- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces StyleForge, a method that transfers a reference style to a few-step text-to-image model without additional training. Training a model for each style can be expensive and can hurt its few-step generation quality. Instead, the paper suggest a method that tries to use the style knowledge already in the model. A vision-language model (VLM) examines the reference images and describes their style. It separates reusable features, such as rendering, color, and lighting, from the objects and scenes in the references. It adds measured color statistics and turns the description into a reusable style prompt. This prompt is combined with new content prompts and given to the (unchanged) generator. The authors compare with methods that learn styles through training and methods that use prompts. They use VLM-based evaluation and CLIP scores, and show visual examples and tests on other generators in the appendix. They report improvements in the balance between matching the style and following the requested content. The main contribution is a VLM pipeline that turns reference images into a detailed style prompt. The prompt is designed to keep the style without copying the reference content. The authors compare it with methods that learn styles through training, methods based on prompts, and methods that use reference images directly. Their visual examples and numerical results aim to show that the prompt captures the style and applies it to different subjects and scenes.
Critical strengths
- Strong visual results. The generated images match the reference styles well compared with the baselines, and apply those styles to different subjects and scenes. Doing this without training for each new style is a clear advantage, especially for few-step generators.
- A thoughtful way to describe style. Visual style is hard to describe fully in words. Still, the authors offer a useful breakdown: rendering, color and lighting, composition, and reference content. They specify which parts to keep, weaken, or leave out when generating new content. This is a sensible approach, and it works well for the styles shown in the paper.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper does not test which parts of the method are needed, or how much it depends on a very strong VLM. The main contribution is the way the style prompt is built. Yet, there are no tests that remove or change its individual parts. These include the color and brightness statistics; the descriptions of where colors appear, how much area they cover, and how they are distributed; the rules for keeping or dropping style information; the prompt order; and the check for copied reference content. I am not convinced that this complicated process is necessary. A single detailed instruction asking the VLM to describe the style, measure colors and brightness, and separate style from content might work just as well. The closest baseline, direct style extraction (DSE), is not described clearly: neither its prompt nor its VLM is given. I assume it uses the same VLM as StyleForge, but this needs clarification. The paper also does not test other VLMs. If the way the prompt is built is what makes the method work, I would expect it to work well with several VLMs.
- The range of tested styles is quite limited. The visual results cover only about a dozen reference sets. Several look similar, and four are dominated by red. The appendix tests the same sets on other generators rather than adding new styles. Almost all the examples have a strong, consistent color palette. The method relies heavily on color statistics and on describing where colors should appear. It also keeps only features shared by the reference images. It is therefore unclear how it handles styles with varying palettes, such as an artist whose colors change but whose style remains recognizable, or real-world references. The paper does not discuss failures or limitations of this kind. Style transfer is a broad and well-studied problem, but the current examples do not show that the method works beyond styles with consistent palettes that suit the method well.
- The paper does not analyze cost or compare with giving the reference images directly to a strong closed-source generator, such as Nano-Banana or GPT Image. The authors explain that the VLM describes the style once, and a lightweight few-step model can then use that description to generate many images. This could be useful. However, extracting and compiling the style also has a token cost. If that cost is higher than simply giving a generator the reference images and a short prompt, the practical advantage is less clear. Overall, I started with doubts that visual style can be fully described in words, and the paper has not resolved those doubts. The results suggest that the method can work well for styles with a distinct, limited color palette. There is little evidence that it works beyond those cases. Even if any style could be described in text, the experiments are not broad enough to convince me that this particular approach is the right way to do style transfer.
Questions for authors
- Please explain the DSE baseline in more detail, including its prompt and the VLM it uses.
- How many tokens does the method use on average?
- How does the method behave as the number of reference images changes? How well does it work with just one reference image?
5 comments
Response to the Reviewer [2/3]
[Weakness 1. Methodological Contribution and Validation Part (2/2)]
- Extraction VLM. We replace GPT-5.5 with GPT-5.6-Sol while retaining the reference images and content prompts, and evaluate both FLUX.2-klein-4B and 9B.
| Extraction VLM | Generator | Qwen3-VL-8B-Instruct Score ↑ | Qwen3-VL-32B-Instruct Score ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|
| GPT-5.5 | 4B | 3.908 | 3.798 |
| GPT-5.6-Sol | 4B | 3.845 | 3.695 |
| GPT-5.5 | 9B | 3.909 | 3.856 |
| GPT-5.6-Sol | 9B | 3.849 | 3.783 |
The two extractors produce close scores, with an average difference around 0.1 points across the reported judges and generators. This supports the applicability of StyleForge with another extraction VLM. Nevertheless, a capable VLM remains important because the quality of the extracted guidance depends on its understanding of visual style. More accurate guidance can better elicit the frozen few-step generator’s existing style-transfer capabilities. We have revised the manuscript to include the alternative extraction VLM experiment and discuss the dependence on extraction quality in Section A.3.10 (Alternative Extraction VLM).
-
Novelty Clarification. In fact, both Detailed DSE and StyleForge activate a frozen few-step generator’s existing style-transfer capabilities through prompts. StyleForge’s competitive results against D-OPSD (NeurIPS 2026) [1] highlight the potentially underestimated value of this route alongside recent post-training approaches. We respectfully hope the reviewer will assess our contribution from this perspective, beyond individual choices in prompt construction.
- [1] Jiang et al., NeurIPS 2026, D-OPSD: On-Policy Self-Distillation for Continuously Tuning Step-Distilled Diffusion Models.
[Weakness 2. Breadth of Style Coverage] Thanks for the thoughtful comment. In fact, our quantitative evaluation covers 30+ styles with 10+ content prompts per style, as detailed in Section 4.1 (Experiment Setup). Due to space constraints, the figures present selected examples from this evaluation. StyleForge also describes line, shape, texture, and brushwork alongside color and lighting. These rendering characteristics can convey shared stylistic traits beyond a fixed palette. We agree that substantial palette variation within a style and diverse real-world references are important tests of broader applicability. Our current results do not fully characterize these settings. We have revised the manuscript to clarify the evaluation scope and discuss the related limitations in Section A.3.12 (Scope and Remaining Limitations).
Response to the Reviewer [3/3]
[Weakness 3. Cost and Practical Applicability] Thank you for the valuable comment.
-
Cost Analysis & Generator Selection. Style preparation averages approximately 15,266 API tokens, including reasoning, and 150 seconds per style. This is a one-time overhead. The resulting prompt is reused across content requests without further extraction calls, amortizing the overhead over repeated generation. Following the evaluation practice of prior adaptation studies [1, 2], we use open-weight few-step generators to enable controlled comparisons between eliciting existing capabilities and per-style post-training. We have revised the manuscript to include the preparation cost and prompt reuse analysis in Section A.3.11 (Preparation Cost and Reuse).
- [1] Jiang et al., NeurIPS 2026, D-OPSD: On-Policy Self-Distillation for Continuously Tuning Step-Distilled Diffusion Models.
- [2] Miao et al., ICLR 2025, Tuning Timestep-Distilled Diffusion Model Using Pairwise Sample Optimization.
-
Reference-Guided Generation. Our RCG baseline, described in Appendix A.1.1 (Detailed Baseline Descriptions), tests reference images plus a short instruction on the same FLUX.2-Klein backbone. It scores below StyleForge (Table 2). It can miss distinctive rendering cues (Figure 3, row 1), replace monochrome rendering with warm colors (Figure 7, row 4), or introduce unrequested figures (Figure 6, row 1). These cases suggest that a short instruction may not adequately specify which rendering traits to preserve and which reference content to exclude.
-
Textual Representation of Style. We appreciate the concern about how faithfully visual style can be conveyed through language. Figure 1 illustrates how textual instructions bind blue and yellow to the robot’s body and scarf, respectively, and guide predominantly cyan liquid above a thin magenta layer. These color relationships and relative proportions are important aspects of visual style. Together with our transfer results, they support the potential of textual guidance to draw on the generator’s existing visual knowledge. We also acknowledge that subtle texture or brushwork relationships may remain difficult to describe or faithfully realize. Improving fidelity in these challenging cases remains a direction for future work. We have revised the manuscript to discuss the limitations of expressing and reproducing subtle texture and brushwork relationships in Section A.3.12 (Scope and Remaining Limitations).
-
The Point We Hope to Convey. More importantly, StyleForge demonstrates the potential of eliciting a frozen few-step generator’s existing style-transfer capabilities through prompts alone. Our comparison with D-OPSD (NeurIPS 2026) suggests that the potential of this route may be substantially underestimated relative to recent post-training approaches. We respectfully hope the reviewer will give due weight to this central insight, beyond the finer details of prompt engineering.
[Question 1. Baseline Specification] Thanks for the helpful question. Please see our response to Weakness 1.
[Question 2. Token Consumption] Thanks for the valuable question. Please see our response to Weakness 3.
[Question 3. Number of Reference Images] Thanks for the insightful question. We evaluate one- and two-reference settings with FLUX.2-klein-4B and include the original paper results using four reference images for comparison.
| Reference images | Qwen3-VL-8B-Instruct Score ↑ | Qwen3-VL-32B-Instruct Score ↑ |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 3.849 | 3.685 |
| 2 | 3.874 | 3.745 |
| 4 | 3.908 | 3.798 |
StyleForge remains effective with just one reference image. These results suggest that additional references can improve style-transfer quality, although the gains are relatively modest. We have revised the manuscript to include the reference-count study in Section A.3.8 (Number of Reference Images).
Response to the Reviewer [1/3]
We thank the reviewer for the positive comments on the strong visual results across different subjects and scenes, on the thoughtful way of describing style, and on the useful breakdown of which parts to keep, weaken, or leave out. Our point-by-point responses to the weaknesses and questions are as follows.
[Weakness 1. Methodological Contribution and Validation Part (1/2)] Thanks for the helpful comment. We clarify the DSE baseline and examine component contributions, the detailed-prompt alternative, and the choice of extraction VLM below.
These results support the contribution of each examined component to StyleForge’s generation quality. To complement the Scores, we use GPT-6.1 Sol as a proxy evaluator to summarize visual comparisons between StyleForge and its ablated variants.
We have revised the manuscript to include the component ablation results and analysis in Section 4.2.3 (Ablation Analysis).
GPT-6-Sol assesses individual content constraints, requested framing, satisfaction of all core content requirements, unrequested dominant objects, and overall preference considering both content preservation and style fidelity.
We have revised the manuscript to include the DSE extraction prompts and the Detailed DSE comparison and analysis in Section A.3.9 (Detailed Direct Style Extraction).