- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SWA-IC, a multirate image compression model supporting 128 operating points. It combines sliding window attention, context feature reuse, growing channel groups, and generalized Gaussian entropy modeling to improve rate–distortion performance.
Critical strengths
- Strong results against recent compression methods.
- Good coverage of benchmarks and runtime comparisons.
- Useful ablations, especially for context feature reuse.
Critical weaknesses
- The novelty is limited. Most components are adaptations of existing methods.
- The much larger training dataset raises concerns about comparison fairness.
- Some ablations change model capacity, making the reported gains difficult to isolate.
- The 165M-parameter model also weakens the storage-efficiency motivation.
Questions for authors
- Would the improvements hold with matched training data and model capacity?
- Can the authors provide parameter-matched ablations for channel grouping and context feature reuse?
- What is the actual storage advantage over MixCompress, considering the full model size?
3 comments
Update: Response to Reviewer st8m
The new results are in (details in the general comment):
W2/Q1: Training data. SWA-IC trained on ImageNet-1k is on par or slightly better than the main model (+0.07% / −0.34% / −0.59% on Kodak / Tecnick / CLIC), as is a 400k-image subset (Sec. 4.1, App. A.7).
W3/Q2: Capacity-matched ablations. With one additional synthesis block, removing the context features still costs 8.50% (8.53% before). With equal channel groups at matched parameters, the gap is 5.19% (9.62% before). Table 2 lists parameters and decoding complexity for every row.
W4/Q3: Storage. The abstract and introduction now state that the storage argument applies to sets of single-rate models, and quantify the overhead of MixCompress's rate adaptation. App. A.5 gives the total sizes.
Do the new results, together with the storage clarification, address your concerns? We are happy to clarify anything that remains open.
The rebuttal addresses most of my concerns. I will raise my rating from 2 to 3.
Response to Reviewer st8m
We thank the reviewer for the feedback and the concrete questions.
W1: Novelty. We agree that the components build on prior work. The contribution is what their combination shows: sharing all network weights across 128 rates reaches state-of-the-art rate–distortion performance; reusing context features for synthesis gives a large gain; and the bimodal GGD shapes (Sec. 4.2.2) may explain why GGD helps more here than reported by Zhang et al. (2025).
W2/Q1: Training data. Retraining on ImageNet-1k and a 400k-image subset with otherwise identical settings is under way (see the general comment).
W3/Q2: Capacity-matched ablations. Capacity-matched controls are in training; the general comment lists the parameters and decoding complexity of the original variants and their controls.
W4/Q3: Storage. We agree that the storage argument applies to sets of single-rate models and will clarify this. One 165.1M-parameter checkpoint covers all 128 operating points; six checkpoints of the compared single-rate codecs need 397–716M.
MixCompress-MoD is slightly smaller (156.6M) because of its lighter cascaded LALIC backbone (66.1M); its rate-dependent experts and conditioning add 90.4M (+137%). SWA-IC shares all transform and context-model weights across rates, with 237.6k rate-specific parameters (+0.14%; gains and per-rate factorized priors). Our non-cascaded backbone, following DCVC-RT, uses wide features at low resolution and thus more parameters for a given compute budget; experts would add to it. At similar size, SWA-IC saves 5.00%, 5.04%, and 3.05% bitrate over MixCompress-MoD (Kodak, Tecnick, CLIC), offers 128 instead of six operating points, and decodes faster: MixCompress-MoD reports slightly slower decoding than LALIC, which is 1.7–3.4× slower than SWA-IC.