- Rating
- 3(+2)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The authors introduce DuetRNA, a method based on dual-frame RNA structure modeling for unconditional generation of RNA biomolecules. A range of experiments suggests the usefulness of modeling dual rather than single RNA frames to improve generative modeling and structural robustness of deep learning methods developed for RNA. Empirically, dual frames seem to encode additional priors that help model RNA structures.
Critical strengths
- The authors identify a key issue in current RNA generative modeling work: a single choice of geometric nucleotide frame does not capture all of RNA's structural diversity for distribution learning.
- DuetRNA, the authors' new method based on this idea, features dual RNA nucleotide frame tracks to address this concern, supporting training and sampling in a straightforward manner.
- Empirically, DuetRNA's dual frames appear to improve unconditional generative modeling of single-chain RNA, suggesting future work may benefit from such a parametrization of RNA.
Critical weaknesses
- The authors do not empirically compare their method to a state-of-the-art baseline, RiboDiff [1]. This is necessary to ensure that DuetRNA is truly offering new capabilities beyond what existing methods offer for RNA generation.
- Dual frames do not seem to guarantee improved RNA structural modeling (in all cases). For example, if I'm understanding it correctly, Table 4 on Page 9 of the main text suggests that a sugar-GS-only frame parametrization offers considerably better structural accuracy for C1′–N9 and C1′–N1 bond lengths.
- Most importantly, the paper's writing style is hard to follow, as it appears to be at least partially LLM-generated. For instance, phrases such as
A complementary dual-frame reconstruction analysis...,Inter-residue O3′–P P99 deviation..., andThe present evidence is limited to...read like opaque LLM text. Additionally, Figure 1 in the paper is rather unexciting for an ML conference paper, since it simply reviews different ways of representing RNA nucleotide structures without any connection to ML itself. This makes the paper, to me, read more like an incremental (RNA biology-centric) improvement for a single RNA generation task instead of a compelling and expressive method for many RNA modeling contexts.
References:
[1] Li, X., Uehara, M., Su, X., Scalia, G., & Ji, S. (2026, April). A Joint Diffusion Model with Pre-Trained Priors for RNA Sequence-Structure Co-Design. In International Conference on Learning Representations (Vol. 2026, pp. 105615-105639).
Questions for authors
- Would the authors please rewrite the LLM-like phrases flagged in Weakness (3)?
- Are the authors planning on releasing open-source code for this? If so, how easy is the implementation to follow, since existing RNA generative models tend to produce very verbose and unintuitive code implementations?
Summary of Revisions and Final Discussion Status
Dear Area Chairs,
Thank you for overseeing the review of our submission. As the author–reviewer discussion period concludes, we briefly summarize the main concerns raised across the reviews, how we addressed them in the revised manuscript and follow-up responses, and the resulting discussion status.
DuetRNA couples base and sugar frames in a flow-matching model, using RNA-specific geometric priors to jointly generate sequences and all-atom structures. We are pleased that all three reviewers recognized the geometric motivation for this dual-frame representation and its empirical benefits. We addressed their concerns with the additional experiments, analyses, and revisions summarized below.
Frame representation and coupling (kmG3 and exCU). We repeated reconstruction with compatible decoders, trained a Base-only control, and tested the suggested bond-length/angle supervision. These experiments support the benefits of the dual-frame representation and relative-pose coupling (Tables 3–5; Appendix D.5).
Geometry and physical validity (all three reviewers). Joint validity and FR3D analyses confirm DuetRNA's gains over single-frame controls. We clarified glycosidic bond errors and specified a closed-form post-processing step. Training on curated data further improves backbone continuity and GS validity without architectural changes (Table 3; Appendix E.6).
External baselines (eQvA and exCU). We documented that RiboDiff's training/inference code and trained checkpoints were not publicly available. Our follow-up using RNA-FrameFlow outputs from Table 2 confirms DuetRNA's higher joint validity, including with bond-geometry filtering. We also report clash comparisons on a shared atom set.
Presentation (eQvA). We moved the model overview to Figure 1, reorganized Section 4, and clarified terminology and prose. We also explained training and sampling variability (Table 7) and the trade-offs between all-atom and frame-based generation.
As a result, following three rounds of discussion, Reviewer eQvA (Confidence: 4) raised their rating from 1 → 2 → 3 (Weak Acceptance) and confirmed they are inclined to accept the paper. Reviewer kmG3 (Confidence: 3) remains at 3 (Weak Acceptance). The revised manuscript addresses both technical questions with additional experiments and analyses. Reviewer exCU (Confidence: 3; Rating: 2) explicitly confirmed in their latest comment that Q1, Q3, and Q4 are resolved, leaving only the external-baseline joint-validity comparison, which we have now provided in our follow-up. At the time of writing, exCU has not yet responded to our follow-up, so we respectfully ask the Area Chairs to assess this evidence alongside the revised manuscript and the reviewers' updates.
Thank you for your time and careful consideration of our submission.
Best,
The authors