- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Graph2TS, a structure-conditioned time series generation framework based on quantile graphs. The method represents temporal structure through first-order transitions between value-based quantile states and employs a conditional VAE to generate time series from graph embeddings and stochastic latent variables. A combined loss is used for training Graph2TS model, including reconstruction, KL regularization, contrastive alignment, and distribution-matching losses. Experiments on four datasets demonstrate good performance, particularly on ECG and CHB-MIT. Additional experiments investigate the effects of sequence length, structural conditioning, stochasticity, and quantile resolution.
Critical strengths
-
Incorporating quantile graphs as structural conditions for time series generation is an interesting and potentially novel direction, although converting raw time series to quantile has been used in the time series literature for a long time.
-
The proposed framework is easy to follow, with additional theoretical analysis providing a useful interpretation of the method.
Critical weaknesses
-
Insufficient motivation. The choice of quantile graphs is not sufficiently justified, and their advantages over alternative structural representations remain unclear. Especially it is a concern that the information lost in quantile conversion from time series, including the long-term dependency, could cause a lot of negative impact.
-
Limited evaluation. The experiments lack VAE-based baselines, cover relatively few and less common datasets, and do not evaluate the downstream task performance of generated data.
Questions for authors
-
it is a concern that the information lost in quantile conversion from time series, including the long-term dependency, could cause a lot of negative impact. Can you analyze it both qualitatively and using experiments?
-
Downstream task performance.It would be valuable to include a evaluation to assess the downstream task performance of the generated data beyond statistical fidelity.
-
Dataset selection. The evaluation covers only four datasets, some of which are less commonly used in time series generation. I wonder whether the conclusions would hold on more widely adopted datasets as those used in TSFlow or DiffusionTS.
-
VAE-based baselines. Given the VAE-based architecture, I would like to see comparisons with representative VAE-based time series generators, such as TimeVAE [1].
[1] Desai, Abhyuday, et al. "Timevae: A variational auto-encoder for multivariate time series generation." arXiv preprint arXiv:2111.08095 (2021).
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the potential novelty of quantile-graph conditioning and the theoretical interpretation of Graph2TS. We address the concerns below.
Quantile graphs are chosen because they provide a compact, fixed-size representation of empirical temporal transitions in a globally shared amplitude state space. Importantly, the information loss introduced by quantile conversion is intentional rather than an overlooked limitation. As discussed in Section 4.4, Graph2TS follows a structure–residual perspective: the graph captures selected transition characteristics, while the stochastic conditional generator models variations not specified by the graph, including potentially longer-range dependencies. This does not guarantee complete recovery of lost information, but avoids requiring the graph itself to preserve the entire sequence. The existing experiments also provide empirical evidence. Table 3 shows that removing graph conditioning increases ACF error from 0.051 to 0.088 and PSD discrepancy from 0.0059 to 0.0179. Furthermore, Table 5 demonstrates relatively stable performance across quantile resolutions from Q = 5 to 20. These results support the usefulness of the proposed structural representation despite its lossy nature.
Our study focuses on generative fidelity and distributional coverage rather than downstream task augmentation. Accordingly, we evaluate marginal distributions, temporal correlations, spectral characteristics, representativeness, and coverage using nine complementary metrics. These evaluations directly address the stated objective of generating realistic and diverse time series. While downstream task evaluation provides an additional perspective, its results depend on the choice of auxiliary models, tasks, and training configurations, which may limit their representativeness and generalizability. We will consider broader downstream task evaluations in future work.
The four datasets cover distinct temporal characteristics, including physiological signals (ECG and EEG), solar activity (Sunspot), and electricity consumption (Electricity). This diversity allows us to examine how structural conditioning behaves across different signal characteristics. While broader benchmark coverage would further strengthen the generalizability assessment, the current experiments provide evidence of the method’s effectiveness across heterogeneous time-series characteristics.
Although Graph2TS adopts a conditional VAE architecture, its primary contribution lies in structural conditioning rather than the VAE backbone itself. Our evaluation includes representative GAN-, diffusion-, and flow-matching-based generators, particularly TSFlow (ICLR 2025), which represents a more recent generative modeling paradigm than conventional VAE approaches. Furthermore, Table 3 directly isolates the contribution of graph conditioning through a controlled ablation under the same architecture. We believe these comparisons provide meaningful evidence of Graph2TS’s effectiveness against both established and recent generative approaches.
In summary, Graph2TS deliberately uses a lossy structural representation to separate selected transition information from residual stochastic variation. The theoretical formulation, controlled ablations, and evaluation across diverse datasets collectively support this design choice and its effectiveness within the investigated settings.