- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Stylus, a training-free algorithm specifically designed for facial image stylization. Given an identity reference image and a style reference image, the method generates a stylized facial image that follows the style of the latter while preserving the identity of the former as faithfully as possible. Similar to prior work, Stylus obtains the target image by interpolating between the identity and style references in the latent space. Its key difference is the introduction of additional correction terms after interpolation to further improve the resulting image.
Critical strengths
- Introducing the concept of low-dimensional manifolds into facial stylization is an interesting and potentially insightful idea.
- The experimental evaluation is relatively comprehensive, and most of the paper's claims are supported by empirical evidence.
Critical weaknesses
-
The overall contribution appears somewhat limited. First, the manifold hypothesis has already been extensively explored in the context of diffusion models. Applying it to stylization is a reasonable direction, but it is difficult to regard this extension alone as a major contribution. Second, the core method largely follows the existing paradigm of interpolating between identity and style reference images in the latent space. The main difference is the addition of correction terms after interpolation, which are designed to better align the interpolation process with the manifold hypothesis. The methodological novelty therefore appears limited. Finally, the task is restricted to facial stylization, leaving the generalizability of the proposed insights and method unclear. Moreover, the method does not appear to exploit any face-specific prior, and it is therefore unclear why the authors focus exclusively on faces rather than exploring stylization in a broader domain.
-
Limited quality of some visual results. Some qualitative results are less convincing, particularly for cartoon-style transfer, where the generated images do not appear to match the target style well.
-
Poor presentation. The paper contains several noticeable formatting issues, such as the overlap between Fig. 2 and Table 1. In addition, the Limitations section appears to be incorrectly titled, as it does not actually discuss any limitations. The main text also contains a large number of equations, some of which lack sufficient explanation, making the paper harder to follow. I believe the authors could improve readability by reducing the number of equations and providing clearer explanations for the essential ones. Although presentation quality should not be the primary criterion for evaluating a paper's overall quality, the poor readability and several obvious figure-related errors nevertheless raise concerns about the overall quality of the paper.
Questions for authors
I hope the authors can clarify the paper's core contributions during the rebuttal. If my current understanding does not accurately reflect the intended contributions, and the authors can articulate them more clearly and convincingly, I would be willing to reconsider my score.