- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
- The paper deals with training a completion model to recover a fingerprint with partial visibility from phone cameras.
- Their main contribution is to utilize other frames to complete details that are missing in the base (degraded) frame.
- Their method contains three components: (1) predicting the ridge structure first (before pixel reconstruction), (2) phase-free spectral loss which is based on comparing the frequency content instead of the pixels, and (3) attention of additional reference images from the sweep. The experimental section uses two datasets: MMFV and ISPFDv2, and two print matchers.
Critical strengths
- The idea of incorporating additional frames to complete missing details from the degraded frame sounds interesting and promising
- The results at Table 1 shows clear trend of improvement when using SweepFill with varied ‘w’
Critical weaknesses
- I find the paper hard to follow. The authors could simplify phrases and better organizing the sections. Instead, long and complex sentences made the paragraphs hard to understand. See for example, lines 279 - 282: “Because everyMMFV frame shows the whole fingertip, the window is synthetic and the references always contain the hidden region, the favorable end of the sweep setting, and we bound the other end by degrading the references (Table 13, Appendix E), removing them (Table 35, Appendix K.3) and occluding them(Appendix D.1). “. I would clarify the paragraphs and make the paper more readable. Currently the paper is not clear or holistic enough for publication.
- It is not clear why diffusion models based inpainting cannot be the basis for fingerprint reconstruction? One can input the full video sweep to the model and it could be a valid baseline. The authors did explained in Appendix I why there is no diffusion baseline. However, applying diffusion models conditions with additional frames from the sweep can be the right baseline to compared to.
- Important ablations appear very late in the paper’s appendix. For example, a comparison to multi-frames fusion directly. In Table 1 the comparison is only to degrade-probe. I would expect to see such a comparison in the main table.
Questions for authors
- No questions
5 comments
Authors Response (2/3)
Weakness 2
It is not clear why diffusion models based inpainting cannot be the basis for fingerprint reconstruction? …
We trained the prompts of LeftRefill (Cao et al., CVPR 2024), a reference-conditioned diffusion inpainter on frozen Stable Diffusion 2, on our crops with the sweep frames as its references, and ran the video diffusion inpainter DiffuEraser (Li et al., 2025) with 21 sweep frames as input. With 30% of the print visible, SweepFill reaches 79.2% rank-1, against 54.2% for DiffuEraser and 29.2% for LeftRefill, and it also leads both on equal error rate, orientation error and unsupported minutiae. Its rank-1 lead over DiffuEraser is significant over subjects. DiffuEraser with its released weights is not significantly different from SweepFill trained at the equal budget.
All rows
SweepFill at the larger budget leads in every column except missed minutiae. Missed is the share of true hidden minutiae with no generated counterpart, and unsupported the share of generated minutiae there with no true counterpart.
| 30% visible | EER% ↓ | rank-1% ↑ | minutiae EER% ↓ | orientation error° ↓ | missed / unsupported% ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LeftRefill (equal budget), guidance 2.5 | 37.5 | 9.4 | 42.8 | 27.1 | 77.2 / 86.1 |
| LeftRefill (equal budget), guidance 1.0 | 28.1 | 29.2 | 39.7 | 25.2 | 73.3 / 82.2 |
| LeftRefill (1.9× budget), guidance 1.0 | 31.2 | 21.9 | 38.6 | 25.6 | 77.0 / 82.6 |
| DiffuEraser, released weights, 21 frames | 17.7 | 54.2 | 29.0 | 15.7 | 76.7 / 66.0 |
| SweepFill (equal budget), 2 frames | 18.8 | 57.3 | 30.4 | 14.1 | 93.6 / 75.0 |
| SweepFill (larger budget), 2 frames | 11.6 | 79.2 | 23.2 | 10.9 | 78.7 / 54.2 |
DiffuEraser
The published SweepFill raises rank-1 by 25.0 points over DiffuEraser ([+10.4, +38.5], p=0.031) and the true accept rate at a 1% false-accept rate by 18.8 points ([+5.2, +29.2]), with a lower EER (11.6%, jackknife of the difference [-9.3, -2.8]) and orientation error (10.9 against 15.7°, point estimates). At the equal budget DiffuEraser is not significantly different from SweepFill (17.7 against 18.8% EER, jackknife [-5.3, +7.4], rank-1 54.2 against 57.3%, p=0.81). Each probe sits in a 22-frame clip with 21 frames of the other two sweeps of the same session, including the two frames SweepFill uses, only the probe frame is masked, and DiffuEraser leaves the visible window as it is. Of its hidden-region minutiae 66.0% are unsupported, between the two SweepFill models (75.0 and 54.2%).
LeftRefill
LeftRefill does not lower EER (28.1 against 26.0% for the raw probe, 31.2% after 1.9× the budget), its rank-1 is above the raw probe's 21.9% in all four sampling seeds (25.0 to 33.3%, not tested over subjects), and its orientation error is 25.2° against 14.1° for SweepFill at the equal budget. Its unsupported-minutiae rate (82.2%) is above that of SweepFill even with another subject's frames (60.7%). With the authors' guidance of 2.5 it oversaturates its outputs, and guidance 1.0 also scores best on 8 training subjects.
LeftRefill with more visible
Trained for 1.9× the budget, LeftRefill does not lower the raw probe's EER with 50 or 70% visible, and its rank-1 is equal at 50% and higher at 70% (63.5 against 59.4%) (point estimates, no paired test).
| deep matcher | EER% ↓ | rank-1% ↑ |
|---|---|---|
| raw probe, 50% visible | 20.8 | 53.1 |
| LeftRefill 1.9×, 50% visible | 20.8 | 53.1 |
| raw probe, 70% visible | 15.8 | 59.4 |
| LeftRefill 1×, 70% visible | 14.6 | 66.7 |
| LeftRefill 1.9×, 70% visible | 15.8 | 63.5 |
Section 5.2 and Appendix I now report both.
Authors Response (3/3)
Weakness 3
Important ablations appear very late in the paper’s appendix. …
We added this comparison to Table 1 and fused the other frames, degraded like the probe, with the raw probe and with the output of SweepFill. Fusing them with the output of SweepFill gives the lowest EER among the degraded-frame options, 8.3% with 30% of the print visible, against 12.5% for the frames alone and 10.4% for the degraded probe fused with them. Against the frames alone the change holds over subjects, and against the fused raw probe it does not.
Fusion and the other baselines
Fusing the degraded frames with the output of SweepFill gives the lowest EER, and only matching the two clean frames directly is better (Table 35). Deep matcher, 30% of the print visible.
| probe | EER% ↓ | rank-1% ↑ |
|---|---|---|
| degraded probe | 26.0 | 21.9 |
| SweepFill, references switched off at test | 17.6 | 55.2 |
| mosaicking from the two sweep frames | 16.7 | 54.2 |
| two degraded frames alone | 12.5 | 78.1 |
| degraded probe fused with them | 10.4 | 78.1 |
| SweepFill from the degraded frames | 14.4 | 77.1 |
| SweepFill from the degraded frames, fused with them | 8.3 | 80.2 |
| SweepFill with clean references | 11.6 | 79.2 |
| two clean frames matched directly | 6.1 | 93.8 |
Table 1 now lists these rows with the other baselines, and the new Table 2 in Section 5.2 holds the comparison with LaMa and the reference-guided inpainters.
SweepFill leads the diffusion inpainters given the sweep, and Table 1 and the new Table 2 now carry the comparisons the reviewer asked to see in the main text.
Authors Response (1/3)
We thank the reviewer for the concrete suggestions on readability and on the order of the results. Following the reviewer's suggestions, we ran each requested analysis, and all of them are now in the paper. For clarity, the main text now uses shorter sentences and moves the key comparisons into Tables 1 and 2. Below, EER is the equal error rate (lower is better), rank-1 is the share of probes whose top match is the right person, and percentages of the print visible describe the probe.
Weakness 1
We shortened long sentences throughout the main text and moved the key comparisons into the main tables. The main text now uses shorter sentences, and Tables 1 and 2 carry the comparisons a reader needs. The sentence the reviewer quoted now reads "Every MMFV frame shows the whole fingertip, so the window is synthetic and the references always contain the hidden region. This is the favorable case for sweep references. We test less favorable cases by degrading the references (Table 15, Appendix E), removing them (Table 38, Appendix K.3) and occluding them (Appendix D.1)." Table 1 now carries the comparison with multi-frame fusion, and the new Table 2 in Section 5.2 puts LaMa, TransRef, LeftRefill and DiffuEraser on the same inputs as SweepFill, using the extra page allowed during the discussion.