- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
GASC proposes a style transfer framework based on the Diffusion-Mamba model. The motivation is that the global and local styles from a reference image should be injected into the model through different conditioning interfaces. Accordingly, the authors designed several modules to inject the global and local styles into the and B parameters of the Mamba architecture, respectively, while preserving the image structure.
Critical strengths
GASC makes reasonable assumptions based on the various functions of the SSM interface and conducts a 2×2 granularity allocation study along with a single-route ablation. This approach achieves the best performance among the methods compared across the metrics, thereby demonstrating its effectiveness.
Critical weaknesses
- Although GASC proposes a sound and effective approach, its core technical concepts overlap with existing work. Its innovation lies primarily in the integration and refinement of prior methods.
- The authors have thoroughly validated the effectiveness of their proposed design through 2×2 granularity allocation, single-route ablation, and visual comparisons. However, these experiments primarily focus on the final generation quality and do not explicitly analyze how and B individually influence global style versus local texture.
Questions for authors
- It would further strengthen the persuasiveness of the proposed granularity interface alignment hypothesis if the authors could provide more analysis of how conditioning and B affects global stylistic details respectively.
- It would be interesting to compare the proposed group-level carrier retrieval with standard token-level retrieval to better understand the benefits of grouping.
- In the implementation details, the group queries are computed by sum pooling rather than mean pooling. So the magnitude of the queries will be changed accordingly. It would be helpful to clarify the motivation behind this design choice.
- Although aims to avoid relying on predefined spatial correspondence, the final carrier fusion incorporates spatially aligned raw reference features. It would be helpful to clarify the motivation behind this design and how it affects style transfer when the content and reference images have different spatial layouts.
I thank the authors for their detailed rebuttal and additional experiments.
Regarding W2, Q1, Q2, and Q3, the authors have addressed my concerns through supplementary experiments and explanations.
My remaining concerns are primarily related to novelty and spatial correspondence. Regarding novelty, although the authors have further clarified the distinctions between GASC and existing methods, I still believe that the contribution primarily lies in the effective integration and refinement of existing techniques. Regarding spatial correspondence, while the authors provide a reasonable justification for incorporating raw reference features and a dynamic gate, the potential impact of spatially aligned raw reference features when content and reference images have different spatial layouts has not been directly evaluated.
Overall, the rebuttal has addressed most of my concerns. I have decided to maintain my original rating of Weak Acceptance. I also encourage the author to upload a revised manuscript before the end of the rebuttal period.