- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper asks whether different models have different effective reasoning behaviors. It induces candidate behaviors from correct and incorrect question-answering traces, labels their presence, and selects a model-specific Behavioral Strength Set using the difference in presence rates (Δ) and statistical tests. The authors then amplify these behaviors through prompt injection, behavioral reflection, supervised fine-tuning, or GRPO. Across nine settings spanning three open-weight models and three multi-hop QA benchmarks, the intervention selected on the discovery split improves over the baseline. The paper argues that the choice of intervention should match the type of behavior being targeted.
Critical strengths
- Valuable research question. The paper examines whether models have different effective reasoning behaviors and turns that idea into a measurable, actionable method. The question is clear and has practical value beyond applying the same reasoning strategy to every model.
- Broad experimental evaluation. The study covers three open-weight models, three multi-hop QA benchmarks, and four interventions, reporting EM/F1 and some confidence intervals. Volume-matched SFT and cross-model behavior-set ablations also probe the value of behavior-based selection and model specificity.
Critical weaknesses
- The reasoning is not fully justified. Behaviors that appear more often in correct traces are treated as model-specific reasoning strengths, and their amplification is taken to improve reasoning. Yet correlation does not establish that these behaviors cause correct answers. For example, explicitly committing to an answer may simply accompany a good answer. The current results do not adequately separate better reasoning from better answer presentation.
- The experiments do not fully support the proposed mechanism. Table 2 matches the number of ISA-SFT and vanilla SFT training examples but does not control for question difficulty, trace length, or answer format. In addition, the labeled discovery split is used both to induce candidate behaviors and to compute Δ. Without disjoint-sample validation and ablations by behavior category, alternative explanations involving data selection and sample reuse remain open.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors match question difficulty, trace length, and answer format when comparing ISA-SFT with vanilla SFT? How much gain remains when amplifying only answer-formation behaviors or only multi-hop reasoning behaviors?
- If candidate behaviors are induced and Δ is estimated on disjoint samples, how stable are the selected behavior sets and final gains?
2 comments
I appreciate the authors' responses and clarifications. The rebuttal has addressed some of my concerns and improved my understanding of the paper. I have decided to raise my rating to 3.
Responses to Reviewer UHq4
We appreciate the reviewer's positive assessment of the research question and the thoughtful comments.
W1 and Q1 (second question): Better reasoning or better answer presentation, and amplifying only one type of behavior.
To separate better reasoning from better answer presentation, we decomposed every test question that the selected intervention fixed, across all nine settings, by the quality of the baseline answer. A fix counts as a presentation fix if the baseline answer was already a near-match (token F1 ≥0.5 but not an exact match), and as a substantive fix if the baseline answer was wrong in content (F1 <0.5). 75% of fixes are substantive. Consistently, F1 gains track EM gains (+12.0 vs. +14.6 points on average), which would not hold if the gains came mainly from answer formatting. Gemma is the exception: most of its smaller gains on HotpotQA and MuSiQue are presentation fixes, which is consistent with its Strength Set consisting mainly of answer-formation behaviors (single-answer convergence, answer-minimization check).
Behavior discovery identifies behaviors that are associated with correct answers, and the effect of amplifying them is then measured directly by the interventions on held-out questions. To check that the associations are not simply a by-product of question difficulty, we compared correct and incorrect traces only within groups of questions from the same dataset and of similar difficulty, measured by how many of the other models answer the question correctly. Within these groups, 14 of 15 Strength-Set behaviors keep Δ≥0.10 and 13 of 15 remain significant after FDR correction. The gains of the steered models also hold on the hardest questions: on questions that no other model answers correctly, the selected intervention improves EM by 13.4 points (95% CI [10.4, 16.4]) across the nine settings.
Amplifying only reasoning or only answer-formation behaviors. We split each Strength Set into reasoning behaviors and answer-formation behaviors using a classification made by an independent LLM from the behavior definitions alone, and re-ran prompt injection on the test sets with each subset. These runs cover all nine settings, and we will share the results in a follow-up comment as soon as they are available.
W2 and Q1 (first question): Matching difficulty, trace length, and format in the SFT comparison.
We compared the ISA-SFT and vanilla-SFT training sets directly. They are matched in question difficulty (mean number of other models answering the question correctly: 2.6 vs. 2.6 for Llama, 2.2 vs. 2.1 for gpt-oss, 2.4 vs. 2.4 for Gemma) and in target length (median 686 vs. 668, 897 vs. 918, and 1,438 vs. 1,559 characters). Across models, both sets use identical prompt and answer formats and are drawn from the same model's correct training traces. Where example counts differ, the vanilla set is the larger one (gpt-oss +7%, Gemma +21%), which works against ISA-SFT rather than in its favor.
W2 and Q2: Disjoint validation, and stability of the selected behavior sets and final gains.
We recomputed behavior selection using only the 200-example train split of each model-dataset pair. All 15 behaviors in the paper's Strength Sets remain selected (Δ≥0.11, FDR-adjusted q≤0.004), and 14 of 15 remain selected when Δ is computed within each dataset. Repeating behavior induction three times on different samples of discovery traces recovers 76% of the Strength-Set behaviors per repeat (12 of 15 reappear as essentially the same behavior at least once). For the final gains, selecting the intervention on one half of the held-out data and evaluating it on the disjoint other half (2,000 random splits) picks the same intervention in 100% of splits for all gpt-oss settings and Gemma/RAMDocs. Where selection varies (Llama), the candidates are near-tied and the chosen intervention trails the best by 3.7 EM on average.