- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TileSkipper, a region-adaptive tile pruning method for accelerating 3D Gaussian Splatting. It uses offline calibration to assign different contribution thresholds to Gaussian groups, reducing Gaussian-tile pairs without modifying the original Gaussians. Experiments across 13 scenes and multiple rasterizers show modest rendering speedups with little impact on rendering quality.
Critical strengths
The main strength of this paper is its thorough and transparent experimental evaluation. The authors provide extensive ablation studies, comparisons across different rasterizers, and detailed performance breakdowns. They also clearly separate the speedup from existing techniques and the actual contribution of their method, and openly discuss its limitations and negative results. This makes the experimental results more convincing and easier to assess.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited Practical Speedup The actual rendering speedup is relatively small, especially when compared with already optimized rasterizers, Table 1 reports only 1.096× on Speedy-Splat. Compared with AdaGScale, the improvement is only 1.010× at standard resolution (Table 3). Also, much of the reported speedup over vanilla 3DGS comes from existing opacity-aware bounding techniques rather than TileSkipper itself. These results make me question whether the additional complexity is justified by the practical performance gains.
-
Insufficient Justification for Regional Adaptation Table 2 shows that the proposed regional strategy achieves almost the same rendering performance as directly assigning thresholds to individual Gaussians. Regional adaptation improves over a global threshold, but it is unclear what additional benefits the proposed region grouping and allocation strategy provides compared with simpler per-Gaussian threshold selection.
-
Missing Relevant Work The paper does not discuss FilterGS[1] (cvpr 2026), which also focuses on reducing redundant Gaussian-tile pairs for efficient rendering. Although the two methods target somewhat different settings, I believe this work should at least be discussed to better clarify the novelty of TileSkipper.
[1] FilterGS: Traversal-Free Parallel Filtering and Adaptive Shrinking for Large-Scale LoD 3D Gaussian Splatting
Questions for authors
My main questions concern the novelty over existing methods, the limited practical speedup, and the necessity of regional adaptation, as discussed in the Critical Weaknesses section.