- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The RespFocus paper deals with a weakly supervised respiratory-sound classification framework that uses multiple instance learning (MIL) to learn temporal evidence from respiratory cycle-level labels rather than requiring event-level annotations.
It combines OPERA-CT and AST audio representations, uses shared abnormal-presence evidence to guide separate crackle and wheeze branches, and preserves their differing temporal patterns through crackle max pooling and wheeze top-k pooling. The subtype decisions are then composed into four categories: Normal, Crackles, Wheezes, and Both
The paper also introduces PedResp2026, a multicenter pediatric cohort with 493 recordings from 137 children across seven hospitals, using expert respiratory-cycle labels and patient-disjoint evaluation (i.e. patients used during training, are not used during evaluation)
Critical strengths
-
RespFocus analyzes each annotated respiratory cycle as a MIL bag and learns which temporal tokens within that cycle provide evidence for abnormal sounds - without requiring event-level annotations. Each prediction is accompanied by subtype-specific crackle/wheeze evidence aligned to the original cycle interval. This helps to analyze the decision of the model - as shown in the Figs.
-
RespFocus achieves the highest reported mean four-class classification Score among the compared methods on both benchmarks: 69.55% on ICBHI 2017 and 72.91% on the new PedResp2026 cohort. These results improve over the strongest baselines
Critical weaknesses
-
RespFocus combines two pretrained feature streams, cross-attention of both, separate convolutional subtype branches, different pooling rules, ..., and independently selected thresholds. The ablation demonstrates incremental gains, but it does not fully isolate the contribution of all training objectives and modeling choices. The motivation for the particular design choice/composition of the model architecture is not always clear/supported by ablations (there is Table 2 - but it still lacks a clear motivation why particular stages are useful. Also there are many hyperparameters - not all of them seem to be set via the validation fold. Some ablations might be useful.
-
The final four-class label is obtained by independently thresholding crackle and wheeze probabilities. Threshold pairs are selected through validation grid search, and the Both label is assigned whenever both decisions are positive. This approach is sensitive to calibration and threshold choice and is not optimal
-
The paper argues that RespFocus learns interpretable temporal evidence, but it never evaluates whether the highlighted regions actually coincide with expert-annotated crackle or wheeze events.
Questions for authors
Is the PedResp2026 publicly avaliable?
Does the method work without annotated cycle intervals? Do the comparison methods in Table 1 require the cycle labels?
Adventitious lung sound classification is interesting, but would it be not much more valuable to have disease classification?
Why are the two subtype probabilities combined via thresholding (determined by validation data) to form the final output. Why is this not simply learned? How do the results change if you learn this combination?
What is exactly meant with evidence pathway in Table 2 - is it the refinement?
The optional text interface is entering towards the end of the paper. This is a bit confusing - maybe consider to remove it from the paper.
Remark: There is other work on respiratory disease classification using MIL available (a short version appeared at IEEE EMBC). The aim there is disease classification. It might be worth to mention it. Nguyen, T. T. K., Nguyen, M. D. N., Nguyen, S. V., Tran, T. T. N., Ma, N. T. H., Quach, H. T., Pham, A. L., & Pernkopf, F. (2026). “Lung-Sound Respiratory Disease Classification via Multiple-Instance Learning.” IEEE Access, 14, 41333–41349. DOI: 10.1109/ACCESS.2026.3669914.