- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes HVLR, which unifies eight distinct reasoning forms within the common autoregressive latent interface, to tackle visual reasoning. Its core idea is to render all reasoning forms into the common pixel space and encoding them with the same vision encoder, then use a two-stage distillation procedure to transfer these representations into latent states that can be generated without explicit intermediate supervision at inference time. Experiments on nine benchmarks show that HVLR improves Qwen2.5-VL-7B from 64.66% to 69.97% in average performance, with greater reasoning-form diversity yielding consistent gains and latent reasoning being more efficient than explicit intermediate decoding.
Critical strengths
- The paper identifies an important limitation of existing visual reasoning methods: different intermediate representations are typically modeled through separate reasoning interfaces, making it difficult to combine complementary reasoning signals.
- The proposed framework provides a simple and effective way to unify heterogeneous reasoning signals, while avoiding representation-specific decoders and explicit intermediate reasoning at inference time.
- Experiments demonstrate that HVLR improves Qwen2.5-VL-7B from 64.66% to 69.97% in average performance, while achieving the promising accuracy–efficiency tradeoff.
Critical weaknesses
- The novelty is limited, as the core idea of rendering reasoning content into images and internalizing the resulting representations as autoregressive latent states has already been explored by Render-of-Thought [1]. While HVLR extends this paradigm to eight heterogeneous reasoning forms, the paper neither discusses this closely related work nor clearly establishes the additional technical novelty beyond using broader heterogeneous supervision.
- The comparison with latent-reasoning baselines (e.g., LVR and SkiLa) is not fair. HVLR is trained on the newly curated heterogeneous reasoning data, whereas these competing latent-reasoning baselines directly use their official checkpoints. Therefore, the reported performance gains cannot be attributed solely to the proposed method.
- The modality-diversity experiment does not isolate the effect of reasoning-form diversity. The eight reasoning forms are generally collected from different datasets rather than being alternative representations of the same examples. Therefore, increasing the number of reasoning forms also increases source and task diversity.
[1] Render-of-Thought: Rendering Textual Chain-of-Thought as Images for Visual Latent Reasoning
Questions for authors
- Can the authors retrain some strong latent-reasoning baselines, such as LVR or SkiLa, using the same training setting as HVLR? This comparison is necessary to determine whether the reported gains arise from the proposed method.
- What is the total training cost of HVLR, including both training stages and the offline extraction of teacher targets, and how does it compare with existing latent-reasoning baselines?
- How well does HVLR generalize across VLM architectures beyond the Qwen-VL family?
6 comments
W2 & Q1 (baseline fairness)
W2. The comparison with latent-reasoning baselines (e.g., LVR and SkiLa) is not fair. HVLR is trained on the newly curated heterogeneous reasoning data, whereas these competing latent-reasoning baselines directly use their official checkpoints. Therefore, the reported performance gains cannot be attributed solely to the proposed method.
Q1. Can the authors retrain some strong latent-reasoning baselines, such as LVR or SkiLa, using the same training setting as HVLR? This comparison is necessary to determine whether the reported gains arise from the proposed method.
Response
The paper already includes a data-controlled re-implementation of LVR (Sec. 4.4, Table 4, Finding 3), which separates the effect of the data from that of the method.
We adapted LVR's method (a single teacher-forced stage, a prediction head that predicts each latent slot, and alignment + answer cross-entropy + contrastive losses) and trained it on our corpus:
| Model (7 benchmarks of Table 4) | Training data | Avg. |
|---|---|---|
| LVR-7B (official checkpoint) | LVR's own data (~430K) | 62.41 |
| LVR-style method + our data | 500K examples of our corpus | 67.44 |
| HVLR | 40K examples of our corpus | 69.58 |
- Method effect with the data source held fixed: HVLR beats the LVR recipe by +2.14 while using 12.5× less data from the same corpus.
- Data effect with the recipe held fixed: our data lifts the LVR recipe by +5.03 over its official checkpoint.
Both factors therefore contribute, and we see this as complementary rather than as a weakness. The heterogeneous corpus is part of our contribution, and it can only be exploited through a shared interface: LVR's original pipeline supervises a single form of helper. Further evidence for the method on identical data comes from the stage ablations (Table 5: −1.95 / −1.47) and a new plain-SFT control. We trained plain SFT (image + question → answer, no helper images and no latent slots) on the same 40K data and the same 25 mixtures as Sec. 4.1, and compared each model with the HVLR model trained on the same mixture:
| K | Plain SFT | HVLR | Δ (HVLR − SFT) | HVLR wins (same mixture) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 66.63 | 66.65 | +0.02 | 5 / 8 |
| 3 | 66.83 | 67.67 | +0.83 | 7 / 8 |
| 5 | 66.95 | 68.61 | +1.66 | 8 / 8 |
| 8 | 68.79 | 69.97 | +1.18 | 1 / 1 |
| All 25 mixtures | +0.85 | 21 / 25 (Wilcoxon p = 1.9×10⁻⁴) |
HVLR is better on 21 of 25 paired mixtures (+0.85 on average, Wilcoxon p = 1.9×10⁻⁴) and reaches 69.97 vs. 68.79 on the full 8-form mixture.
SkiLa is designed for interleaved text–sketch reasoning: its training traces interleave textual reasoning steps with latent sketches. 7/8 of our forms provide a helper representation without such an interleaved textual trace, so SkiLa's recipe cannot be applied to our corpus without being redesigned.
W3
The modality-diversity experiment does not isolate the effect of reasoning-form diversity. The eight reasoning forms are generally collected from different datasets rather than being alternative representations of the same examples. Therefore, increasing the number of reasoning forms also increases source and task diversity.
Response
We ran a source-controlled experiment. We selected 10K images from Visual Genome. For every image, we built all four of bbox crop, text CoT, segmentation and depth: each form has a question that depends on it and a newly rendered helper of that form. Every K condition therefore draws from the same image pool, with the same training budget (10K examples per condition) and schedule. Only the number of reasoning forms changes. Since all four forms exist for every image, K ranges from 1 to 4. We report the tier mean over all C(4,K) form subsets.
| K (same images) | Avg. (HVLR) | Δ vs. K=1 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 65.25 | – |
| 2 | 66.18 | +0.93 |
| 3 | 67.33 | +2.08 |
| 4 | 68.41 | +3.16 |
Accuracy still rises monotonically with fixed sources: each added form helps (+0.93, +1.15, +1.08), at about +1.06% per form. If the original trend came mainly from source or task diversity, holding the images fixed should make it smaller. It does not: the total gain from K=1 to K=4 here (+3.16) is similar to that from K=1 to K=8 in Sec. 4.1 (+3.32, 66.65 → 69.97). The two setups differ in data scale, so we compare the direction and rough size of the trend, not exact values.
In addition, we trained plain SFT (image + question → answer, no helper images and no latent slots) on the same 25 mixtures as Sec. 4.1, under the same 40K budget:
| Plain SFT | HVLR (latent) | |
|---|---|---|
| K=1 tier mean (std) | 66.63 (1.18) | 66.65 (1.09) |
| K=3 tier mean (std) | 66.83 (0.45) | 67.67 (0.45) |
| K=5 tier mean (std) | 66.95 (0.20) | 68.61 (0.42) |
| K=8 | 68.79 | 69.97 |
| OLS slope per form | +0.166 ± 0.086 (p = 0.066) | +0.483 ± 0.079 (p = 2.9×10⁻⁶) |
| R² | 14.0% | 62.1% |
| Spearman ρ | 0.17 (p = 0.41) | 0.88 (p = 7.4×10⁻⁹) |
| Jonckheere–Terpstra concordant pairs | 126 / 216 (chance: 108) | 205 / 216 |
| Mann–Whitney, K=5 > K=3 | 36 / 64 pairs | 64 / 64 pairs |
| Benchmarks with positive slope | 8 / 9 | 9 / 9 |
Under plain SFT, the trend is much weaker and not significant (+0.166 vs. +0.483 per form, Spearman ρ = 0.17 vs. 0.88). The Sec. 4.1 trend is therefore not explained by mixing more data sources alone. It requires the shared latent interface.
Because of the rebuttal timeline, the source-controlled study uses 10K images, four forms and one source. In the revision we will extend it to more forms and a second image pool (e.g., Visual CoT images), and add it to Sec. 4.1.
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the motivation and practical value of unifying heterogeneous reasoning representations. We appreciate the suggestion to discuss RoT and clarify our technical contribution. We address this comparison below, together with the concerns about baseline fairness, training cost, and generalization beyond the Qwen family.
W1
Response
We will cite Render-of-Thought (RoT) and add a detailed comparison in the Introduction and Related Work. HVLR differs from RoT in its goal, method and outcome.
Goal: compressing one form vs. unifying many. RoT renders a single form, textual CoT, into images in order to compress text reasoning. It is evaluated only on text-only math benchmarks (trained mainly on GSM8k-Aug-NL and evaluated on GSM8k-Aug, GSM-Hard, SVAMP, MultiArith and MATH).
In HVLR, rendering is a unification device. 7/8 of our forms (crops, highlights, masks, depth, edges, scene graphs, interleaved images) are natively visual or structural and have no textual chain to compress. Our central question is whether heterogeneous forms can share one latent space, and how capability scales with the number of forms (Sec. 4.1). This question cannot be posed in a single-form setting.
Method: a projection-head regression vs. two-stage translation and distillation. RoT attaches a projection head to the LLM. In Stage I, the backbone and vision encoder are frozen and only the projection head is trained, with an MSE alignment loss against the vision-encoder features of the rendered CoT, plus a cross-entropy term on the answer. In Stage II, the vision encoder and projection head are frozen and the LLM is fine-tuned with LoRA using cross-entropy only, with no visual alignment loss. The latents are therefore regressed directly onto the encoder features of the rendered text, and once the LLM itself is trained there is no alignment signal at all. Our Table 5 shows that direct alignment to encoded helper features is suboptimal in the heterogeneous setting: the "w/o distillation" variant, which aligns the student directly to the pooled helper features Z, is 1.95% worse.
HVLR differs in three ways:
Outcome: a large accuracy loss vs. a gain in both accuracy and efficiency. By RoT's own results, its latent reasoning comes at a large accuracy cost relative to explicit CoT: RoT scores below explicit CoT in every cell of its main table. Numbers reported in the RoT paper (Pass@1, %):
RoT decreases 14–27% on the four-benchmark average across three backbones, and up to 43% on GSM8k-Aug, in exchange for 3–4× shorter reasoning.
HVLR shows the opposite pattern. With the same model, data and weights, keeping reasoning in the latent space is more accurate than decoding it as text: forced-latent beats forced-text by 1.16 and 1.24 points, and no explicit-text variant reaches the all-latent model (Sec. 4.2, Table 11). It does so with 8 latent steps instead of ~177 generated tokens.
In short, RoT shows that rendered text can be compressed into latents at a substantial accuracy cost, while HVLR shows that a shared latent space can outperform explicit decoding while unifying eight heterogeneous forms.