- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors proposed a 2D learned speech compression with content-adaptive time-frequency modeling. In listening test, the proposed methods outperform BigCodec, MimiCodec, and FlowDec in MUSHRA test. The idea is promising. But the experiment is only on speech and lacks the generalization ability.
Critical strengths
-
The writing of Section 1 and Section 2 are clear.
-
The result of the method is promising from the listening test.
Critical weaknesses
-
The writing of Section 2 is not clear. I can not understand how the system is built from the current version.
-
There is a lack of definition of CA2D.
-
No code is available.
-
3.1, there is a lack of description how X is compressed to y. What shape is y?
-
3.1, In Fig. 2, there are channels of 256, 384, and 768. However, in the main text of 3.1, there is a lack of description of how the purple block of Fig. 2 is done. I do not understand where does the 256, 384, and 768 are concatenated, or where do they go.
-
3.2, what is the full name of CMIC? How Mamba will affect the result? What is the ablation if there are not Mamba block?
-
3.3, There are several symbols that are not easy to understand. Such as the symbols in line 3 of Section 3.3.
-
3.3, Is the equation in line 207 necessary? Is this a new contribution, or is it just from some other papers?
-
3.4 Is this some standard bitstream method?
-
Experiment. For speech, 16kHz, 24kHz, 48kHz do not make big difference. To verify the effectiveness of the method, it is better to evaluate on HiFI music as well. This is very important for a research on Codec.
Questions for authors
- See Critical weaknesses.
3 comments
Thanks the comments from the authors. I have read though it and keep my score unchanged.
Thank you for taking the time to review our responses. We have also released the inference code, pretrained weights, and an online demo to improve reproducibility. We would appreciate it if you could reconsider the Soundness score in light of these additions.
Making the system explicit: dimensions, symbols, and the bitstream
We thank the reviewer for the detailed comments.