1. Limited methodological novelty
My primary concern is the limited methodological novelty of the proposed approach.
The main contribution consists of replacing the MSA/RNA-FM input representations in RhoFold+ with pretrained ERNIE-RNA hidden states and attention maps. The downstream folding architecture, including the Evoformer, IPA-based structure module, coordinate conversion, and EGNN refinement, is largely inherited from RhoFold+.
Prior work, particularly DRfold2[1], has already demonstrated MSA-free RNA 3D structure prediction using pretrained RNA language models. Although RNAStructFold uses a different language model and feature integration strategy, the manuscript does not sufficiently establish what fundamentally new modeling insight is introduced beyond this existing paradigm.
I therefore consider the methodological contribution incremental, and the paper currently lacks convincing evidence that its specific architectural modifications provide a distinctive advantage.
2. Insufficient comparisons with existing MSA-free methods
A major weakness of the experimental evaluation is the absence of comparisons with relevant existing MSA-free RNA structure prediction methods.
The manuscript primarily compares RNAStructFold against RhoFold+, which relies on alignment-derived information. While this comparison is useful for examining the consequences of removing the MSA input from the original architecture, it is insufficient to establish the competitiveness of RNAStructFold among existing single-sequence prediction approaches.
Given the substantial overlap in the problem setting, a quantitative comparison with DRfold2 and other relevant methods on common benchmark targets is essential. Without such comparisons, it is difficult to assess whether the proposed framework offers any meaningful advantage over established MSA-free alternatives in either structural accuracy or computational efficiency.
3. Limited empirical evidence supporting the proposed approach
The reported results do not convincingly demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
According to Tables 1–3, RNAStructFold consistently underperforms RhoFold+ in average TM-score:
- RNA-Puzzles: 0.226 vs. 0.240
- CASP15: 0.100 vs. 0.134
- OrphanRNA: 0.067 vs. 0.124
Across all 47 reported evaluation records, the average TM-score decreases from 0.181 to 0.151.
The degradation on OrphanRNA is particularly concerning because the motivation for MSA-free prediction is especially relevant to RNA targets with limited homologous information. On this benchmark, RNAStructFold does not achieve any wins exceeding the stated TM-score comparison threshold. Although several individual RNA targets show substantial improvements, these examples do not establish consistent advantages across diverse targets.
At the same time, the paper lacks essential ablation studies. In particular, the authors do not separately evaluate the contributions of each component. These missing experiments make it difficult to determine whether attention-derived pair features provide meaningful structural information beyond simpler language-model representations.
Reference:
[1] Li Y, Feng C, Zhang X, et al. DRfold2 is a deep learning-based tool that enables efficient and accurate RNA structure prediction[J]. PLoS Biology, 2026, 24(2): e3003659.