- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces CenPrime-MIL, a framework designed to mitigate center-specific shortcut learning in cross-center whole-slide image (WSI) classification. The approach combines fixed center embeddings, dual-path learning, Prime-difference center identification, and class-conditional adversarial regularization to reduce center-related information while preserving pathological discriminative features. The method is evaluated on three datasets (CAMELYON17, CAMELYON16, and Skin-PEAN) using ABMIL, CLAM, and TransMIL. The authors report consistent improvements in classification AUC, alongside improved tumor localization, reduced linear center decodability, and higher performance under staining perturbations. However, no comparison with current SOTA methods is provided.
Critical strengths
One aspect I appreciated is that the authors did not limit their evaluation to a single MIL architecture. The method improves mean AUC across all nine combinations of datasets and backbones, which is encouraging. I also found the patch-level tumor localization experiments valuable, since they provide evidence beyond slide-level classification accuracy. The improvements in localization suggest that the method may help the models focus on more relevant pathological regions.
Critical weaknesses
The role of the Prime-difference mechanism is not entirely convincing. My main concern is related to the PDCIH component. Since the center code is explicitly injected into one of the two paths, I wonder whether predicting the center from the difference between their representations actually encourages the model to separate center-related information, or whether the auxiliary classifier simply learns to recognize the injected code. The ablation results show that PDCIH contributes to classification performance, which is encouraging, but they do not fully explain why it helps. I also think a comparison with a simpler model using only class-conditional adversarial regularization, without the Prime mechanism, would be important to better understand the contribution of the proposed approach.
The comparison with other SOTA methods is absent. This is probably the most important weakness. The proposed method is not compared against other SOTA methods, as the ones discussed in the Introduction.
Questions for authors
-
Regarding the PDCIH objective, since the center code is explicitly injected into the Real-Prime path, how can we be sure that the difference representation captures meaningful center-related information rather than simply encoding the injected center identity? Also, would it be possible to compare the full method with a simpler MIL + CCAR model without the Prime mechanism? I think this would help clarify the actual contribution of the proposed architecture.
-
Some of the reported AUC improvements are relatively small compared with the variability across the five seeds. Could the authors provide additional statistical significance tests to better assess whether these improvements are consistent and reliable?
-
In Figure 3, I noticed that both the baseline and CenPrime-MIL seem to follow a similar decreasing trend as the perturbation strength increases. How can we conclude that CenPrime-MIL is more robust to these changes, rather than simply maintaining the performance gain it already showed in the previous experiments?
-
Why not comparing the proposed method against the other SOTA approaches in cross-center robustness and debiasing in computational pathology, presented in the Introduction ? Is there a major difference or reason ? Please discuss about this point.
2 comments
Promise is not a result...
I thank the authors for their answers but promises cannot replace results. Major experiments, such as MIL + CCAR ablation, or CaMIL/SOTA baselines, are deferred to a future revision, which cannot be seen nor evaluated by the Reviewer. Furthermore, statistical significance tests on the existing 5 seeds required no new model training, yet were still withheld from the rebuttal. I thus maintain my score. I believe that the paper will likely be stronger once these promised experiments and statistical checks are actually executed and verified, but I think that it is not ready for acceptance in its current state.
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the evaluation across MIL architectures and the value of patch-level localization.
Its intended role is to discourage collapse of the auxiliary pathway, maintaining distinguishable offsets while the shared task classifier learns the same pathological label with and without them. CCAR provides the explicit adversarial constraint on center predictability in the bag representation. We will clarify this division of roles and revise wording that implies guaranteed disentanglement.
We will add base MIL plus CCAR with the entire Prime pathway removed. We will also compare difference-based supervision with a code-only auxiliary head receiving the projected code. Together with matched representation probes, these controls will examine whether the interaction between slide features and the injected offset contributes beyond code recognition. 2. Statistical reliability of the gains The current experiments use the same five seeds across methods. Reported means and variability describe these runs but do not directly test the paired improvements.
We will provide individual-run results, paired differences, confidence intervals, and appropriate paired statistical analyses. Patient-level resampling will preserve the grouping of slides from the same patient. We will distinguish test-cohort uncertainty from variability across training runs, specify the meaning of the reported variability, and account for multiple comparisons. Additional training repetitions will be included where needed to improve the assessment of run-to-run variability. These analyses will establish which gains are consistently supported and which remain uncertain. 3. Interpretation of the perturbation experiment The current experiment shows that CenPrime-MIL generally maintains higher absolute AUC across staining perturbations with frozen model weights. This supports persistence of the classification advantage when staining conditions change.
The reviewer correctly distinguishes this from reduced sensitivity to perturbation. Similar declining curves can preserve an initial performance gap without showing a smaller decline. We will therefore additionally report each model's AUC decrease from its own unperturbed level at every perturbation intensity, using matched perturbation realizations and uncertainty estimates. The wording will distinguish higher performance under perturbation from a smaller performance degradation, with the latter claim determined by the additional analysis. 4. Comparisons with related methods The manuscript already includes IBMIL with ABMIL, CLAM, and TransMIL on all three datasets. We will make this comparison clearer and expand the evaluation to include CaMIL and additional relevant methods with reproducible implementations.
Where applicable, comparisons will use matched patch features, data splits, and model-selection procedures. We will state the center labels and target data available to each method. CAMELYON17 includes evaluation on unseen centers, while CAMELYON16 and Skin-PEAN include some target-center training samples. This distinction will be made explicit when interpreting results.
The additional evaluations will assess performance against closely related approaches under comparable conditions. We will also strengthen the methodological discussion so that differences in assumptions and mechanisms are explained independently of the performance ranking.