- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors proposed La-Ribo, a generative pipeline for RNA sequence (co)-design, via geometry–latent flow matching. Besides the framework itself, this submission also includes a novel corpus of 168,561 RNA structures across experimental results and in silico generated data from OpenFold3, NuFold and trRosettaRNA2. In general, this is a comprehensive study with open-source code and most of the statements documented in this submission are supported by the quantitative results of various experiments.
Critical strengths
- A new dataset towards precision RNA generation (design) was included. Specifically, the authors managed to integrate both experimental and in silico structural data from different sources.
- A comprehensive appendix was well documented. Besides the promising dataset mentioned above, several general concerns (e.g., computational cost, details of the training strategy) have been addressed quantitatively.
Critical weaknesses
-
It is still UNCLEAR for me that why the three atoms (i.e., P, C4' and glycosidic N) are picked as sparse geometric anchors. Some supporting information needs to be added afterwards, to specify the reasons behind it. Compared with the similar strategy (i.e., C, Cα and N), widely applied in the field of protein design, I assume the authors are trying to identify the backbone atom(s) of each RNA base, which is pretty interesting and meaningful. However, something more efforts have to be made. Specifically, besides the finalized strategy and those options included in Table 11, have the authors ever tried any other amendments?
-
I notice that the authors chose to generated another batch of in silico data via trRosettaRNA2, based on the sequences from bpRNA-1m(90) and RNAStralign. I'm wondering if the authors ever applied other existing folding pipeline(s) to generate the corresponding 3D structures from the original sequences. If the answer is yes, I would be so happy if the authors could post the detailed comparisons afterwards. If the answer is no, several representative pipelines (e.g., AlphaFold3, Chai-1, Protenix) are highly recommended to be used to generated the 3D structural data. Additionally, a follow-up concern regarding those entries from NuFold: which species have been included in the final dataset?
Questions for authors
Please refer back to "Critical Weaknesses".
4 comments
Response to Reviewer EwQ6 (2/2)
Q2. Other folding pipelines for the bpRNA-1m(90)/RNAStralign structures.
For this subset we have so far completed structure prediction only with trRosettaRNA2. We plan to generate and release synthetic structures for this subset with other competitive predictors, such as Protenix. Given the data volume, we cannot complete this comparison within the rebuttal period, but we will release the corresponding datasets to the RNA community and provide a detailed comparison at that time.
Q3. Which species are in the NuFold subset?
The full NuFold database covers 48 species, and the final dataset retains 47 of them, obtained by mapping the source taxonomy identifiers to species level through NCBI Taxonomy. The species are: Danio rerio, Homo sapiens, Rattus norvegicus, Enterococcus faecium, Mus musculus, Zea mays, Glycine max, Oryza sativa, Schistosoma mansoni, Arabidopsis thaliana, Trichuris trichiura, Drosophila melanogaster, Escherichia coli, Caenorhabditis elegans, Strongyloides stercoralis, Brugia malayi, Shigella dysenteriae, Sporothrix schenckii, Salmonella enterica, Paracoccidioides lutzii, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Histoplasma capsulatum, Candida albicans, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Onchocerca volvulus, Madurella mycetomatis, Wuchereria bancrofti, Nocardia brasiliensis, Neisseria gonorrhoeae, Mycobacterium tuberculosis, Dictyostelium discoideum, Haemophilus influenzae, Mycobacterium ulcerans, Dracunculus medinensis, Mycobacterium leprae, Plasmodium falciparum, Staphylococcus aureus, Campylobacter jejuni, Helicobacter pylori, Methanocaldococcus jannaschii, Trypanosoma cruzi, Leishmania infantum, Fonsecaea pedrosoi, Trypanosoma brucei, Cladophialophora carrionii, Klebsiella pneumoniae and Streptococcus pneumoniae.
Re: Authors' Responses
Dear Authors,
I would love to say thank you for the detailed responses towards most of my concerns.
I hereby confirm you all that I WILL read each and every word of yours while considering my final recommendation.
Please feel free to post some more supporting information (if applicable) during the rebuttal period.
Reviewer EwQ6
Thank you for your note
Dear Reviewer EwQ6,
Thank you very much for your kind note. For convenience before the discussion period closes, we also posted a brief summary on the forum ("General Response to Reviewers and AC") that collects all rebuttal results in one place, including the scaffold and rotation ablations for your Q1 and the parameter-matched Base/Tri comparisons from the other threads.
Please let us know if there is anything else we can clarify.
Response to Reviewer EwQ6 (1/2)
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment and the constructive questions. In brief:
Q1. Why P, C4′ and glycosidic N, and have other options been tried?
Design rationale.
What we tried.
For this rebuttal we retrained the autoencoder (encoder and decoder) and the flow model for the following variants, with all other settings identical to Table 1, using the lighter Base architecture and RhoFold scoring:
RhoFold, 200 steps
Percentages; mean ± SD over three 600-structure sampling campaigns. The first row is the original model of Table 1; the other rows are retrained variants.
Results.
In this setting (Base architecture, 200 steps, RhoFold), P/C4′/N with a learned Q gives the highest value in every column.