- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This manuscript proposes RNAcoder, a modification-aware framework for learning local all-atom representations of RNA nucleotides, base pairs, and consecutive dinucleotides. The approach uses EquiformerV3 encoders and MLP decoders to reconstruct atomic coordinates and chemical identities in the proposed RNAtom37 layout, producing continuous embeddings that serve as node and edge features in downstream RNA graphs. The authors report accurate local reconstruction and improvements over hand-crafted 2.5D graph features on small-molecule binding-site prediction, protein-interface prediction, and pocket-conditioned ligand-class prediction. Explicitly encoding nucleotide-pair geometry and accommodating chemical modifications are useful RNA-specific design choices, with ablations supporting the contribution of pair-level representations. However, improvements over other pretrained representations are task-dependent, and the downstream evaluations rely on experimentally resolved RNA structures, including protein-bound conformations for interface prediction. These results do not establish whether the learned representations remain useful with predicted structures or across different binding states, leaving their applicability beyond experimentally characterized RNAs unresolved. Overall, the manuscript provides evidence for a useful local geometric representation within structure-conditioned benchmarks, while the practical scope of its broader biological applications requires clearer justification.
Critical strengths
RNA-specific representation of nucleotide-pair geometry
Jointly encoding base pairs and consecutive dinucleotides is a meaningful RNA-specific design choice, allowing inter-nucleotide geometry to be represented explicitly as graph-edge features rather than relying solely on individual nucleotide embeddings. The ablation in Table 3 supports the usefulness of these pair-level representations: removing them reduces the reported AUC by 4.1, 1.7, and 6.2 percentage points on RNA-Site, RNA-Prot, and RNA-Ligand, respectively.
Explicit support for chemical modifications
RNAtom37 provides a common atomic reconstruction layout for standard and supported modified nucleotides, while the training objective explicitly distinguishes modification subtypes. This is a useful representation contribution because it retains chemical distinctions that would be lost by reducing every nucleotide to its canonical A/C/G/U identity.
Evidence of downstream utility
The evaluation goes beyond reconstruction accuracy to include three downstream tasks, comparisons with other pretrained representations, and ablations of the encoder and bottleneck design. The strongest result is on RNA-Prot, where RNAcoder achieves an AUC of , compared with for RiboSphere and for the stronger 2.5D baseline. These results provide evidence that the proposed local features can be useful within the evaluated structure-conditioned setting.
Critical weaknesses
The practical scope is insufficiently established
All three downstream evaluations assume experimentally resolved RNA structures, and RNA-Ligand additionally assumes an identified three-dimensional binding pocket. For RNA-Prot, the interface labels are derived from RNA–protein complexes, so the evaluation concerns identifying contacts from RNA conformations observed in the bound state. Removing protein atoms from the model input does not establish performance on an independently determined unbound RNA conformation. Consequently, the results demonstrate retrospective, structure-conditioned prediction, but do not establish applicability when the relevant RNA conformation is unavailable or changes upon binding. This does not invalidate the task, but it leaves the intended deployment setting and the significance of the broader biological applications insufficiently clear. The authors should identify concrete applications in which the required input structures are available; if applications beyond experimentally characterized conformations are intended, a focused evaluation using predicted structures or matched bound/unbound structures would help substantiate that scope.
The effective biological diversity of the training data remains unclear
Table 5 reports approximately 1.74 million nucleotide training samples extracted from 2,170 RNA units, but these counts alone do not establish the number of independent RNA families or structural environments represented. The tokenizer uses a temporal split rather than a family-based split, while the downstream benchmarks use structural clustering. The reported sampling strategy usefully addresses imbalance among local geometric categories, but does not by itself establish coverage across RNA families and protein-binding contexts. A breakdown of the training data by RNA family and binding context, counting both RNA units and sampled local environments, would make the effective diversity more interpretable. Where sample sizes permit, reporting existing downstream results separately for major RNA groups would also help determine whether the gains extend across biological contexts rather than primarily reflecting recurrent motifs in well-represented groups.
Questions for authors
The benefit of learned tokenization over directly supplied geometry is not fully isolated
The 2.5D baselines use nucleotide identities and discrete edge types, whereas RNAcoder supplies learned features derived from all-atom geometry. The pair-token ablation therefore supports adding pair-level information, but does not fully distinguish the benefit of pretraining from that of providing richer geometric inputs. Likewise, accurate coordinate reconstruction establishes fidelity to the input, but does not alone establish an advantage over directly computed geometric descriptors. A targeted comparison using local torsions, distances, and relative base orientations as features in the same downstream graph framework would clarify the additional value of the learned tokenizer. This would address the representation contribution more directly than adding further unrelated downstream tasks.
RNAcoder tokenizes base pairs and dinucleotides alongside single nucleotides, which fits RNA’s folding physics well, and RNAtom37 is a useful resource for modified nucleotides in its own right. My main objection was that the submitted ablation did not isolate the paper’s own thesis; the rebuttal fixes this with properly tuned controls against Leontis–Westhof edge types and 3DNA/NtC descriptors, where RNAcoder is ahead on RNA-Site and RNA-Ligand. The compositionality results are also now convincing, with the arithmetic surviving removal of L_atom and extending to base modifications, and the predicted-structure and COVID experiments widen the paper’s relevance considerably. My one remaining concern is RNA-Ligand, which was rebuilt mid-rebuttal with a leak fix and a baseline-input change applied together, leaving a large asymmetric swing unexplained. That is a presentation issue rather than a flaw in the method. I recommend acceptance, conditional on the RNA-Ligand ablation, the revised abstract, and the recalibrated downstream claims appearing in the camera-ready version