- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
- VolS-GS decomposes Gaussian appearance into Lambertian diffuse reflection, anisotropic spherical-Gaussian specular reflection, and volumetric subsurface scattering (SSS), with shadow attenuation applied to direct reflection. This separates surface reflection from internal light transport to improve relighting of translucent objects.
- A differentiable finite-volume diffusion solver operates on occupancy derived from the Gaussian scene, enabling light propagation across primitives without mesh extraction. Its output is combined with a separate single-scattering term to model the subsurface response.
- The shadow model reads cues from the same transport field, while a shadow-aware specular regularizer reduces compensation between appearance branches. Experiments on three benchmarks report improved relighting quality over prior methods.
Critical strengths
- The volumetric solver explicitly couples light transport across Gaussians through the occupied medium, capturing nonlocal SSS that depends on object connectivity rather than only per-primitive appearance. A controlled substitution with a per-primitive dipole model reduces PSNR in six of seven scenes, supporting the benefit of this spatial coupling (Appendix G).
- The transport domain is derived directly from Gaussian occupancy, requiring neither mesh extraction nor separate trainable grid parameters. Adjoint differentiation avoids storing solver iterations, allowing the transport model to be optimized from images. The method also reports 64.5 FPS on five synthetic SSS objects at 256² resolution on an A6000, after transfer-basis precomputation (Appendix C).
- The shadow branch uses the same transport cues as SSS, while shadow attenuation is applied only to direct reflection to avoid attenuating the scattered contribution twice. A shadow-aware regularizer discourages the specular branch from absorbing transported light. Removing transport cues lowers Statue PSNR from 38.35 to 35.09 dB, while qualitative ablations support cleaner component separation (Table 2 and Appendix F).
Critical weaknesses
- The SSS transport domain is filled from Gaussians optimized for image reconstruction, whose surface positions and spatial extents may not accurately represent the physical boundary. Such errors could bridge narrow gaps, omit thin connections, or misclassify interior regions, altering SSS propagation. Their impact on the filled geometry and transport results is not directly evaluated (Sec. 2.3).
Questions for authors
- Have you considered the geometric inaccuracies of the learned 3DGS representation when constructing the filled transport domain? Please clarify how surface and connectivity errors are handled and evaluate their effects on the interior filling and SSS results.
3 comments
Thank you for addressing my concerns and clarifying the points I raised. I will maintain my Clear acceptance rating.
Official Comment by Authors to Reviewer LKnB
Dear Reviewer LKnB,
Thank you for the constructive suggestions and for maintaining your Clear acceptance rating. We are glad that your concerns have been addressed. Thank you for the time and care that you put into reviewing VolS-GS.
Best regards,
The Authors
First Rebuttal for Reviewer LKnB - W1/Q1
We sincerely thank Reviewer LKnB for the precise and thorough summary, and for the acknowledgement of the spatial coupling through the medium, the mesh-free transport domain and the shared transport cues of the shadow branch. The question about geometric error is an important one, and we address the weakness and the question below.
Reviewer LKnB - W1: Effect of geometric errors on the filled domain and on SSS
We agree that the transport domain inherits any geometric error of Gaussians, so its effect requires a direct evaluation which we now provide.
Effect on the filled domain. We voxelize the ground-truth solid from the original Blender meshes onto the same 643 grid and compare it with our domain cell by cell (Table 13). Please note that real captures have no ground-truth geometry, so this comparison uses the three synthetic scenes whose source meshes are available. Thin parts are kept (78 to 97% of the cells in parts under about three cells thick), and narrow gaps are rarely bridged (0 to 8.6% of the gap cells, excluding the one-cell band around the surface that the footprint covers by design). The largest disagreement is on Candle, whose underside faces away from all cameras and is therefore sparsely covered by Gaussians, so some interior cells near the base fall outside the domain (recall 0.84). Table 14 shows that this has no measurable cost. The domain deliberately extends about one cell past the surface (Table 11 in Appendix H), which accounts for part of the precision gap at this resolution.
Table 13. Learned domain against the ground-truth solid (643).
Effect on SSS. To measure the cost of the remaining geometric error, we replace our domain with the ground-truth solid and retrain from scratch, using it for both training and testing with everything else unchanged. The ground-truth domain changes PSNR by at most 0.17 dB on the three scenes, with no consistent sign (Table 14), even on Statue, whose learned domain agrees least with the ground truth. The ground-truth solid also lacks the one-cell extension past the surface that our domain has by design. The remaining geometric error therefore has no measurable cost on these scenes, because the diffused light varies smoothly and is insensitive to small errors of the domain boundary, while the per-Gaussian SSS amplitude kisss adjusts the fine detail on top of it.
Table 14. Transport domain learned from the Gaussians vs. the ground-truth solid, test PSNR (dB).
Reviewer LKnB - Q1: How such surface and connectivity errors are handled
We build the domain (Sec. 3.3, Sec. 2.3 in the submission) such that the typically expected errors of Gaussians fitted to images barely change its topology.
Their effects on the interior filling and on SSS are evaluated in our answer to W1 above (Tables 13 and 14).
Tables 13 and 14 are in the new Appendix H, and Appendix B describes the grid box, the footprint union, the dilation and the occupancy cutoff. Thank you again for this insightful question. We hope the rebuttal answers the reviewer’s concern and would be glad to provide further analysis if needed.
The Authors