- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposed transform-aligned learned features by applying the attribute transform to learned spatial representation. Firstly, this paper claimed that the features exactly represent the first-order prediction term of a smooth nonlinear model, with a bounded Taylor remainder. Then, this paper incorporated TALF into a transform based attribute codec with explicit coefficient prediction and conditional residual entropy modeling. The codec is optimized under a unified coefficient domain rate distortion objective. Experiment demonstrates TALF improved the rate distortion performance.
Critical strengths
Strength:
-
The paper aims to address the problem that, in existing works, the attribute transform defines the coding targets without itself aligning learned spatial representation.
-
The paper gives a through review of the related works in this field.
Critical weaknesses
Weakness:
-
Fig 1 and Fig. 2 are of low quality, which seems to be synthesized by large model. I suggest to make these Figs more readable.
-
Many equations lack of indexing or numbering, which makes the paper difficult to read.
-
The paper lacks of qualitative result comparison, which make the improvement of the proposed model less convincing.
-
In line 189, the equation is expressed as first order plus second-order Taylor remainder. However, it is not clear why the x can be expanded like this. This equation lack of rigorous proof. Similarly, Eq. (5) is also not verified mathematically.
-
In the experiments, the paper lacks of encoding time and decoding time comparison with the existing works.
-
I did not find the paper does experiments on the human body dataset, such as Soldier, Longdress, etc. These sequences have very rich attributes, which should be used for demonstration.
Questions for authors
- Fig 1 and Fig. 2 are of low quality, which seems to be synthesized by large model. I suggest to make these Figs more readable.
- Many equations lack of indexing or numbering, which makes the paper difficult to read.
- The paper lacks of qualitative result comparison, which make the improvement of the proposed model less convincing.
- In line 189, the equation is expressed as first order plus second-order Taylor remainder. However, it is not clear why the x can be expanded like this. This equation lack of rigorous proof. Similarly, Eq. (5) is also not verified mathematically.
- In the experiments, the paper lacks of encoding time and decoding time comparison with the existing works.
- I did not find the paper does experiments on the human body dataset, such as Soldier, Longdress, etc. These sequences have very rich attributes, which should be used for demonstration.