- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses the problem of object detection in foggy scenes and presents the BiDO (Bilevel Discriminative Learning with Online Synthesis) framework that integrates fog synthesis, dehazing, and object detection through bilevel optimization. The fog synthesis network generates foggy images with depth-aware global synthesis and object-guided local modulation. The task model is trained for image restoration and object detection together. Results on RTTS and Foggy Driving show that the proposed framework improves performance compared to previous work.
Critical strengths
- BiDO achieves strong detection performance on real foggy benchmarks, with consistent improvements across nine dehazer-detector combinations in Table 4.
- The ablation studies show the effectiveness of the proposed components. BiDO also shows promising results with limited training samples in Table 6.
Critical weaknesses
-
I think the justification for bilevel optimization is not sufficient. The proposed framework needs to be compared with simple alternatives, such as online adversarial augmentation [1] and curriculum-based fog training [2]. These comparisons would help clarify whether the proposed formulation provides benefits.
-
Also, the contribution of the proposed bilevel optimization to the reported performance gains is not clear. Although BiDO substantially outperforms existing methods on RTTS (0.337 vs. 0.246 mAP), its single-level baseline already achieves 0.318 mAP. The authors should clarify which components account for the large improvement over existing methods, particularly given the differences in training protocols.
[1] X. Chen et al., "Robust and Accurate Object Detection via Adversarial Learning," CVPR 2021.
[2] C. Sakaridis et al., "Model Adaptation with Synthetic and Real Data for Semantic Dense Foggy Scene Understanding," ECCV 2018.
Questions for authors
- In Sections 3.2 and 5.2, the authors explain that object-guided local modulation enables more targeted fog degradation around objects. However, the global module already generates a spatially varying density field using depth information. Could the authors clarify the additional benefit of bounding-box guidance and compare it with spatially varying fog synthesis without object guidance?
- The authors claim in Figure 1 that bilevel optimization encourages flatter minima. Could the authors provide empirical evidence supporting this claim?