- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents ScalePlace, a visual relocalization framework that builds upon the Gaussian feature field-based sparse initialization and dense refinement pipeline introduced by STDLoc (Huang et al., 2025). Its main contribution is a multi-resolution supervision strategy for a shared Gaussian feature field, incorporating RGB and SuperPoint feature targets at multiple rendering resolutions to encourage scale-consistent scene descriptors.
The method achieves average translation/rotation errors of 0.63 cm/0.19° on 7-Scenes and 8 cm/0.12° on Cambridge Landmarks, outperforming STDLoc on both benchmarks. Ablation studies on Chess and King’s College further show approximately 13% lower translation errors with three-scale supervision compared to native-resolution training alone, providing empirical support for the proposed multi-resolution strategy.
Critical strengths
- Multi-resolution supervision. The method extends STDLoc’s single-scale training by supervising a shared Gaussian feature field at multiple rendering resolutions, providing a straightforward approach to encouraging cross-scale feature consistency.
- Strong localization accuracy. The reported results show consistent improvements over STDLoc on both benchmarks, achieving the lowest errors across all 7-Scenes scenes and the best average accuracy among the compared NeRF/GS-based methods on Cambridge Landmarks.
- Detailed ablation studies. The ablation studies provide useful insights into the effectiveness of the proposed supervision strategy, with three-scale training achieving the lowest localization errors on both Chess and King’s College.
Critical weaknesses
-
The novelty of the proposed method seems somewhat limited. Several key components, including matching-oriented landmark sampling, coarse-to-fine refinement, and localization without retrieval or pose priors, have already been explored in STDLoc. The main difference appears to be the multi-resolution feature-field supervision (MRFS), and the authors should clarify the contribution accordingly.
-
The motivation for multi-scale supervision is not sufficiently supported by the experiments. While the ablation results show accuracy improvements, it remains unclear how single-scale training affects localization under scale changes. It would be helpful to analyze feature consistency, matching inlier rates, or localization errors at different scales.
-
The scale robustness of the proposed method needs further investigation. Since the supervision targets are obtained by resizing a single SuperPoint feature map, it is unclear whether the improvements can generalize to scale changes caused by different camera viewpoints. Comparisons with standard image-resizing augmentation or controlled scale-change experiments would be useful.
-
The ablation studies on training scales are only conducted on Chess and King's College. It would be better to include more scenes to verify whether the improvements are consistent across different datasets. Repeated experiments could also help assess the reliability of the reported gains.
-
Given the similarity between the proposed pipeline and STDLoc, it is difficult to isolate the contribution of MRFS from the current comparisons. A more direct experiment would be to introduce MRFS into the original STDLoc pipeline while keeping the other settings unchanged.
-
The additional training cost of MRFS is not discussed. Since the method requires rendering and supervision at multiple resolutions, it would be useful to report the training time and GPU memory usage. A comparison with a single-scale baseline under a similar training budget would also help assess the trade-off between accuracy and computational cost.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors quantify the gain from adding MRFS alone to STDLoc under otherwise identical settings? This would help isolate the contribution of the proposed supervision strategy.
- Does MRFS remain beneficial under controlled changes in query scale or camera distance, and how does it compare with standard image-resizing augmentation?
- Could the authors report the mapping time, final map storage size, and per-query localization latency, preferably with a direct comparison to STDLoc under the same hardware and evaluation settings?
- It would be helpful if the authors could use author–year citations consistently throughout the manuscript, distinguishing between narrative citations (e.g., “Smith et al. (2024) propose …”) and parenthetical citations (e.g., “… (Smith et al., 2024)”).