- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies the normalization space used for Gaussian attribute prediction in feed-forward 3D Gaussian Splatting. The authors argue that radial distance normalization does not canonicalize the spacing between Gaussian centers, which can make appropriate Gaussian scales vary across camera configurations and scenes. They propose Gaussian Spacing Normalization (GSNorm), using the median of depth divided by the geometric mean of the pixel-space focal lengths as a scene-level normalization factor. The reported results show broad improvements in perceptual quality, supported by normalization and training-design ablations.
Critical strengths
-
A useful perspective on normalization for Gaussian prediction. The paper revisits the common practice of predicting Gaussian attributes in the normalized coordinate space inherited from a geometry backbone. Its observation that canonicalizing radial distance does not necessarily canonicalize Gaussian spacing is relevant to feed-forward Gaussian prediction. Since appropriate Gaussian scales depend on the spacing between their centers, using a spacing-based normalization statistic provides an intuitive, geometrically motivated alternative.
-
Broad empirical evaluation and informative visualizations. The evaluation covers seven datasets, both pose-free and pose-conditioned settings, and varying numbers of input views. The normalization and training ablations provide useful evidence for the effectiveness of the proposed system, while qualitative comparisons across different scene configurations help illustrate the practical effects of the normalization choice.
Critical weaknesses
- The role of physical scene scale requires a more precise explanation. The paper places considerable emphasis on generalization across scene scales, but absolute physical size alone cannot explain variations in Gaussian spacing after RDNorm. If scene geometry and camera translations are jointly scaled by the same factor, while camera intrinsics and image sampling remain unchanged, both local spacing and the radial-distance normalization factor scale proportionally. The normalized spacing therefore remains unchanged. Although the paper also discusses camera configurations, it does not clearly distinguish the effect of physical scene size from correlated factors such as camera placement and viewing distance. An operational definition of scene scale and a clearer account of these relationships would make the motivation more precise and clarify when GSNorm should be most beneficial.
Questions for authors
-
Which scene and camera properties determine the limitations of RDNorm? Please clarify what "scene scale" means operationally and how it relates to normalized Gaussian spacing, given the invariance to joint scaling of scene geometry and camera translations described above. More specifically, which measurable properties of the scene or capture configuration predict when RDNorm becomes inadequate and when GSNorm offers the greatest benefit? A more explicit characterization would strengthen the paper's contribution beyond demonstrating that an alternative normalization works well.
-
Can a focused controlled analysis better distinguish the sources of the improvement? A useful complement to the existing experiments would be a within-scene comparison that varies camera trajectory extent or the spatial distribution of observations, while controlling other settings where feasible. For example, uniformly distributed observations could be compared with observations concentrated in a subset of scene regions. Reporting both normalized spacing statistics and rendering performance would help connect the proposed explanation to the observed gains. A median radial-distance baseline would also help distinguish the benefit of normalizing a different geometric quantity from that of replacing the mean with a more robust statistic. These targeted comparisons would address my concern more directly than additional evaluations across scene categories.
Office Comment by Reviewer
Thanks for the rebuttal. My concerns have been addressed. I will raise my score to weak acceptance.