- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SlideTTT, a slide-specific test-time training framework for whole-slide image analysis. The Slide TTT Layer, which forms the core of SlideTTT, is configured to combine complementary global and local adaptation, where the global branch captures long-range semantic dependencies and the local branch models short-range spatial interactions through convolutional fast weights. In the experiments in the paper, it is reported that the proposed method shows superior results compared with conventional methods.
Critical strengths
As far as its model structure is concerned, SlideTTT presented in this paper is expected to be applicable to data other than WSIs. This point is considered to be a strength from the perspective of the generality of the proposed method.
In addition, a very large number of experimental results are presented, and I was able to sufficiently understand the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Critical weaknesses
Although this study proposes SlideTTT targeting WSIs, doubts remain as to whether it can be said to be a study specialized for tasks targeting WSIs. This is because SlideTTT itself can also be considered a general purpose method and is considered to be applicable to various fields. As mentioned above, this is undoubtedly a strength of this study, but on the other hand, it can also be said that the reason for limiting the target to WSIs in this paper is unclear.
The explanation in Section 3 is confined to content regarding the structure and processing of the model, and it cannot be said that why the proposed method comes to solve the problems that have existed conventionally is clearly described. It is desirable that it be clearly shown whether these model structures were derived heuristically, or whether they were introduced with confidence based on prior knowledge.
Most of the experimental results report the accuracy of the model, but it would have been desirable for it to be made clear what tendencies the accuracy of the model shows with respect to the statistical properties of the target data.
Questions for authors
As described in both the Strengths and the Weaknesses, this study can also be said to be a general purpose study. The reviewer would like the authors to clarify where the reason lies that it must be WSIs. In addition, if it is a general purpose effort that does not need to be specialized for WSIs, The reviewer thinks that the explanation of this paper should originally be written in that way, and that the evaluation also does not need to be limited to WSIs.
In this paper, it is stated that, in order to perform a more rigorous evaluation of cross-center generalization, the smaller cohort was consistently used for model development and the larger cohort for external evaluation. The reviewer would like the authors to show whether the same conclusion can be obtained even when this is reversed.
It is clearly shown that the accuracy of the proposed method is superior to that of conventional methods. On the other hand, the reviewer hopes that it will also be clearly shown, with respect to the tendencies of the data, in what cases superior results are obtained and in what cases difficulties are involved.