independent-validation rate for individual verifier judgments is not reported in the current evaluation.

Revised manuscript. We revise the Validation, Feedback, and Memory in Page 6, Line 307-310, Contract-Aware Feedback Page 15, Line 776-780, and Limitations in Page 23, Line 141-1242.

Thank you again for your thoughtful comments. We hope the clarifications and additional process evaluation address the concerns you raised. The corresponding changes are highlighted in the revised manuscript, and we will carry them through to the camera-ready version.

Thanks for the responses, these concerns can be further remedied.

Thank you for your reply and for taking the time to consider our responses. We appreciate your feedback and would welcome any further questions or specific concerns you would like us to address. We would be happy to provide additional clarification and further improve the manuscript.

Comments on the paper

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Friendly Reminder for Discussion

Dear Reviewers,

As the discussion period draws to a close, we wanted to follow up on the rebuttal we posted earlier. We would appreciate any feedback you may have while there is still time for us to address remaining concerns. If you have any further questions or would like clarification on any point, please let us know. We sincerely thank the reviewers and the Area Chair for your time and effort throughout the review process.

Sincerely, Authors of Manuscript 14110

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of Rebuttal and Discussion

Dear Area Chair and Reviewers,

We sincerely thank you for the time and effort devoted to our submission. As the discussion period draws to a close, we would like to summarize the main contributions, our responses and revisions to the reviews, and the discussions made to the manuscript.

1. Core contributions

AtomMath-Agent organizes mathematical reasoning through mathematical atomic capability units that jointly specify agentic behavior with subgoal and mathematical capability. The atomic unit provides an interface for planning, execution, and feedback, allowing each stage to refer to the mathematical capability requirements.

Across seven backbones and six benchmarks, our framework improves text-only and multimodal accuracy by 5.0 and 4.4. Tool-matched comparisons and ablations examine the contributions of atomic capability and reasoning structure. The structured trajectories also support model mid-training, increasing the six-dimension average from 52.48 to 56.11, with the largest gains in mathematical planning and feedback.

2. Summary of responses and revisions

We submitted detailed responses to all three reviewers and incorporated the corresponding clarifications and additional experiments into the revised manuscript. We are encouraged that Reviewer 8jEY and iDkv explicitly acknowledges that the rebuttal has strengthened the paper and solved most concerns. The remaining requests in the latest feedback mainly concern the detailed analysis of the implementation and the need for more comparative experiments. In response, we have now added substantive answers with new quantitative analysis and experimental results comparison, and are awaiting further reviewer feedback.

ReviewerStatusConcernsResponses and revisions
YH3cScore 2; no new questions1. Separating results from generic DAG planning; 2. novelty and training claims; 3. direct assessment of failure modes; 4. verifier judgments.1. Conduct the Generic labels and Coarse Structure ablations and clarified what they establish (p. 8, lines 388–390 and 405–412). 2. Refined the contribution and training claims to reflect the strongest gains in planning and feedback (p. 8, lines 429–431). 3. Added an expert evaluation of intermediate reasoning (pp. 21–22, lines 1115–1128 and 1134–1141). 4. Clarified that all contract checks are LLM judgments guided by capability-specific criteria (p. 6, lines 307–310; p. 15, lines 776–780).
8jEYScore 2, W2 substantially alleviated; further analyses awaiting feedback1. granularity of the eleven capabilities; 2. intermediate reasoning quality; 3. capability-assignment reliability and impact; 4. empirical comparison with AoT and SCoT.1. Expanded the taxonomy rationale (p. 13, lines 680–689) and 2. added the expert process evaluation (pp. 21–22, lines 1115–1128 and 1134–1141), which the reviewer explicitly acknowledged. 3. Our further response adds the 30-trajectory audit, a misassignment-impact example, and future assignment improvements (p. 22, lines 1142–1150 and 1161–1175; p. 23, lines 1225–1227). 4. Added experiment results comparisons with AoT/SCoT (pp. 22–23, lines 1176–1205).
iDkvScore 2, Baseline concern resolved; further verifier clarification awaiting feedback1. Contract-aware implementation; 2. provenance of the displayed log; 3. Gemini settings.1. Documented the Gemini medium/20K setting, the separate 42K Base setting and its 57.2% accuracy (p. 20, lines 1026–1057); the reviewer confirms that this concern is resolved. 2. Our further response acknowledges that the earlier-version log was mistakenly retained and adds a simplified excerpt from a log of the latest implementation consistent with B.2 (p. 23, lines 1202–1210; p. 24, lines 1242–1295).

3. Closing Summary

We have made every effort to respond to each concern through detailed explanations, additional evaluation, and revisions highlighted in blue. Although some new questions have not yet received feedback, we believe that most concerns have been addressed, with specific improvements explicitly recognized by the reviewers. The remaining discussion has focused on method implementation and additional experimental comparisons, for which we have now provided further evidence and clarification. While we await feedback on these latest additions, we believe the paper has been substantially strengthened through the discussion, with clearer methodological descriptions, more direct evidence about intermediate reasoning, and broader comparisons.

We sincerely thank the reviewers and the Area Chair again for your careful assessment and valuable feedback, and respectfully ask that the additional evidence and revisions be considered in the final assessment. Thank you again for your dedication to maintaining the high standards of ICLR.

Sincerely,

The Authors of Submission 14110

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.