- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes BiCo, which explicitly coordinates pixel-level enhancement and semantic-level perception under low light via bilevel optimization. It designs two role-balanced evaluators that provide complementary quality and semantic feedback, optimizes the enhancer at the upper level while alternating the two evaluators at the lower level, and adopts a two-stage scheme of cross-task collaboration plus task-specific adaptation.
Critical strengths
The bidirectional bilevel modeling is a substantive improvement over one-way cascading. The hierarchical dependency between the upper-level enhancer and the two lower-level evaluators is explicitly modeled, and V-PBGD avoids differentiating through the alternating trajectory, achieving mutual feedback between pixel and semantic objectives with tractable computation.
Critical weaknesses
- Only two downstream tasks are covered. The cross-task conclusions of CTC and TSA are validated only between detection and segmentation, with no extrapolation to keypoints, depth estimation, or video tasks, leaving the boundary of transferability unclear.
- A direct comparison with the Lipschitz-view restoration-detection synergy work of Zhao et al. 2025 is missing, although it is the closest in motivation and is only mentioned in related work without experimental comparison.
- Enhancement quality evidence is limited and not fully independent. Visual quality relies only on no-reference IQA metrics, which give inconsistent rankings, and CLIP-IQA overlaps with the CLIP-based guidance used in training. Paired-reference metrics or a human study would better support the claim.
Questions for authors
- Can you provide reference-based PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS to verify pixel-level fidelity of the enhancement?
- Do the cross-task conclusions generalize beyond detection and segmentation, for example to keypoint estimation or video understanding?
- How does BiCo compare numerically with the Lipschitz-based synergy method of Zhao et al. 2025 under the same settings?
2 comments
Dear Reviewer 6Xap,
Could you check if the response has addressed your issues? Since the discussion is closing soon, your reply would be very important.
Best,
AC
Response to Reviewer 6Xap
Table 1: Quantitative comparison of full-reference image quality on the MIT dataset.
Q1: Can you provide reference-based PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS to verify pixel-level fidelity of the enhancement?
Response: Our main focus is joint enhancement-perception learning, where the enhancer is trained without paired reference images, reducing dependence on supervised pixel-level reconstruction and favoring broader downstream applicability. Nevertheless, following the reviewer's suggestion, we additionally evaluate full-reference fidelity on the standard MIT test set, consisting of 500 paired samples [1], using PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS.
As shown in Table 1, BiCo achieves the best SSIM and LPIPS and the second-best PSNR among the compared methods. These results demonstrate that, despite being optimized without paired supervision, BiCo preserves strong pixel-level fidelity while simultaneously supporting downstream semantic perception.
[1] Ma L, Ma T, Xu C, et al. Learning with self-calibrator for fast and robust low-light image enhancement[J]. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 2025.
Table 2: Quantitative comparison of joint image enhancement–instance segmentation (En + In) and joint image enhancement–depth estimation (En + Dep).
Q2: Do the cross-task conclusions generalize beyond detection and segmentation?
Response: We further evaluate BiCo on two additional downstream tasks. For comparison, we select the five top-performing competing enhancers based on their average detection and segmentation performance in Table 2 of the manuscript. Specifically, instance segmentation is evaluated on the RGB-Dark split of LIS [1] using RF-DETR-Seg Small [2], while monocular depth estimation is evaluated on nuScenes-Night [3] using Depth-Anything-V2-Metric-VKITTI-Base [4]. For all methods, the enhancers are kept fixed, and only the downstream task networks are fine-tuned. As shown in Table 2, BiCo achieves the best downstream performance on both tasks while maintaining competitive enhancement quality, further demonstrating the transferability of its learned meta-representations across diverse downstream tasks.
[1] Chen, et al., "Instance Segmentation in the Dark," IJCV 2023.
[2] Robinson, et al., "RF-DETR: Neural Architecture Search for Real-Time Detection Transformers," ICLR 2026.
[3] Zheng, et al., "STEPS: Joint Self-supervised Nighttime Image Enhancement and Depth Estimation," ICRA 2023.
[4] Yang, et al., "Depth Anything V2," NeurIPS 2024.
Table 3: Quantitative comparison with the Lipschitz-based restoration-detection synergy method of Zhao et al. on ExDark.
Q3: How does BiCo compare numerically with the Lipschitz-based synergy method of Zhao et al. 2025 under the same settings?
Response: We additionally compare BiCo with Lipschitz-based synergy method LR-YOLO under the same ExDark setting. As shown in Table 3, BiCo consistently outperforms LR-YOLO in both enhancement quality and detection performance.