acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

GR-GS: Geometric Regularization 3D Gaussian Splatting Segmentation

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Recent advances in 3D Gaussian Splatting (3DGS) have achieved remarkable success in real-time scene rendering. However, interactive 3DGS scene segmentation remains challenging. Current MLLM-based agents often treat spatial grounding as a black box, propagating multi-instance ambiguities into the 3D domain where an absence of structural constraints allows boundary Gaussians to erroneously elongate along viewing rays. In this paper, we introduce GR-GS, a unified framework that tightly couples explicit topological reasoning with physical covariance regularization to achieve high-fidelity 3D segmentation. Rather than relying on unstable multi-view voting to resolve semantic ambiguities, our framework introduces an LLM-Driven Relational Extraction (LDRE) module that enforces rigorous, pre-lifting topological constraints, isolating the exact target directly in 2D before spatial corruption can occur. To ensure these precise semantic boundaries are preserved during 3D optimization, we propose a Ray-Aligned Covariance Penalty (RACP). Instead of generic regularization, RACP leverages cross-view Jacobian projection to artificially inflate the screen footprint of ill-posed, elongated Gaussians. This forced boundary spillover triggers steep positional gradients that reactivate the splitting mechanism, organically compressing artifacts without additional parameters. Extensive experiments demonstrate that GR-GS achieves state-of-the-art results on NVOS and LERF-OVS. By treating semantic grounding and geometric fidelity as a coupled optimization problem, our method delivers superior relational reasoning and flawlessly delineated object boundaries.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
3D Gaussian Splatting, LLM, segmentation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_oa8tOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper combines language-based relational grounding, confidence/area-based mask filtering, and a ray-aligned covariance modification for text-guided 3D Gaussian segmentation.

Critical strengths
  • The paper proposes LDRE to improve the grounding results and RACP to improve accurate object boundaries.
  • The paper reports improved segmentation and boundary metrics on NVOS, LERF-OVS and ScanNet
Critical weaknesses
  • The adopted 2D-to-3D optimization lifting pipeline has been widely explored in many existing works, limiting the overall contributions.
  • The LLM-Driven Relational Extraction (LDRE) module part seems to directly combine the existing external model, limiting the technique's contribution.
  • It will be helpful to add more recent works[1,2] to conduct the comparisons.

[1] Cos3d: Collaborative open-vocabulary 3d segmentation. NeurIPS 2025.
[2] Uni3R: Unified 3D Reconstruction and Semantic Understanding via Generalizable Gaussian Splatting from Unposed Multi-View Images. CVPR 2026.
[3] Dr. Splat: Directly Referring 3D Gaussian Splatting via Direct Language Embedding Registration. CVPR 2025.

Questions for authors

Please refer to the weakness.

Reviewer_MitqOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes GR-GS to address two issues that it identified in interactive 3D scene segmentation. Given multi-view image and a text query, first, MLLM-agent methods e.g. REALM ground queries per view without structure, being prone to multi-instance ambiguity and therefore requiring a costly multi-view ID voting. This paper proposes LLM-Driven Relational Extraction module, combining LLM and GroundingDINO to extract the target in 2D. SAM2 produces multi-view masks, which is further processed by robust mask filtering. Second, when 2D masks are lifted to 3D, boundary Gaussians stretch along the ray which appears as spikes crossing the boundary in novel view segmentation. The paper proposes a Ray-Aligned Covariance Penalty (RACP) module to regularize the geometry. Experiments on NVOS, LERF-OVS and ScanNet report gains over REALM in terms of mAcc, mIoU and B-mIoU metrics.

Critical strengths

The experimental evaluation is broad in scope. The method is compared against many baselines covering both language-basedmethods (e.g., LangSplat, LangScene-X) and mask-guided optimization methods (e.g., SAGA, COB-GS, REALM), on three datasets (NVOS, LERF-OVS, ScanNet) and under both implicit and explicit prompts, together with a component ablation and a runtime comparison. This gives a comprehensive picture of how the method relates to both families of approaches. The broad evaluation would be more valuable if the evaluation settings were clearly described and the inconsistencies in the baseline numbers (W1, Q3) were addressed.

Critical weaknesses

Weakness 1: My major concern is that the presentation is unpolished and makes the method difficult to understand and verify. For example, whether a pretrained 3DGS is used, and the RACP is for fine-tuning it, are not clear stated in the paper. The manuscript also contains numerous typos and inconsistencies, e.g. garbled figure text (“Covariance Penlty”, Fig. 1; “Aligan Boundary”, Fig. 2), “LanScene-X” for LangScene-X throughout, “explicit nom prompts” and “NOVS” in the supplementary tables, inconsistent publication years for baselines (e.g., SA3D-GS listed as both 2023 and 2024). Reported results are also confusing. For example, implicit reasoning prompts that are given by Qwen2.5-VL, should in general be more difficult to query than the explicit noun prompts. Methods like LangSplat are distilling CLIP features into 3DGS, which should respond better to explicit noun (which the CLIP is trained on image-text captions) than reasoning. However, main paper Table 3 reports mIoU 20.5 for implicit reasoning but the explicit results are 15.3 in appendix Table 3.

Weakness 2: Another major concern is that, the proposed pipeline appears unsuitable for interactive segmentation. From the paper, the impression is that the whole 3DGS are fine-tuned after query-dependent view filtering. Which means that each new incoming query requires running the LLM, Grounding DINO, SAM2 and 3DGS optimization. The 11 minutes according to Table 4 looks like cost for a single query, which is far from interactive. By comparison, methods like SAGA can respond in milliseconds, latest open-vocabulary methods also can perform query in almost real-time. In addition, if the same scene are modified with different geometry for different queries, the methods might be difficult to be applied for downstream applications.

Questions for authors

Q1 (W2). Please clarify the training pipeline and its cost. (a) Is a pretrained 3DGS fine-tuned, or is the scene reconstructed from scratch on V_train? If fine-tuned, which parameters are updated, and is densification re-enabled? (b) Is a separate optimization run for every new query? If so, does the same scene end up with different geometry for different queries? (c) Is the 11-minute training time in Table 4 per query or per scene, and does it include the LLM, Grounding DINO and SAM-2 propagation? (d) What exactly does the 0.9 s inference time measure: rendering one view, or answering a new query?

Q2 (W1). REALM, the main baseline, reports results on LERF, 3D-OVS and REALM3D. Why does the paper evaluate on NVOS, LERF-OVS and ScanNet instead, rather than comparing on REALM’s benchmarks under its protocol?

Q3 (W1). How were the baseline numbers obtained (re-run or copied, and with which prompts and masks)? In particular, how were point-prompt-based methods such as SAGA evaluated with implicit text queries? REALM reports 92.88 mIoU on LERF with implicit queries, compared with 80.2 here; what differs in the evaluation setting? Finally, why do several methods score higher with implicit prompts than with explicit ones (see W1)?

Reviewer_8RnQOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents GR-GS, a text-guided 3D Gaussian Splatting segmentation method that couples 2D semantic reasoning with a 3D geometric regularizer. The framework has three parts. The first is an LLM-driven relational extraction stage: a large model first breaks a free-form query into a structured tuple of target object, spatial relation, and contextual anchor, then uses Grounding DINO with relative center offsets to localize the unique target instance in 2D, lifts it to 3D, and hands the mask off to SAM-2 for propagation across views. The second part is robust mask filtering, which uses mask area ratio and SAM-2 confidence as a double gate to keep only reliable views for training. The third part is the ray-aligned covariance penalty, which adds a rank-1 PSD term to the covariance of boundary Gaussians, gated by Sobel edge magnitude. The authors claim this term is invisible in the source view because the view direction lies in the null space of the projection Jacobian, but produces a positive-definite footprint inflation from other viewpoints, which amplifies spillover gradients and reactivates the native 3DGS split-and-prune mechanism. The method is evaluated on NVOS, LERF-OVS, and ScanNet, reporting state-of-the-art results, with the largest gains on implicit relational queries.

Critical strengths
  1. The central geometric observation behind RACP is non-trivial and well-motivated. Exploiting the null-space structure of the projection Jacobian in the source view while projecting to a non-trivial vector from other viewpoints is a more targeted approach than generic isotropic covariance regularization, and to my knowledge this specific cross-view Jacobian duality has not been used for boundary Gaussian regularization in prior work.

  2. The pipeline is internally consistent. The three modules address distinct failure modes, namely semantic ambiguity, unreliable views, and geometric degradation, and the derivation chain from Eq. (7) through Eq. (12) connects covariance injection, cross-view footprint inflation, position-gradient amplification, and the densification threshold in a coherent manner.

  3. The experimental evaluation is reasonably comprehensive. It covers three standard benchmarks spanning both implicit relational reasoning and explicit noun prompts, with clear improvements over recent strong baselines including REALM, NG-GS, and COB-GS. Component-wise ablations in Table 6 cover all three modules, and a computational efficiency comparison is provided in Table 4.

  4. The method builds on top of standard 3DGS without introducing new learnable parameters. The idea of coupling a geometric regularizer to the native densification mechanism is potentially transferable to other Gaussian-based representations.

Critical weaknesses

1.The paper's framing is inconsistent with its own ablation. The title and abstract position RACP as the core contribution, yet Table 6 shows that removing RACP costs only 1.3 B-mIoU points on NVOS, while removing LDRE costs 17.6 points and removing RMF costs 7.1 points. On explicit noun prompts, where LDRE's relational reasoning is not needed, the margin over REALM shrinks to 1–3 points. The paper does not explain this gap, and a reader cannot tell whether the main contribution is the geometric insight or the LLM-driven pipeline.

2.The core intuition anisotropic boundary Gaussians overflow and should be split/compressed along the responsible axis is already explored in VCAR, COB-GS, and GradiSeg. RACP's contribution is the specific implementation, but the high-level idea of boundary Gaussian splitting for sharp segmentation is not new.

3.The paper lacks comparison to prior covariance-regularization work. Existing methods such as Effective Rank Regularization and Micro-Splatting already address needle-like and over-anisotropic Gaussians, and the latter also uses regularization to trigger splitting. Without a simple baseline such as an isotropic trace penalty or effective-rank penalty, it is unclear whether RACP's view-aligned, boundary-gated design is necessary, or whether a simpler regularizer would achieve comparable boundary quality.

4.Sensitivity to inter-view baseline distance is not analyzed. The cross-view term vanishes as the view angle approaches zero, since the projected vector becomes arbitrarily small for adjacent views. Because 3DGS training samples views randomly, the effective strength of RACP depends on the camera sampling schedule, which the paper does not discuss, nor does it report performance variation with cross-view angle.

5.The reported training time excludes the LDRE preprocessing stage. Table 4 lists 11 minutes of per-scene training, but this covers only the 3DGS optimization and rendering. The LDRE pipeline, including LLM parsing, Grounding DINO inference, and SAM-2 mask propagation, is neither included nor reported separately. The fact that 11 minutes is nearly identical to REALM's 10 minutes despite three additional modules suggests the LDRE cost was omitted; the paper should report full end-to-end per-scene time with deployment and hardware details.

Questions for authors

Some minor questions:

  1. The title is missing a preposition: "Geometric Regularization for 3D Gaussian Splatting Segmentation" would be grammatically correct.

  2. The term Ray-Aligned is imprecise: the vector points from the Gaussian toward the camera, whereas in graphics convention the ray direction points from the camera into the scene, so the two are opposite.

  3. Several claims are overstated relative to the evidence: "flawlessly delineated object boundaries", "strictly guarantees a positive-definite gradient update", and "artificially inflate" carry more force than the approximate derivation and 1 to 3 point gains support.

  4. The caption of Figure 1 largely repeats the motivation given in the introduction and could be trimmed.

  5. RMF uses fixed thresholds, thin, small, or low-confidence objects such as handles or transparent items may be systematically filtered out, and the paper should acknowledge this failure mode or report sensitivity to these thresholds.

  6. The LDRE relation logic uses hard-coded center-offset and depth heuristics for relations such as beside, which are view-dependent and can reverse under camera rotation; a brief discussion of this limitation would strengthen the paper.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.