- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces TangoGS, a density control framework for 3D Gaussian point clouds designed to automatically adapt the number of Gaussian primitives across different acquisition scales. The method first estimates the learning margin by adjusting the total input pixels and the average SfM trajectory length. During optimization, the PSNR of training views is used to regulate the densification target and pruning intensity. Finally, a sensitivity-based pruning step determines which Gaussian primitives to retain.
The proposed method is evaluated on 13 standard benchmark scenes and 8 larger-scale scenes, compared against 13 published baseline methods. Results show comparable quality-size trade-offs on standard scenes, while achieving improved reconstruction quality on larger-scale scenes—all without requiring scene-specific re-tuning.
Critical strengths
-
This article employs a simple approach to achieve better control over the number of Gaussians, by using all the pixels and the track length to determine the initial upper limit for optimizing the number of Gaussians.
-
The concept of capacity allocation under capture conditions and adaptive allocation based on training quality is clearly defined and easy to integrate into the existing 3DGS pipeline. This paper includes component-level reduction experiments, comparison of matching counts with LiteGS, alternative capture statistical methods, redundant view experiments, and portability tests for another implementation. These experiments provide certain support for the practical application of the proposed controller.
Critical weaknesses
-
This article aims to enable the automatic adjustment of the optimization amount of Gaussian quantities, thereby avoiding the need for manual setting of the Gaussian quantity in the optimization process. However, the adopted method will automatically introduce other parameters that require manual setting in Equation (2) (Line 140)
-
The relationship between the proposed control signal and the required representational capacity lacks sufficient justification. This method relies on two heuristic mappings: there is a square root relationship between the trajectory adjustment pixels and the learning tolerance, and there is a linear relationship between the training PSNR and the retention rate. Although these rules have empirical basis, the paper does not adequately explain why they should be able to be generalized to images under different observation quality, geometric structure, or photometric consistency.
-
The images and tables in the article make it difficult to distinguish the author's contributions. For instance, in Figure 4, the purple F dots and the star of TangoGS are always very close to each other, making it hard to tell from this ablation study whether the proposed module in the article can have a significant effect. Moreover, in the table in the supplementary materials, the lack of bold font annotations makes it difficult to discern the quality of the data.
-
This paper reads like an incremental improvement from previous paper without significant insights and looks like not enough for ICLR venue.
Questions for authors
- In Figure 1 (a), at the bottom of "Learning allowance", there is a text "sublinear mapping". What does this mean?
- In line 147, you used the statistics of 13 scenarios to set T_ref and T_lin. How do you ensure their generalization ability in other standard scenarios? Can their generalization ability be demonstrated through ablation experiments? And are the hyperparameters in Equation (3) also empirical values? For example, s = 1.7, c = 0.0075, P = 20 dB, etc.
- In your ablation study figure 4, does point F indicate that your method has degenerated into LiteGS? If so, based on the data in the graph, in the standard scenes, the two are very close. For large scenes, your method needs to achieve approximately a 0.6dB improvement with about 2 times the number of Gaussians, while SSIM and LPIPS hardly change. Is this because you used the PSNR signal to supervise the learning allowance? Why did you choose PSNR for supervision and can other metrics be used for supervision instead? What kind of changes would there be if different metrics are used for supervision?
We thank the reviewer for their feedback!
Introducing new constants in TangoGS
The goal of our technique is to remove the dependency of 3DGS techniques on constants that require retuning per scene (such as gradient thresholds) or per capture scale and replace them with a technique that is demonstrably transferable across scenes and across capture scales, since there cannot be a technique that is completely free of parameters. We will make this clear in the paper.
Justification of functional forms (X~ and linear ρ(P))
Our intuition for these two design choices is to use the lowest-order monotonic parameterizations so that a single calibration on standard scenes transfers without tuning across capture scales:
Why ρ(P) is linear in PSNR (Eq. 3): Because PSNR=−20log10(RMSE), a linear function of PSNR is a logarithmic function of reconstruction error (RMSE), reducing capacity proportionally to the orders of magnitude of remaining error as convergence progresses. The floor P∗=20 dB corresponds directly to RMSE=0.1 (10 error), below which terminal pruning is disabled.
Why Tcap scales with X~ (Eq. 2): Because 3D Gaussians are multi-scale primitives (one large Gaussian can represent thousands of pixels on smooth surfaces while fine textures require dense primitives), required capacity grows sublinearly with observed surface X~. Taking the geometric mean Tcap=TrefTlin (β=0.5) is the parameter-free midpoint between a constant budget (β=0, e.g., LiteGS) and a linear budget (β=1).
We will add the intuition behind these choices, in addition to parameter ablations, to the paper to justify the specific design decisions.
Figure 4: What point F measures
F disables both proposed components: it uses a fixed 1M allowance and LiteGS's density-control rules, while keeping the shared training profile and the timing of densification and pruning fixed across the Figure 4 variants. It is therefore a controlled removal of both components; the released LiteGS baseline is evaluated separately.
Figure 4: Close results on standard scenes and value of quality improvement
The metrics are indeed close for standard scenes where the quality saturation point is already 1M (the preset budget used by point F in the ablation). For the transfer experiment on large scenes (lower part of Fig. 4), TangoGS gains 0.62 dB PSNR and 0.031 SSIM and lowers LPIPS by 0.044 over F. This change in SSIM and LPIPS is quite meaningful for observed visual quality. We reference a few published works [1–3] that have smaller quality improvements as their main gain.
Why PSNR feedback, and could other metrics replace it?
Training PSNR is already computed in training, so it is a natural choice for our work. Our experiments show that a single linear mapping to the keep ratio provides useful capacity feedback across the evaluated scenes without per-scene tuning. We additionally tested a combination of SSIM and PSNR as guiding feedback and found that we can achieve the same results with a simpler approach using only PSNR. LPIPS would be an interesting option to test in a context where the computational overhead can be comfortably afforded. We will add to the paper more justification for our design decisions in addition to insights regarding which versions of the feedback components failed and why. Comparing additional alternative feedback metrics would be an interesting direction for future work.
Meaning of “sublinear mapping” (Question 1)
This is referring to the square-root conversion Tcap=TrefgX~.
Generalization to other standard scenes and choice of constants
We designed TangoGS to perform as well as the best SOTA methods on the standard benchmarks, and this guided the choice of Tref and the empirically chosen constants s=1.7 and c=0.0075, while the main contribution is to show the transferability of these parameters across scales. For generalization, we rely on the representativeness of the benchmark results as an indication of how our technique performs on other captures of the same scale.
The lack of bold font annotations in supplementary tables
We will fix this. Thank you for the suggestion.
[1] Zheng Zhang et al. Pixel-GS: Density Control with Pixel-aware Gradient for 3D Gaussian Splatting. ECCV 2024. Table 1 reports +0.008 SSIM and −0.026 LPIPS on Mip-NeRF 360.
[2] Haosen Yang et al. Improving Gaussian Splatting with Localized Points Management. CVPR 2025. Table 1 reports +0.011 SSIM and −0.013 LPIPS on Mip-NeRF 360.
[3] Yanzhe Lyu et al. ResGS: Residual Densification of 3D Gaussian for Efficient Detail Recovery. ICCV 2025. Table 1 reports +0.013 SSIM and −0.017 LPIPS on Mip-NeRF 360.