- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a LiDAR range image compression method called Proteus which is robust to bitstream truncation. The method dedouples the bitstream into two part (significant, and insignificant range bit-planes) and compresses independently. The method encodes the significant range bit-planes (SIG) with bits-back coder and the insignificant range bit-planes (INS) with FIFO range coding. In SIG, the mid sub-block is encoded and used as initial bits for coding of the head sub-block. In INS which can be truncated, the remaining bit-planes are ordered before the attribute bit-planes, so that the truncated range is zero-padded and the truncated attribute is predicted by a prediction head. Experiments on Waymo and SemanticKITTI show performance gains over previous G-PCC and Unicorn.
Critical strengths
The paper clearly formulates the problem and aligns with the goal of decoding the bitstream under truncated scenario.
The proposed method shows promising compression performance over previous methods.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited bitrate range. In real world scenario, the bandwidth for LiDAR transmission is often limited. But the SIG is fixed to the first 10 bit-planes, so the method cannot decode when the bitrate is lower than the size of SIG.
Q1. Please provide results with different split index (e.g., smaller SIG, such as the first 5), and compare with G-PCC and Unicorn at low bitrate such as 1 to 5 bpp.
- Unclear novelty. The proposed method is built on existing techniques. The bit-plane progressive coding corresponds to JPEG 2000, and bits-back coding corresponds to ArIB-BPS. The main difference from ArIB-BPS seems to be that the initial bits are moved from INS to the mid sub-block, which is hard to regrad as technical novelty.
Q2. Please clarify whether the first OP in Figure 5 is SIG coding only with INS truncated. If so, it shows the performance of the main contribution of the paper. Please compare the performance with ArIB-BPS, G-PCC, and Unicorn under the SIG only setting (without INS) by changing the split index (e.g., smaller SIG, larger SIG).
Questions for authors
See the Q1 and Q2.